Abstract. Accurate assessment of Antarctic mass balance is essential for understanding and projecting sea-level rise. In this study, we assess the uncertainties in mass balance estimates using the input–output method in Wilkes Land, East Antarctica, with a focus on Basin 13. We developed a new flux gate product based on enhanced radar echo sounding (RES) coverage from Bedmap1, Bedmap2, and Bedmap3, enabling placement closer to the grounding line and reducing spatial bias. Using five different ice thickness datasets (Bedmap2, Bedmap3, BedMachineV2, BedMachineV3, and RES-derived thickness) along with velocity maps from 1995 to 2022, we calculate ice discharge and quantified the associated uncertainties. The results show that the improved flux gate and high-accuracy thickness data reduced discharge uncertainty from 53% to 4%. Approximately 42% of this reduction was due to improved thickness data, while about 7% resulted from the use of higher-quality velocity datasets. These findings highlight the essential role of accurate flux gate placement and reliable thickness data in reducing uncertainties in input–output-based Antarctic mass balance estimates.
Introduction: The Challenge of Measuring Ice Discharge
To predict sea-level rise, scientists must calculate the "mass balance" of the Antarctic Ice Sheet—a planetary-scale checkbook of how much snow falls (input) versus how much ice flows into the ocean (output/discharge). The Input-Output (IO) method is a standard approach, but it faces a major hurdle: calculating ice discharge requires precise measurements of ice thickness and velocity at the "grounding line," where the ice starts to float.
Because radar data is often sparse or noisy right at the coast, researchers typically place "flux gates" further inland and use models to correct for the gap. This study tackles the massive uncertainties introduced by these gaps, specifically in Basin 13 of Wilkes Land, an area often called "East Antarctica’s weak underbelly" due to its vulnerability to warming oceans.
Methodology and Data Integration
The authors developed a new, optimized Flux Gate (FG) configuration. By integrating the latest radar echo sounding (RES) data, they were able to position this gate approximately 7 km closer to the grounding line than previous standard models. This proximity significantly reduces the reliance on model-based "corrections," which are often sources of hidden error.
To quantify how data quality affects results, the study utilized a comprehensive suite of observations:
- Ice Thickness: A comparison of Bedmap2, Bedmap3, BedMachineV2, BedMachineV3, and a custom hybrid dataset (BMP3_RES) that combines Bedmap3 with point-based RES measurements.
- Ice Velocity: Multi-year and annual maps from MEaSUREs and ITS_LIVE, spanning 1995 to 2022.
- Surface Mass Balance (SMB): Data from the RACMO2.3p1 regional climate model to account for mass changes between the flux gate and the grounding line.
Results: The Uncertainty Collapse
The most striking result of the study is the dramatic reduction in uncertainty achieved by refining thickness data and gate placement. By using the new flux gate and the BMP3_RES thickness data, the uncertainty in discharge estimates for Basin 13 dropped from 53% to 4%.
Key Insights
- Thickness is the Bottleneck: The study reveals that ice thickness data is the primary driver of uncertainty. Improving thickness data accounted for 42% of the total uncertainty reduction, whereas improving velocity data only contributed about 7%.
- Wilkes Land Dynamics: Despite East Antarctica's reputation for stability, Basin 13 is in a state of net mass loss, with a mean mass balance (1995–2022) estimated at -11 ± 20 Gt/y.
- Glacier Trends: The Totten Glacier remains the dominant outlet, discharging ~70 Gt/y. Meanwhile, the Denman, Frost, and Holmes Glaciers showed increasing discharge trends, likely due to the intrusion of warm Circumpolar Deep Water (CDW) thinning ice shelves from below.
Conclusion
This research demonstrates that while ice velocity data has improved significantly over the last decade, accurate ice thickness measurements remain the most critical factor in predicting sea-level rise. The power of hybrid data—incorporating raw, point-based radar sounding measurements into gridded products—is essential for high-precision glaciology. Future work must continue to close coastal data gaps to further refine these vital climate metrics.
Summary updated