Attraction effect of different colored cards on thrips Frankliniella intonsa in cowpea greenhouses in China

Liangang Mao, Yiming Chang, Fulai Yang, Lan Zhang, Yanning Zhang, Hongyun JiangScientific 2018 · DOI

Abstract

The flower thrips Frankliniella intonsa (Trybom) is a major pest in Chinese cowpea greenhouses. Due to increasing pesticide resistance, non-chemical management strategies like sticky traps are essential. This study evaluated the color preference of F. intonsa across 13 colors, as well as the impact of trap height and orientation. Results from two commercial greenhouse trials demonstrated that white cards are significantly more attractive to F. intonsa than the industry-standard blue cards. Optimal trapping was achieved when white or deep sky blue cards were placed low to the ground (0 cm). These findings suggest that white sticky traps should be the primary tool for monitoring and controlling F. intonsa in cowpea IPM programs.

Introduction

In cowpea (Chinese long bean) production, Frankliniella intonsa causes significant economic loss through direct feeding and the transmission of plant viruses. To align with China’s "Action to Achieve Zero Growth of Pesticide Use," researchers are prioritizing integrated pest management (IPM) tools. While blue sticky traps are widely recommended for thrips generally, previous research on F. intonsa has been inconsistent. This study aims to definitively identify the optimal trap parameters—color, height, and orientation—for this specific pest within the unique environment of a cowpea greenhouse.

Methods

Two trials were conducted in commercial greenhouses in Beijing. Researchers tested 13 standardized colors (defined by specific RGB values) including white, pink, pale green, light yellow, powder blue, crimson, yellow green, deep sky blue, dark slate blue, dark orange, medium orchid, gold, and black, with clear plastic as a control.

Variables tested included:

  • Placement Height: 0 cm, 80 cm, and 160 cm.
  • Orientation: North, South, East, and West.
  • Temporal Tracking: Counts were taken at 2, 4, and 6 hours post-placement.

Data were analyzed using ANOVA and Fisher’s LSD tests ($P < 0.05$) to ensure statistical significance.

Results

Color Preference

Contrary to the general preference for blue seen in many thrips species, F. intonsa showed a robust and statistically significant preference for white cards. In Trial II, white cards captured an average of 474 thrips per card, vastly outperforming deep sky blue, which captured approximately 161 thrips.

Figure 6: Thrips attraction by color in Trial II at 4 hours, showing the clear dominance of white cards.

In Trial I, the trend remained consistent, with white cards maintaining the highest attraction levels throughout the 6-hour observation period.

Figure 4: Thrips attraction by color in Trial I at 6 hours, confirming white as the most effective attractant.

Height and Orientation

Traps placed at ground level (0 cm) were significantly more effective than those at 80 cm or 160 cm. This is likely due to the biological behavior of F. intonsa, which may descend to the soil for pupation or to seek refuge from intense light. While cardinal orientation (e.g., South-facing) showed some initial influence, its effect was less consistent over time compared to color and height.

Discussion and Conclusion

The study highlights that color preference is habitat-specific. While blue is often the standard, the cowpea greenhouse environment clearly favors white for F. intonsa management.

Future work should investigate the potential for "bycatch"—ensuring white traps do not inadvertently remove beneficial predatory insects. Additionally, combining these optimized white traps with aggregation pheromones could further increase their efficacy as a mass-trapping tool. For now, growers are encouraged to utilize white sticky traps placed at ground level for the most effective monitoring and control of flower thrips.

Summary updated

Abstract

The flower thrips Frankliniella intonsa (Trybom) is one of the most economically important pests in cowpea greenhouses in China. Widespread pesticide resistance of thrips and the negative environmental effects limit the application of pesticides for thrips control. Two commercial cowpea greenhouse experiments were designed to determine the color preference of F. intonsa to colored cards, including white, pink, pale green, light yellow, powder blue, crimson, yellow green, deep sky blue, dark slate blue, dark orange, medium orchid, gold, and black. Clear pieces of plastic were used as the control cards. Additionally, the effects of placement height and orientation (cardinal direction) of the cards were also studied. Both greenhouse trials showed that white cards were significantly more attractive to F. intonsa than the other 13 card colors, followed by deep sky blue cards. White or deep sky blue cards placed low to the ground were found to be most attractive to F. intonsa. Orientation of the colored cards also affected the attractiveness to F. intonsa. The results indicate that white sticky cards were significantly more attractive to F. intonsa than blue cards and therefore can be recommended to monitor F. intonsa population densities and to control them in cowpea greenhouses as part of integrated pest management programs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2018attraction,
  author = {Liangang Mao and Yiming Chang and Fulai Yang and Lan Zhang and Yanning Zhang and Hongyun Jiang},
  title = {{Attraction effect of different colored cards on thrips Frankliniella intonsa in cowpea greenhouses in China}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-32035-8},
}
Figure