Attention Discriminant Sampling for Point Clouds

Cheng-Yao Hong, Yu-Ying Chou, Tyng-Luh Liu

Abstract

3D point cloud processing requires efficient downsampling that preserves critical geometric and semantic information. Traditional methods like Farthest Point Sampling (FPS) often fail to capture complex structural details. We present Attention Discriminant Sampling (ADS), a novel framework that utilizes hierarchical self-attention and clustering to prioritize points based on local complexity and global similarity. ADS achieves state-of-the-art performance across classification, segmentation, and detection tasks, demonstrating significant robustness even at extremely low sampling ratios.

Introduction

3D point clouds—collections of data points in space typically generated by LiDAR or depth cameras—are often massive and irregular. To process them efficiently with deep learning, we must "sample" them (reduce the number of points) while keeping the most important information.

The industry standard has long been Farthest Point Sampling (FPS), which picks points that are furthest from each other to ensure a uniform spread. However, FPS is "blind" to the actual structure of the object. It treats a flat wall and a complex chair leg with the same priority if they are spatially distant. This research addresses the lack of semantic and structural awareness in current sampling techniques, which often leads to the loss of fine-grained details or redundant sampling of simple surfaces.

Methodology: The ADS Framework

The proposed Attention Discriminant Sampling (ADS) moves beyond simple distance-based metrics by utilizing a three-stage hierarchical approach:

  1. Clustering: Instead of treating the point cloud as a single mass, the framework uses Mean Shift clustering to decompose the cloud into structural components. This step implicitly captures the local geometry of the object.
  2. Discriminant Attention Analysis: This stage evaluates two levels of self-attention to determine point importance:
  3. Within-cluster: Measures "semantic complexity." Clusters with high internal variety are assigned more points.
  4. Between-cluster: Measures "semantic similarity." If two clusters are highly similar, the sampling rate is reduced to avoid redundancy.
  5. Sampling: Based on attention scores, a specific sampling ratio is calculated for each cluster. An "asymmetric" attention module then selects the specific points within those clusters that are most representative of the overall shape.
Overview of the ADS pipeline showing clustering, attention analysis, and sampling for part segmentation.

To ensure the sampled points truly represent the original object, the model employs an Earth Mover’s Distance (EMD) loss, penalizing the system if the downsampled version cannot effectively reconstruct the original dense point cloud.

Experimental Results

The researchers evaluated ADS across several benchmark datasets, including ModelNet40 (synthetic CAD models), ScanObjectNN (real-world scans), ShapeNet Part (segmentation), and large-scale indoor scene datasets like S3DIS and ScanNetV2.

Quantitative Performance

ADS achieved impressive gains across all tasks:

  • Classification: Reached 95.1% accuracy on ModelNet40 and 87.5% on ScanObjectNN, outperforming previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods.
  • Segmentation: Achieved 91.1% accuracy on the S3DIS dataset and 75.6% mIoU on ScanNetV2.
  • Detection: On the ScanNetV2 object detection task, it reached 55.0% mAP₅₀, a significant improvement over previous benchmarks.

Robustness to Sparsity

A key finding is the robustness of ADS at high downsampling rates. While traditional methods like FPS experience sharp performance drops as points are removed, ADS maintains high accuracy even when keeping only 1/64th of the original points.

Performance comparison of ADS against FPS and other samplers across varying sampling ratios.

Key Insights

  • Information Density over Uniformity: ADS recognizes that complex joints or small features require more points to describe than large, flat surfaces.
  • Hierarchical Reasoning: By analyzing both local (within-cluster) and global (between-cluster) relationships, the sampler makes intelligent decisions about point allocation.
  • Plug-and-Play Compatibility: ADS is designed as a drop-in replacement for sampling modules in existing architectures like PointNet++.

Conclusion

While ADS introduces some computational overhead due to the clustering and attention steps, its ability to preserve critical structural information makes it superior for complex 3D tasks. Future work may involve more end-to-end integration of the clustering step and applying this attention-driven logic to other 3D data representations.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper describes an attention-driven approach to 3-D point cloud sampling. We establish our method based on a structure-aware attention discriminant analysis that explores geometric and semantic relations embodied among points and their clusters. The proposed attention discriminant sampling (ADS) starts by efficiently decomposing a given point cloud into clusters to implicitly encode its structural and geometric relatedness among points. By treating each cluster as a structural component, ADS then draws on evaluating two levels of self-attention: within-cluster and between-cluster. The former reflects the semantic complexity entailed by the learned features of points within each cluster, while the latter reveals the semantic similarity between clusters. Driven by structurally preserving the point distribution, these two aspects of self-attention help avoid sampling redundancy and decide the number of sampled points in each cluster. Extensive experiments demonstrate that ADS significantly improves classification performance to 95.1% on ModelNet40 and 87.5% on ScanObjectNN and achieves 86.9% mIoU on ShapeNet Part Segmentation. For scene segmentation, ADS yields 91.1% accuracy on S3DIS with higher mIoU to the state-of-the-art and 75.6% mIoU on ScanNetV2. Furthermore, ADS surpasses the state-of-the-art with 55.0% mAP 50 on ScanNetV2 object detection.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hong2023attention,
  author = {Cheng-Yao Hong and Yu-Ying Chou and Tyng-Luh Liu},
  title = {{Attention Discriminant Sampling for Point Clouds}},
  booktitle = {IEEE/CVF International Conference on Computer Vision},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/iccv51070.2023.01327},
}
Figure