Open field trials of food-grade gum in California and Oregon as a behavioral control for Drosophila suzukii Matsumura (Diptera: Drosophilidae)

Gabriella Tait, Tingyu Zhu, Jimmy Klick, Fatemeh Ganjisaffar, Claira Castillo, Ryan David Kennedy, Hillary Thomas, Christopher G. Adams, Ferdinand Pfab, Serhan Mermer, Enrico Mirandola, Lan Xue, Frank G. Zalom, Michael P. Seagraves, Vaughn M. WaltonFrontiers in Insect Science 2023 · DOI

Introduction

The invasive spotted-wing drosophila (Drosophila suzukii, or SWD) has become a primary threat to berry and cherry industries across Europe and the United States since its introduction in 2008. Unlike typical fruit flies, SWD targets healthy, ripening fruit, leading to significant economic losses. Currently, management relies heavily on frequent applications of conventional insecticides—a "pesticide treadmill" that is increasingly unsustainable due to chemical resistance and impacts on non-target species. This study evaluates a novel, non-toxic behavioral control method: a food-grade gum (GUM) designed to disrupt the pest's reproductive cycle.

The "Egg Sink" Mechanism

The proposed solution utilizes a "behavioral sink" strategy. Deployed on dispenser pads, the food-grade gum mimics the olfactory and tactile cues of high-quality fruit. The mechanism works in two stages:

  1. Attraction: Volatile scents lure SWD away from the ripening crop.
  2. Egg Deposition: The flies are tricked into laying eggs in the gel-like gum. Because the gum cannot support larval development, the eggs fail to hatch, effectively removing those individuals from the future population.

Experimental Design and Field Trials

Researchers conducted open-field and screenhouse trials across nine locations in California and Oregon during the 2019 and 2020 growing seasons. The study covered five commercial crops: cherry, wine grape (Pinot noir), blueberry, raspberry, and blackberry.

The trials compared three conditions:

  • Untreated Control (UTC): No pest management applied.
  • GUM Treatment: Dispenser pads placed at a rate of 124 per hectare.
  • Buffer Plots: Intermediate zones used to assess the active range of the gum's attractants.

Results: Significant Reductions in Damage

The majority of trials demonstrated that the GUM treatment significantly reduced egg-laying in susceptible fruit. In the most successful instances, fruit damage was reduced by up to 78%. A meta-analysis of ten independent trials confirmed highly significant differences (p < 0.001) between GUM-treated plots and untreated controls.

Efficacy of GUM treatment in wine grapes over 11 days, showing reductions in egg counts and infestation rates compared to untreated controls (UTC).

The treatment was particularly effective in wine grapes and blueberries. As shown in the field data for grapes (Figure 5), the GUM treatment (orange line) consistently resulted in lower mean egg counts and infestation rates compared to the untreated control (blue line) as the trial progressed.

Synergy with Integrated Pest Management (IPM)

One of the study's most critical findings came from population modeling simulations. While the GUM treatment alone reduced populations by approximately 79%, and organic-compliant insecticides (like Spinosad) alone reduced them by 91%, the combination of both methods resulted in a 98% reduction. This suggests that GUM acts as a powerful synergistic tool, lowering pest pressure and making traditional interventions more effective.

Challenges and Future Directions

Despite the promising results, several environmental and logistical factors influenced performance:

  • Environmental Factors: High winds can disperse volatiles too quickly, reducing the dispensers' attractive range.
  • Maintenance: Irrigation and wildlife occasionally displaced the pads, suggesting a need for more durable hardware.
  • Host Preference: SWD preference varies by cultivar; in some strawberry trials, flies still preferred the fruit over the gum, indicating that the "recipe" may need crop-specific tuning.
  • Longevity: The current formulation lasts approximately 21 days in the field. Future research will focus on extending this window to reduce labor costs for growers.

Overall, these findings illustrate the commercial value of food-grade gum as a sustainable, non-toxic component of a systems approach to managing D. suzukii.

Summary updated

Abstract

The invasion of <i>Drosophila suzukii</i>, spotted-wing drosophila, across Europe and the US has led to economic losses for berry and cherry growers, and increased insecticide applications to protect fruit from damage. Commercial production relies heavily on unsustainable use of conventional toxic insecticides. Non-toxic insecticide strategies are necessary to alleviate the disadvantages and non-target impacts of toxic conventional insecticides and improve Integrated Pest Management (IPM). A novel food-grade gum deployed on dispenser pads (GUM dispensers) was evaluated to mitigate <i>D. suzukii</i> crop damage in five commercial crops and nine locations. Trials were conducted at a rate of 124 dispensers per hectare in cherry, wine grape, blueberry, raspberry, and blackberry in California and Oregon, USA during 2019 and 2020. The majority of trials with the food-grade gum resulted in a reduction of <i>D. suzukii</i> egg laying in susceptible fruit. In some cases, such damage was reduced by up to 78%. Overall, results from our meta-analysis showed highly significant differences between GUM treatments and the untreated control. Modeling simulations suggest a synergistic reduction of <i>D. suzukii</i> damage when used in combination with Spinosad (Entrust SC) insecticide. These data illustrate commercial value of this tool as a sustainable alternative to manage <i>D. suzukii</i> populations within a systems approach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tait2023open,
  author = {Gabriella Tait and Tingyu Zhu and Jimmy Klick and Fatemeh Ganjisaffar and Claira Castillo and Ryan David Kennedy and Hillary Thomas and Christopher G. Adams and Ferdinand Pfab and Serhan Mermer and Enrico Mirandola and Lan Xue and Frank G. Zalom and Michael P. Seagraves and Vaughn M. Walton},
  title = {{Open field trials of food-grade gum in California and Oregon as a behavioral control for Drosophila suzukii Matsumura (Diptera: Drosophilidae)}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Insect Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/finsc.2023.1141853},
}
Figure