Artificial Intelligence-Based Assessment System for Evaluating Suitable Range of Heel Height

Si-Huei Lee, Bor-Shing Lin, Hsiang-Chen Lee, Xiaowei Huang, Ya-Chu Chi, Bor‐Shyh Lin, Kaoru AbeIEEE Access 2021 · DOI

Abstract

High-heeled shoes of excessive height can severely injure shoe users, causing various conditions such as musculoskeletal pain, osteoarthritis, and hallux valgus. While a physician can estimate an appropriate heel height by assessing calcaneal varus deformation, this professional assistance is typically unavailable to consumers during shoe selection. This study presents a novel system for evaluating the maximum safe heel height for individual female wearers. The system utilizes images of the Achilles tendon, medial and lateral longitudinal arches, and plantar pressure distributions as inputs. Trained on these datasets using Basic CNN, VGG16, and MobileNetV2 architectures, the system achieved an accuracy of 0.88. A subsequent statistical algorithm was applied to refine the AI model's outputs, resulting in a mean absolute error (MAE) of 1.21 cm—less than the typical height increment for commercial high-heeled shoes.

Introduction

High-heeled shoes are a staple of fashion and professional attire, yet wearing heels that exceed an individual's physiological limits can lead to severe long-term health issues. Clinically, a physician determines a "safe" height by observing calcaneal varus—the specific way the heel bone tilts or deforms as it is elevated. However, most consumers lack access to objective, automated tools that can translate these complex clinical observations into practical recommendations. This research addresses this gap by developing an AI-powered measurement platform designed to automate the clinical assessment process.

System Architecture and Methodology

The proposed system consists of a custom hardware-software stack designed to capture both visual and tactile data from the wearer's foot at various elevations.

System architecture including the measurement platform, mainboard, and host computer.

Hardware Components

As shown in the system architecture, the setup includes:

  1. The Measurement Platform: A motorized lifting mechanism that elevates the foot to simulate different heel heights. It is equipped with 42 force-sensing resistor (FSR) sensors to map plantar pressure and six USB webcams to capture foot angles from multiple perspectives.
  2. Mainboard and Host: A central processing unit (Mainboard) manages the sensors and motor, while a host computer processes the visual and pressure data.
Layout of the measurement platform showing the arrangement of six cameras and force-sensing resistors (FSR).

AI and Statistical Modeling

The researchers evaluated three Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) architectures—Basic CNN, VGG16, and MobileNetV2—to classify foot positions as either "wearable" (safe) or "non-wearable" (unsafe). To address potential noise in AI classifications (e.g., a model incorrectly labeling a 7cm height as safe while labeling a 6.5cm height as unsafe), a mode-based statistical algorithm was implemented. This smoothing technique analyzes adjacent height increments to identify the true "critical point" of instability.

Data Collection and Insights

The study involved 175 female subjects, with 100 passing medical screening to ensure a baseline of healthy foot physiology. A total of 4,200 data points, comprising images and pressure maps, were collected. Professional physicians provided the ground truth labels by manually evaluating each subject on the platform.

Several key insights emerged during the training process:

  • The Achilles Advantage: Images of the Achilles tendon alone yielded the highest accuracy (0.88), suggesting that tendon deformation is the most reliable visual proxy for calcaneal varus.
  • The "Matting" Paradox: Contrary to standard practices where background removal (matting) improves model focus, non-matted images performed better here. The background likely served as a consistent reference point for the AI to perceive subtle changes in foot position.
  • Pressure vs. Vision: Plantar pressure data proved less effective than visual images for classification, likely due to idiosyncratic variations in foot size and weight distribution among subjects.

Key Results

The Basic CNN architecture, utilizing Achilles tendon images, emerged as the superior model with an accuracy of 0.88 and an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.96. The model demonstrated a high recall of 0.92, ensuring it effectively identifies safe heights without being overly restrictive.

Crucially, the final system achieved a Mean Absolute Error (MAE) of 1.21 cm. Given that commercial high heels typically increase in height by approximately 2.54 cm (1 inch) increments, an error margin of ~1.2 cm is small enough to provide practically useful recommendations for consumers.

Limitations and Future Work

While promising, the system's current iteration has limitations. The dataset was restricted to females with foot lengths between 22 and 26 cm, and the computer vision model requires a bright, shadow-free environment. Future research will focus on generalizing the model to a wider range of demographics and foot sizes, as well as exploring video-based dynamic analysis to capture gait stability in real-time.

Reference: Lee, S. H., Lin, B. S., et al. (2021). "Artificial Intelligence-Based Assessment System for Evaluating Suitable Range of Heel Height." IEEE Access, vol. 9, pp. 38374-38385.

Summary updated

Abstract

High-heeled shoes of excessive height can severely injure shoe users. Such shoes may cause various injuries, including musculoskeletal pain, osteoarthritis, and hallux valgus. A physician can estimate an appropriate heel height limitation for an individual wearer by touching calcaneus to estimate deformation of the calcaneal varus. It would typically be impractical for a woman to seek the professional assistance of her physician when buying high-heeled shoes. A novel system was developed in this study for evaluating the maximum safe height of high-heeled shoes for female wearers. In this study, images of Achilles tendons, medial longitudinal arches, lateral longitudinal arches, and plantar pressure distributions served as the inputs in the proposed system. After the system had been trained with those images, the system could output the maximum height of high-heeled shoes for each individual wearer. In this study, two crucial methods were used for performing the evaluating system. First, Basic CNN, VGG16, and MobileNetV2 were used to evaluate images of feet. Through the experiments, the proposed artificial intelligence (AI) model achieved an accuracy of 0.88. Next, a statistics algorithm was used to modify the results obtained from the AI model. Subsequently, the error of the system declined. The mean absolute error of the proposed system which was used for evaluating the maximum height of high-heeled shoes was 1.21 cm, which is less than the typical increment for commercially available high-heeled shoes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lee2021artificial,
  author = {Si-Huei Lee and Bor-Shing Lin and Hsiang-Chen Lee and Xiaowei Huang and Ya-Chu Chi and Bor‐Shyh Lin and Kaoru Abe},
  title = {{Artificial Intelligence-Based Assessment System for Evaluating Suitable Range of Heel Height}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2021.3063912},
}
Figure