Association of Laparoscopic Methods and Clinical Outcomes of Cholecystolithiasis Plus Choledocholithiasis: A Cohort Study

Hui Ji, Yafeng Hou, Xiaojian Cheng, Feng Zhu, Chao Wan, Lei FangThe Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study compares three laparoscopic surgical approaches for gallstones in both the gallbladder and the common bile duct (choledocholithiasis). It finds that while all methods improve liver function, one approach, Laparoscopic Common Bile Duct Exploration (LCBDTD), is independently associated with a lower risk of bile leakage compared to a more complex, multi-step procedure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gallstones (cholecystolithiasis) are common, but when they migrate into the common bile duct (CBD), forming choledocholithiasis, they can lead to serious complications like cholangitis and pancreatitis. Treating this dual condition requires clearing stones from both the gallbladder and the CBD. While several laparoscopic surgical techniques exist, their comparative effectiveness and safety, particularly concerning complications like bile leakage, are not fully understood. This paper aims to clarify the clinical outcomes of three distinct laparoscopic methods for treating cholecystolithiasis plus choledocholithiasis.

Methods

This was a retrospective cohort study involving 127 patients who underwent laparoscopic surgery for cholecystolithiasis plus choledocholithiasis between January 2017 and March 2021. The patients were divided into three groups based on the surgical approach:

  1. LCBDTD (Laparoscopic Common Bile Duct Exploration): A minimally invasive approach to directly explore and clear stones from the CBD during laparoscopy.
  2. LCERCP (Endoscopic Retrograde Cholangiopancreatography + Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy): A two-stage approach where ERCP is used first to remove CBD stones, followed by laparoscopic gallbladder removal.
  3. LCBDPSENBD (Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy + Lithotomy of Common Bile Duct + Common Bile Duct Primary Suture + Endoscopic Nasobiliary Drainage): A single-stage procedure involving gallbladder removal, CBD stone clearance, primary suturing of the CBD, and placement of a nasobiliary drainage tube.

The primary outcome measured was bile leakage, with secondary outcomes including liver function indicators, postoperative complications, and hospitalization expenses. Statistical analysis involved comparing patient characteristics and outcomes across the three groups, using appropriate tests for normality and multivariate regression to adjust for confounders.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized retrospective data collected from the hospital's electronic chart system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bile Leakage is a Key Differentiator: The study highlights that the choice of surgical method significantly impacts the risk of bile leakage, a serious complication.
  • Simplicity vs. Complexity: The more complex, single-stage LCBDPSENBD procedure, while aiming to address multiple issues at once, was associated with a higher incidence of bile leakage. This suggests that the added steps and drainage methods in this approach may introduce risks.
  • LCBDTD's Advantage: Laparoscopic Common Bile Duct Exploration (LCBDTD) emerged as a favorable option, showing an independent association with reduced bile leakage. This implies that direct, minimally invasive exploration of the CBD might be safer in terms of leakage.
  • ERCP's Role and Limitations: While LCERCP (using ERCP first) had a low bile leakage rate, the paper notes that ERCP might not always be successful in removing all stones, especially larger ones, and can potentially damage the sphincter of Oddi.
  • Liver Function Improvement: All three surgical methods led to improvements in liver function indicators post-surgery, indicating their general efficacy in treating the condition.

Key Results

  • Bile Leakage: The incidence of bile leakage was significantly higher in the LCBDPSENBD group (29.0%) compared to LCBDTD (4.4%) and LCERCP (3.6%) (P = .001). LCBDTD was independently associated with a significantly lower risk of bile leakage (RR = 0.03, 95% CI: 0.003-0.37, P = .005) compared to LCBDPSENBD.
  • Surgical Outcomes: LCBDPSENBD had the longest surgery duration and highest blood loss. Patients in LCBDPSENBD also had a longer time to get out of bed and a longer indwelling duration of the abdominal drainage tube. Hospitalization expenses were highest for LCERCP.
  • Complications: Hyperamylasemia was more common in the LCERCP group (17.9%) compared to LCBDTD (0%) and LCBDPSENBD (3.2%) (P = .001).
  • Patient Characteristics: The LCBDPSENBD group had a smaller proportion of males, and the LCERCP group had a smaller common bile duct diameter and stone size.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Small Sample Size: The study included a relatively small number of patients (127), which may limit the generalizability of the findings.
  • Single Center: Data was collected from a single tertiary hospital, potentially introducing selection bias as it may attract more complex cases.
  • Retrospective Design: The retrospective nature of the study limits the depth of data that could be analyzed and may be subject to recall bias.

Future work could involve prospective studies to better define the characteristics of surgical treatment and to confirm these findings. The authors also suggest strict control and correction of indications for LCBDPSENBD, including specific criteria for CBD dilation, absence of combined intrahepatic stones or stenosis, and controlled bilirubin levels, to potentially mitigate bile leakage risks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Compared with laparoscopic cholecystectomy+lithotomy of common bile duct+common bile duct primary suture+endoscopic nasobiliary drainage, laparoscopic common bile duct exploration was associated with bile leakage.
BibTeX
@article{ji2022association,
  author = {Hui Ji and Yafeng Hou and Xiaojian Cheng and Feng Zhu and Chao Wan and Lei Fang},
  title = {{Association of Laparoscopic Methods and Clinical Outcomes of Cholecystolithiasis Plus Choledocholithiasis: A Cohort Study}},
  journal = {The Turkish Journal of Gastroenterology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.5152/tjg.2022.22110},
}
Figure