Associations among Screen Time and Unhealthy Behaviors, Academic Performance, and Well-Being in Chinese Adolescents

Hanyi Yan, Rui Zhang, Theresa M. Oniffrey, Guoxun Chen, Yueqiao Wang, Yingru Wu, Xinge Zhang, Quan Wang, Lu Ma, Rui Li, Justin B. MooreInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the links between screen time and various health and well-being indicators in Chinese adolescents. It found that different types of screen use have distinct associations with academic performance, eating habits, sleep, physical activity, and mental health, highlighting the need for nuanced approaches to screen time recommendations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While extensive research has explored the negative impacts of screen time on Western youth, there's a significant knowledge gap regarding these associations in Chinese adolescents. Cultural factors, educational pressures (like "cram schools"), and differing social norms might influence how screen time affects this population. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining the multifaceted relationships between various screen-based activities and key aspects of adolescent health and well-being in China.

Methods

The researchers employed a cross-sectional survey design, collecting data from 2,625 middle and high school students in Wuhan, China. They used questionnaires to gather information on demographics, screen time habits across different platforms (TV, e-games, social media, etc.) on both school and non-school days, and various health and psychological outcomes. Statistical analyses included linear and logistic regression models, adjusted for covariates like age and sex, to determine the associations between screen time and:

  • Body Mass Index (BMI) z-score
  • Eating behaviors (breakfast skipping, late-night snacking)
  • Sleep duration
  • Physical Activity (PA)
  • Academic performance
  • Psychological states (anxiety, life satisfaction, self-esteem)

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset collected from 2,625 middle and high school students in Wuhan, China, during the spring/summer of 2016. This dataset was collected via self-report questionnaires. No new benchmarks were introduced; the study focused on analyzing existing relationships within this specific population.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Not all screen time is equal: The study emphasizes that different types of screen-based activities have distinct and sometimes opposing effects. For instance, while social networking sites were linked to lower academic performance, they were also associated with increased physical activity in some contexts.
  • Context matters (school vs. non-school days): The impact of screen time can vary significantly depending on whether it occurs on school days or non-school days, suggesting that the displacement of other activities (like homework or sleep) might be more pronounced during school days.
  • Cultural nuances in "cram schools": The authors suggest that the prevalence of intensive academic tutoring ("cram schools") in China might neutralize some of the negative effects of screen time on academic performance, as devices might be used for educational purposes within these settings.
  • Unexpected BMI associations: Contrary to some Western studies, this research found no general negative association between screen time and BMI z-score. In fact, social networking site use was linked to being underweight or normal weight, potentially due to appearance comparison and body dissatisfaction.

Key Results

  • Academic Performance: Increased social networking site use (more than 4 hours/day) on both school and non-school days was negatively associated with academic performance. Watching TV (2-4 hours) and videos (<1 hour) on school days also showed negative associations.
  • Unhealthy Eating: Playing e-games for less than 1 hour or more than 4 hours was linked to less frequent breakfast consumption. Watching TV for 2-4 hours on school days was positively associated with snacking at night.
  • Sleep Duration: Playing e-games (2-4 hours) on non-school days and watching TV (not every day or <1 hour) on school days were positively associated with longer sleep duration. Conversely, watching videos (<1 hour) on school days was negatively associated with sleep duration.
  • Physical Activity (PA): Watching TV for more than 4 hours on school days was negatively associated with PA. However, using social networking sites for 2-4 hours on non-school days was positively associated with PA.
  • Mental Health:
    • Anxiety: Watching TV (2-4 hours) on school days was negatively associated with anxiety. Conversely, receiving electronic news/study materials (2-4 or >4 hours) on school days, and using social networking sites (any duration) on school or non-school days, were positively associated with anxiety.
  • Life Satisfaction: Watching TV for more than 4 hours on school days was negatively associated with life satisfaction.
  • Self-Esteem: Watching TV for 2-4 hours on school days was negatively associated with self-esteem.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic Limitation: The sample was limited to Wuhan, China, and may not be representative of all Chinese adolescents.
  • Self-Reported Data: All data were self-reported, introducing potential reporting bias.
  • PA Measurement: Physical activity was assessed with a single item, limiting the assessment to vigorous PA and excluding light/moderate activities.
  • Dichotomized Weight Status: Dichotomizing weight status might obscure nuances, as being underweight can also be a health risk.
  • Cross-Sectional Design: The study design prevents the determination of causal relationships; longitudinal studies are needed.
  • Measure Reliability: Some outcome measures (breakfast skipping, snacking, sleep duration, academic performance) were not validated, raising potential reliability concerns.

Future research should focus on longitudinal studies to establish causality, employ more objective measures for PA and weight, and explore the impact of screen time in diverse cultural and educational contexts. Further investigation into the specific mechanisms linking social networking sites to BMI and PA is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

Screen time is negatively associated with markers of health in western youth, but very little is known about these relationships in Chinese youth. Middle-school and high-school students (<i>n</i> = 2625) in Wuhan, China, completed questionnaires assessing demographics, health behaviors, and self-perceptions in spring/summer 2016. Linear and logistic regression analyses were conducted to determine whether, after adjustment for covariates, screen time was associated with body mass index (BMI), eating behaviors, average nightly hours of sleep, physical activity (PA), academic performance, and psychological states. Watching television on school days was negatively associated with academic performance, PA, anxiety, and life satisfaction. Television viewing on non-school days was positively associated with sleep duration. Playing electronic games was positively associated with snacking at night and less frequently eating breakfast, and negatively associated with sleep duration and self-esteem. Receiving electronic news and study materials on non-school days was negatively associated with PA, but on school days, was positively associated with anxiety. Using social networking sites was negatively associated with academic performance, but positively associated with BMI z-score, PA and anxiety. Screen time in adolescents is associated with unhealthy behaviors and undesirable psychological states that can contribute to poor quality of life.
BibTeX
@article{yan2017associations,
  author = {Hanyi Yan and Rui Zhang and Theresa M. Oniffrey and Guoxun Chen and Yueqiao Wang and Yingru Wu and Xinge Zhang and Quan Wang and Lu Ma and Rui Li and Justin B. Moore},
  title = {{Associations among Screen Time and Unhealthy Behaviors, Academic Performance, and Well-Being in Chinese Adolescents}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph14060596},
}
Figure