Assessing the Risk of Hg Exposure Associated with Rice Consumption in a Typical City (Suzhou) in Eastern China

Gang Wang, Yu Gong, Yixin Zhu, Ai‐Jun Miao, Liuyan Yang, Huan ZhongInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study assesses mercury (Hg) exposure risk from rice consumption in Suzhou, China, a non-mining area. Researchers found Hg levels in rice were well below national standards, and despite high rice consumption rates, the overall health risk (Hazard Quotient) was low, suggesting rice is a minor contributor to Hg exposure in this urban population.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While fish consumption has long been recognized as a primary source of mercury (Hg) exposure, particularly in Asian countries, recent research suggests that rice consumption can also significantly contribute to human Hg intake. This is especially concerning in regions where rice is a staple food. However, there's a notable lack of comprehensive risk assessments for Hg exposure through rice in non-contaminated areas of Asia. This study aims to fill that gap by evaluating the potential health risks associated with rice consumption in Suzhou, a major city in Eastern China that is not known for mercury mining, thereby providing insights into Hg exposure for a general urban population.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  1. Hg Concentration Measurement: Rice samples were collected from local markets and supermarkets across seven districts in Suzhou. These samples were then analyzed for their total mercury content using a direct Hg analyzer (DMA-80), following EPA Method 7473. Quality control measures included certified reference material and instrument blanks.
  2. Rice Ingestion Rate (IR) Assessment: A questionnaire-based survey was conducted among randomly selected Suzhou residents. The survey collected data on the amount of rice consumed per meal, the frequency of consumption, the primary source of rice purchase, and personal information such as sex, age, and body weight.
  3. Health Risk Assessment: The collected data on Hg concentration in rice and the assessed rice ingestion rates were used to calculate the estimated daily intake (EDI) of Hg. This EDI was then used to determine the Hazard Quotient (HQ), a measure of non-carcinogenic health risk, by comparing it to the Provisional Tolerable Weekly Intake (PTWI) for Hg. An HQ greater than 1 would indicate a potential health risk.

Datasets

  • Rice Samples: 177 rice samples were collected from markets and supermarkets in Suzhou in November 2016. These samples were categorized by production area (northeastern China - NEC, and northern Jiangsu - NJS) and source of purchase (market vs. supermarket).
  • Questionnaire Data: 236 completed questionnaires from randomly selected Suzhou residents were used to assess rice ingestion rates and gather demographic information.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Rice as a Potential Hg Source: The study reinforces the growing understanding that rice, not just fish, can be a significant dietary source of Hg, especially in rice-consuming populations.
  • Low Hg in Non-Contaminated Areas: Even in a major urban center like Suzhou, far from mining activities, rice Hg levels were found to be consistently low, well below national standards. This suggests that for many urban populations, rice may not be a primary driver of Hg exposure.
  • High Consumption, Low Risk: A key finding is that despite relatively high personal rice ingestion rates in Suzhou (0.05–0.4 kg/day), the calculated Hazard Quotient (HQ) remained low (0.005–0.05). This highlights the importance of considering both contaminant levels and consumption patterns when assessing dietary risk.
  • Demographics Don't Significantly Alter Risk: The study found that age and sex did not significantly impact the Hg exposure risk from rice consumption in Suzhou. While males had higher ingestion rates, their generally higher body weight compensated, leading to similar HQ values.

Key Results

  • Hg Content in Rice: Rice samples from Suzhou contained Hg levels ranging from 1.46 to 8.48 ng/g, with a mean of 3.83 ng/g. These levels were significantly lower than the Chinese national standard of 20 µg/kg.
  • No Significant Differences in Hg Levels: Hg content in rice was comparable between different production areas (NEC vs. NJS) and between rice purchased from markets versus supermarkets.
  • Rice Ingestion Rates (IR): The average IR for Suzhou residents was 0.2 kg/day, which is comparable to other regions in China and higher than in Western countries.
  • Hazard Quotient (HQ): The calculated HQ for Hg exposure from rice consumption in Suzhou ranged from 0.005 to 0.05, indicating a low risk.
  • Sex and Age Impact: No significant differences in HQ were observed between male and female residents, nor across different age groups.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Geographic Scope: The study focused on a single city, Suzhou. While representative of non-contaminated urban areas, the findings may not be generalizable to all of China or other Asian countries, particularly those with significant Hg contamination or different dietary habits.
  • Focus on Total Hg: The study measured total Hg. While methylmercury (MeHg) is the more toxic form, the paper notes that MeHg is a significant proportion of total Hg in rice. Future studies could benefit from speciation analysis.
  • Potential for Underestimation: The study acknowledges that the questionnaire survey might have excluded underage individuals, whose rice consumption patterns could differ.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest future research should investigate Hg exposure in different regions of China and examine other potentially vulnerable major food types. They also emphasize the need to compare Hg exposure from rice with that from fish, given fish's higher Hg content and proportion of MeHg.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent studies have revealed that not only fish but also rice consumption may significantly contribute to human exposure to mercury (Hg) in Asian countries. It is therefore essential to assess dietary exposure to Hg in rice and its associated health risk. However, risk assessments of Hg in rice in non-contaminated areas are generally lacking in Asian countries. In the present study, Hg concentrations were measured in rice samples collected from markets and supermarkets in Suzhou, a typical city in Eastern China. In addition, the rice ingestion rates (IR) were assessed via a questionnaire-based survey of Suzhou residents. The data were then used to assess the risk of Hg exposure associated with rice consumption, by calculating the hazard quotient (HQ). Hg contents in rice samples were well below the national standard (20 μg/kg), ranging from 1.46 to 8.48 ng/g. They were also significantly (<i>p</i> > 0.05) independent of the area of production and place of purchase (markets vs. supermarkets in the different districts). Our results indicate a low risk of Hg exposure from rice in Suzhou (HQ: 0.005-0.05), despite the generally high personal IR (0.05-0.4 kg/day). The risk of Hg associated with rice consumption for Suzhou residents was not significantly affected by the age or sex of the consumer (<i>p</i> > 0.05). Overall, our results provide a study of human exposure to Hg in rice in Chinese cities not known to be contaminated with Hg. Future studies should examine Hg exposure in different areas in China and in potentially vulnerable major food types.
BibTeX
@article{wang2017assessing,
  author = {Gang Wang and Yu Gong and Yixin Zhu and Ai‐Jun Miao and Liuyan Yang and Huan Zhong},
  title = {{Assessing the Risk of Hg Exposure Associated with Rice Consumption in a Typical City (Suzhou) in Eastern China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph14050525},
}
Figure