Assessing the Tuning of Sung Indian Classical Music

Joan Serrà, Gopala K. Koduri, Marius Miron, Xavier Serra

Introduction

Indian Classical Music (ICM) is renowned for its melodic complexity and the use of microtonal intervals known as shrutis. For centuries, musicologists have debated whether these traditions adhere to Just Intonation (JI)—based on pure mathematical ratios—or the theoretical 22-shruti system. This research, presented at ISMIR 2011, utilizes large-scale computational analysis to move beyond theory and examine how Carnatic and Hindustani music are actually performed today.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed pitch in vocal recordings using a multi-step signal processing pipeline:

  1. Fundamental Frequency (f0) Estimation: The YIN algorithm was used to extract pitch contours.
  2. Stability Filtering: To account for heavy ornamentation (gamakas), the analysis focused on "stable" regions where pitch remained steady (standard deviation < 20 cents) for at least 400ms.
  3. Interval Histograms: Since ICM lacks a fixed absolute pitch, the study calculated intervals between all prominent pitch peaks within a recording. These histograms were then compared against theoretical models of Equal Temperament (ET) and Just Intonation (JI).

Comparative Tuning Analysis

The study revealed a significant divergence in tuning practices between the two major traditions of Indian Classical Music.

Carnatic Music: A Tradition of Flexibility

Carnatic music, the tradition of Southern India, showed a statistically significant preference for Just Intonation ($r = 0.552$). The interval histograms for Carnatic music are characterized by broader, "flatter" peaks. This empirical evidence supports the musicological view that Carnatic notes (swarasthanas) are treated as flexible regions rather than fixed, discrete points.

Interval histogram for Carnatic music (hC). Vertical lines indicate theoretical values: solid (ET), dash-dotted (JI), and dotted (22 shrutis).

Hindustani Music: The "Harmonium Influence"

In contrast, Hindustani music from Northern India demonstrated a strong correlation with Western Equal Temperament ($r = 0.723$). Peaks in the Hindustani histograms clustered tightly around the 100-cent multiples (300, 400, 500, etc.) typical of ET. The authors attribute this shift to the widespread adoption of the hand-pumped harmonium—a fixed-pitch ET instrument—as the primary vocal accompaniment in the North since the 19th century.

Interval histogram for Hindustani music. The peaks align closely with the solid vertical lines representing Equal Temperament.

The 22 Shruti Debate

A key finding of the study concerns the long-standing theory of 22 shrutis. The data showed no strong evidence for 22 distinct, fixed intervals in contemporary singing. Instead, most steady-state intervals aligned with a standard 12-note framework. This suggests that the 22 shrutis may function more as a theoretical framework or as descriptors for microtonal transitions during ornamentation, rather than as fixed points for sustained notes.

Conclusion

The research provides a quantitative foundation for understanding modern ICM tuning. While Carnatic music remains closer to traditional Just Intonation and maintains the "regional" nature of its notes, Hindustani music has significantly shifted toward Equal Temperament. This highlights the powerful role that instrumental accompaniment can play in reshaping vocal traditions over time.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{serra2011assessing,
  author = {Joan Serrà and Gopala K. Koduri and Marius Miron and Xavier Serra},
  title = {{Assessing the Tuning of Sung Indian Classical Music}},
  booktitle = {ISMIR},
  year = {2011},
}
Figure