Assessing the risk of future Dunkelflaute events for Germany using generative deep learning

Felix Strnad, Jonathan Schmidt, Fabian Mockert, Philipp Hennig, Nicole Ludwig

As the European power grid transitions toward a heavy reliance on wind and solar energy, it becomes increasingly susceptible to specific meteorological phenomena. The most critical of these is the Dunkelflaute (dark doldrums)—extended periods of low wind and minimal sunlight, typically occurring during winter high-pressure systems. These events pose significant risks to grid stability, potentially leading to supply shortages and price volatility.

To address this, researchers have developed a novel framework using Generative Spatiotemporal Downscaling (GSD) to project the frequency and severity of these events through the end of the century. By applying flow-matching diffusion models, they have successfully bridged the gap between coarse global climate simulations and the high-resolution data required for energy system planning.

Methodology: Generative AI for Climate Downscaling

Traditional Global Climate Models (GCMs) provide data at resolutions (approx. 100 km) that are too coarse to capture local wind patterns or the sharp diurnal cycles of solar irradiance. The researchers utilized a score-based diffusion model trained on high-resolution ERA5 reanalysis data to downscale CMIP6 ensemble projections.

Unlike deterministic models, this generative approach produces multiple plausible high-resolution realizations, allowing for a robust assessment of uncertainty. The model is conditioned on the hour of the day and month to ensure accurate representation of seasonal and diurnal cycles. To define a Dunkelflaute event, the study calculates a combined "Capacity Factor" (CF) for wind and solar assets. An event is detected when the 48-hour mean CF falls below a critical threshold of 0.06.

Detection of Dunkelflaute events based on a 48-hour mean capacity factor (CF) threshold.

Key Insights and Results

Stability in a Warming Climate

One of the most significant findings is that the frequency and duration of Dunkelflaute events in Germany are projected to remain largely stable through the year 2100. Despite the broader shifts in global climate, the specific meteorological conditions driving these winter doldrums appear resilient across both moderate (SSP2-4.5) and high-emission (SSP5-8.5) scenarios.

Historical Context and Variability

Historical data from 1980 to 2024 shows that Germany typically experiences between 2 and 3 major Dunkelflaute events per year, though annual variability is significant. The downscaled models showed excellent alignment with historical records, validating the use of generative AI as a reliable proxy for computationally expensive regional climate modeling.

Historical annual frequency of Dunkelflaute events in Germany (1980–2024) showing significant inter-annual variability.

Spatial and Temporal Nuances

While the national frequency remains stable, the study identified potential spatial shifts. For instance, Southwestern Germany may become more favorable for renewable generation, while parts of Eastern Germany could see a slight reduction in wind attractiveness. Furthermore, the research highlights that failing to account for high-resolution temporal cycles (the diurnal cycle) leads to an overestimation of risk, as midday solar peaks often provide critical support that coarse models "smear out."

Limitations and Future Outlook

This study focuses strictly on the meteorological likelihood of low generation. It assumes the 2024 mix of solar and wind capacities remains constant and does not account for future grid adaptations such as increased storage (hydrogen/batteries) or cross-border interconnections. Future research aims to couple this high-resolution weather data with grid simulation tools like PyPSA to quantify the actual impact on electricity prices and system reliability. While the average frequency of these events is stable, further investigation into rare, multi-day "tail events" remains a priority for long-term infrastructure resilience.

Summary updated

Abstract

The European electricity power grid is transitioning towards renewable energy sources, characterized by an increasing share of off- and onshore wind and solar power. However, the weather dependency of these energy sources poses a challenge to grid stability, with so-called Dunkelflaute events -- periods of low wind and solar power generation -- being of particular concern due to their potential to cause electricity supply shortages. In this study, we investigate the impact of these events on the German electricity production in the years and decades to come. For this purpose, we adapt a recently developed generative deep learning framework to downscale climate simulations from the CMIP6 ensemble. We first compare their statistics to the historical record taken from ERA5 data. Next, we use these downscaled simulations to assess plausible future occurrences of Dunkelflaute events in Germany under the optimistic low (SSP2-4.5) and high (SSP5-8.5) emission scenarios. Our analysis indicates that both the frequency and duration of Dunkelflaute events in Germany in the ensemble mean are projected to remain largely unchanged compared to the historical period. This suggests that, under the considered climate scenarios, the associated risk is expected to remain stable throughout the century.
BibTeX
@misc{strnad2025assessing,
  author = {Felix Strnad and Jonathan Schmidt and Fabian Mockert and Philipp Hennig and Nicole Ludwig},
  title = {{Assessing the risk of future Dunkelflaute events for Germany using generative deep learning}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2509.24788},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.24788},
}
Figure