Artificial intelligence in nursing: Priorities and opportunities from an international invitational think‐tank of the Nursing and Artificial Intelligence Leadership Collaborative

Charlene Ronquillo, Laura‐Maria Peltonen, Lisiane Pruinelli, Charlene H. Chu, Suzanne Bakken, Ana Beduschi, Kenrick Cato, Nicholas R. Hardiker, Alain Junger, Martin Michalowski, Rune Nyrup, Samira Abbasgholizadeh Rahimi, Donald N. Reed, Tapio Salakoski, Sanna Salanterä, Nancy Walton, Patrick Weber, Thomas Wiegand, Maxim TopazJournal of Advanced Nursing 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the findings of an international think-tank on Artificial Intelligence (AI) in nursing, identifying critical gaps and opportunities for the profession. It argues that nurses must actively engage with AI, from understanding data to participating in development, to ensure its ethical and effective integration into healthcare.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid advancement and adoption of AI in healthcare present both opportunities and challenges for the nursing profession. While AI promises to enhance efficiency and improve patient care, there's a significant risk that nurses will be relegated to passive end-users, missing the chance to shape AI's development and application in ways that align with nursing values and patient needs. This paper addresses the gap in nursing's current engagement with AI discourse, highlighting the potential for AI to either exacerbate existing inequities or, if guided by nursing expertise, to significantly advance the profession and global health outcomes. The core problem is ensuring that nursing, as a profession with a vast workforce and direct patient contact, is not left behind in the AI revolution but rather becomes a leader in its ethical and effective implementation.

Methods

The study's methodology involved an international invitational think-tank, the Nursing and Artificial Intelligence Leadership (NAIL) Collaborative. This collaborative brought together interdisciplinary experts in AI development, biomedical ethics, AI in primary care, legal aspects of AI, philosophy of AI in health, nursing practice, implementation science, health informatics, and patient advocacy. The think-tank convened for a three-day event, preceded by a survey to gauge initial perspectives. Activities included expert presentations and working sessions focused on identifying priority areas, opportunities, and recommendations for addressing AI in nursing. The paper then summarizes the key discussion points and insights from these activities.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nursing's Passive Role is Risky: The current limited engagement of nursing with AI discussions poses a risk of the profession being excluded from decisions that will significantly impact its practice and patient care.
  • Data is the Bridge: Nurses are primary data generators in healthcare. Understanding the relationship between the data they collect and how AI utilizes it is crucial for nurses to critically evaluate AI outputs and ensure data quality.
  • Beyond End-Users: Nurses need to be actively involved in all stages of AI development and implementation, not just as end-users, to ensure AI aligns with clinical realities and nursing values.
  • AI for "Good Nursing": There's a significant untapped potential for nursing to contribute to "AI for Good" initiatives, leveraging AI to address global health challenges and humanitarian efforts.
  • Ethical Imperative: Given the potential magnitude of AI's impact, nurses have an ethical imperative to possess a basic understanding of how AI tools are developed and their implications for clinical judgment and practice.

Key Results

The paper identifies three overarching priorities for nursing in the context of AI:

  1. Understanding the Data-AI Relationship: Nurses must grasp how the data they collect is used by AI technologies, recognizing that this data directly informs AI tools and that nurses serve as the final evaluators of AI-based recommendations.
  2. Involvement in All AI Stages: Nurses need to be meaningfully involved from AI development through implementation, contributing their expertise in delineating clinical problems, acting as intermediaries between clinical and technical spheres, and incorporating relational practice insights.
  3. "AI for Good Nursing" (AI4GN): There's a need to recognize and leverage the role of AI in supporting nursing's contribution to global health and humanitarian efforts, advocating for equity and social justice in AI development.

The paper also outlines actionable suggestions across education, practice, research, and leadership for each priority.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that the discourse on AI in nursing is still limited and largely absent in nursing education. It highlights the need for developing "minimum AI in nursing competencies" within curricula and for practicing nurses. Future work should focus on creating these competencies, fostering interdisciplinary partnerships for AI development, and ensuring that AI implementation is driven by the goal of enhancing nursing care quality rather than solely economic efficiency. The authors emphasize that these priorities are interconnected and require a broad, purposeful approach to empower nurses in the AI landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

We outline crucial gaps where focused effort is required for nursing to take a leadership role in shaping AI use in health systems. Three priorities were identified that need to be addressed in the near future: (a) Nurses must understand the relationship between the data they collect and AI technologies they use; (b) Nurses need to be meaningfully involved in all stages of AI: from development to implementation; and (c) There is a substantial untapped and an unexplored potential for nursing to contribute to the development of AI technologies for global health and humanitarian efforts.
BibTeX
@article{ronquillo2021artificial,
  author = {Charlene Ronquillo and Laura‐Maria Peltonen and Lisiane Pruinelli and Charlene H. Chu and Suzanne Bakken and Ana Beduschi and Kenrick Cato and Nicholas R. Hardiker and Alain Junger and Martin Michalowski and Rune Nyrup and Samira Abbasgholizadeh Rahimi and Donald N. Reed and Tapio Salakoski and Sanna Salanterä and Nancy Walton and Patrick Weber and Thomas Wiegand and Maxim Topaz},
  title = {{Artificial intelligence in nursing: Priorities and opportunities from an international invitational think‐tank of the Nursing and Artificial Intelligence Leadership Collaborative}},
  journal = {Journal of Advanced Nursing},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1111/jan.14855},
}
Figure