ARQ-based spectrum sharing with multiple-access secondary system

Shu Fang, See Ho Ting, Qiang Li, Ashish Pandharipande, Mehul Motani

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel "quid pro quo" spectrum sharing protocol for cognitive radio networks. In this system, secondary users earn the right to transmit by acting as cooperative relays for the primary, licensed user. By utilizing a credit-based mechanism, the protocol ensures that the primary user's throughput remains at its benchmark level while allowing a multiple-access secondary system to utilize the spectrum during primary retransmission phases. Theoretical analysis and Monte Carlo simulations demonstrate that the protocol effectively balances primary protection with secondary throughput gains, especially as the number of secondary transmitters increases.

Introduction

Wireless spectrum management remains a critical challenge as demand for bandwidth grows. Cognitive Radio (CR) technology offers a solution by allowing unlicensed "secondary" users to access spectrum bands assigned to "primary" users when they are underutilized. However, in heavy traffic conditions where the primary user is constantly active, traditional "spectrum hole" sensing is ineffective.

This paper addresses this by leveraging the Automatic Repeat Request (ARQ) mechanism common in primary systems. Instead of avoiding primary transmissions, secondary users actively assist in primary packet delivery to earn transmission opportunities.

System Model

The researchers consider a network consisting of a primary transmitter (PT), a primary receiver (PR), a secondary receiver (SR), and a cluster of $M$ secondary transmitters (STs).

Figure 1: System model of the ARQ-based spectrum sharing network with multiple secondary transmitters.

As shown in Figure 1, the system accounts for various channel gains ($h_{ij}$) between nodes, modeled using Rayleigh flat fading and standard path-loss exponents. The secondary system is a multiple-access configuration where any of the $M$ transmitters can communicate with the single SR.

The Credit-Based Sharing Protocol

The core of the proposed method is a dynamic switching mechanism governed by a credit system. The network alternates between two operational modes:

1. Cooperation Mode

When a primary transmission fails (the PR does not receive the packet correctly), the secondary system intervenes. The protocol selects the "best" ST—the one with the strongest channel to the PR—to relay the primary packet. Successful relaying provides a throughput gain to the primary system, which is recorded as "credits" for the secondary system.

2. Access Mode

Once sufficient credits are accumulated to offset potential interference, the secondary system enters access mode. During a primary retransmission slot, a selected ST transmits its own data (Packet S1) to the SR simultaneously with the PT's retransmission of Packet P1.

Figure 2: Illustration of ARQ mechanisms and packet timing during the access mode.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the protocol manages different events ($A_1, A_2$) based on whether the primary packet is successfully recovered at the PR despite the secondary interference. The "penalty" incurred by the primary system during this phase is balanced against the previously earned credits, ensuring the primary user's average performance never falls below its non-sharing benchmark.

Key Insights and Results

The study reveals several critical aspects of this cooperative approach:

  • Selection Diversity: The presence of multiple STs provides spatial diversity. Picking the best relay among $M$ candidates significantly improves the primary user's reliability, which in turn allows the secondary system to earn credits more quickly.
  • Primary Protection: The protocol successfully maintains the primary system's average throughput. Secondary access is strictly regulated by the credit balance, preventing any net degradation of the licensed service.
  • Scalability and Bounds: Increasing the number of secondary transmitters ($M$) improves secondary throughput. The authors derived analytical upper bounds for throughput as $M \to \infty$, showing that the secondary system can achieve a normalized throughput of up to 0.5 packets per slot in ideal conditions.
  • Throughput Plateau: At very high Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNR), the primary system becomes highly reliable and rarely requires relaying. This creates a "throughput plateau" for the secondary system, as the opportunity to earn credits diminishes.

Conclusion

The proposed credit-based protocol offers a robust framework for spectrum sharing in congested environments. By transforming primary retransmissions into opportunities for secondary access through cooperation, the system achieves a win-win scenario. Future work may extend this model to decentralized networks where secondary transmitters are not clustered, or explore more complex ARQ mechanisms involving multiple retries.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a cognitive radio network in which a multiple-access secondary system coexists with an automatic repeat request (ARQ)-based primary system under heavy primary traffic. To achieve spectrum sharing without degrading the performance of the primary system, the secondary transmitters alternate between cooperation and access modes based on a credit system. In the cooperation mode, the secondary transmitters serve as potential relays among which the best one is selected to help forward the primary packet, thus accumulating credits. These credits will then allow the secondary transmitters to gain spectrum access by exploiting the ARQ mechanism of the primary system.Our results show that with a cluster of closely located secondary transmitters, the proposed spectrum sharing protocol achieves an equal average throughput for the primary system compared to the case without spectrum sharing, while providing access opportunities for the secondary system. Furthermore, by increasing the number of secondary transmitters or decreasing the distance between secondary transmitters and secondary receiver, an overall higher throughput can be achieved for the secondary system, without affecting the analytical results for the upper bounds of primary throughput under cooperation mode, and secondary throughput under access mode are also derived.
BibTeX
@article{fang2013arq,
  author = {Shu Fang and See Ho Ting and Qiang Li and Ashish Pandharipande and Mehul Motani},
  title = {{ARQ-based spectrum sharing with multiple-access secondary system}},
  journal = {EURASIP J. Wirel. Commun. Netw.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1186/1687-1499-2013-129},
}
Figure