Are We Adapting to Climate Change?

Marshall Burke, Mustafa Zahid, Mariana Martins, Christopher M. Callahan, Richard Lee, Tumenkhusel Avirmed, Sam Heft‐Neal, Mathew V. Kiang, Solomon Hsiang, David B. Lobell

Abstract

We study whether the sensitivity of economic, health, and livelihood outcomes to climate extremes has declined over the last half century, consistent with adaptation. Understanding whether such adaptation is already occurring is central to anticipating future climate damages, to calibrating the level of ambition needed for emissions mitigation efforts, and to understanding additional investments in adaptation that could be required to avoid additional damages. Using comprehensive panel data across diverse geographies and outcomes, including data on mortality, agricultural productivity, crime, conflict, economic output, and damages from flooding and tropical cyclones, we find limited systematic evidence of adaptation to date. Across 21 outcomes we study, six show a statistically significant declining sensitivity to a changing climate, five show an increasing sensitivity, and the remainder show no statistically significant change. Our results do not imply that specific documented adaptation efforts are ineffective or certain locations have not adapted, but instead that the net effects of existing actions have largely not been successful in meaningfully reducing climate impacts in aggregate. To avoid ongoing and future damages from warming, our results suggest a need to identify promising adaptation strategies and understand how they can be scaled.

Introduction: The "Clever Human" Hypothesis

A central debate in climate economics revolves around the "clever human" hypothesis: the notion that as the planet warms, human societies will naturally innovate and adjust, rendering historical climate-damage relationships obsolete. If adaptation occurs rapidly and systematically, future damages may be significantly lower than historical data suggests. Conversely, if adaptation is slow or non-existent, current projections likely underestimate the catastrophic costs of climate change.

While anecdotes of adaptation—such as the development of drought-tolerant seeds or the proliferation of air conditioning—are common, empirical evidence of macro-level adaptation remains sparse. This study seeks to quantify the speed of adaptation across diverse sectors and geographies over the last 50 years to determine if we are truly becoming less sensitive to a changing climate.

Methodology: Measuring the Speed of Adaptation

The researchers employed a rigorous panel econometric approach, analyzing longitudinal data to estimate "response functions"—the mathematical relationship between climate variables (like temperature) and societal outcomes (like mortality). To capture the dynamics of adaptation, the study introduced several methodological innovations:

  • Decadal Sensitivity: Rather than assuming a fixed relationship, the model allows response functions to vary by decade, tracking whether the "slope" of impact has flattened over time.
  • Total Sensitivity: Most studies focus on "point sensitivity" (e.g., the impact of a single 35°C day). This paper introduces "Total Sensitivity," an exposure-weighted derivative of the response function. This accounts for the entire temperature distribution, recognizing that a society might improve at handling extreme heat while becoming more vulnerable to moderate warming, leading to a net increase in vulnerability.
  • Adaptation Decomposition: The study separates changes in sensitivity into two primary drivers: "changing responses" (technological or behavioral shifts, such as medical advancements) and "changing exposures" (spatial shifts, such as populations migrating into more flood-prone or hotter regions).

Results: Limited Evidence of Systematic Adaptation

The analysis of 21 societal outcomes reveals that systematic adaptation is the exception rather than the rule. The findings are split into three categories:

  1. Adapted (6 Outcomes): Significant declines in sensitivity were observed in US maize, EU wheat, US violent crime, and US personal income. These "winners" saw sensitivity declines of roughly 1% to 7% per year, though progress was often concentrated in earlier decades.
  2. Worsened (5 Outcomes): Sensitivity actually increased for Brazilian soy and maize, African civil conflict, and US suicide rates. For instance, African conflict sensitivity increased by 3.4% per year.
  3. No Change (10 Outcomes): No statistically significant change in sensitivity was found for global GDP growth, US flood damages, or Indian wheat.

Sectoral Insights: The Productivity Trap and the Sun Belt Effect

The data highlights specific mechanisms that hinder net adaptation. In Brazilian agriculture, increasing sensitivity suggests a "productivity trap": while intensifying farming practices (like higher planting density) increases yields in optimal years, it makes crops more fragile during heatwaves.

In the United States, the "Sun Belt" effect illustrates how migration can offset technological gains. While innovations like air conditioning have reduced the biological impact of heat, the movement of the population toward warmer states increases the population-weighted exposure to extreme temperatures. This "changing exposure" can neutralize the benefits of "changing responses," leaving total societal sensitivity unchanged or even higher.

Furthermore, progress appears to have stalled in several areas. US heat-related mortality showed a remarkable decline through the 20th century, but that progress has largely plateaued or slightly reversed since the 2000s.

Conclusion: The Need for Intentional Scaling

The study serves as a critical wake-up call for policymakers and economists. The assumption that human ingenuity will automatically mitigate climate damages is not supported by the last half-century of data. While specific adaptation efforts may be effective locally, their net effect has not been sufficient to reduce climate impacts in aggregate.

To avoid mounting damages in a warming world, there is an urgent need to identify truly effective adaptation strategies and, more importantly, to understand the economic and political barriers to scaling them. Without a massive, intentional shift in how we invest in and deploy adaptation technology, the costs of climate change will continue to rise unabated.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study whether the sensitivity of economic, health, and livelihood outcomes to climate extremes has declined over the last half century, consistent with adaptation.Understanding whether such adaptation is already occurring is central to anticipating future climate damages, to calibrating the level of ambition needed for emissions mitigation efforts, and to understanding additional investments in adaptation that could be required to avoid additional damages.Using comprehensive panel data across diverse geographies and outcomes, including data on mortality, agricultural productivity, crime, conflict, economic output, and damages from flooding and tropical cyclones, we find limited systematic evidence of adaptation to date.Across 21 outcomes we study, six show a statistically significant declining sensitivity to a changing climate, five show an increasing sensitivity, and the remainder show no statistically significant change.Our results do not imply that specific documented adaptation efforts are ineffective or certain locations have not adapted, but instead that the net effects of existing actions have largely not been successful in meaningfully reducing climate impacts in aggregate.To avoid ongoing and future damages from warming, our results suggest a need to identify promising adaptation strategies and understand how they can be scaled.
BibTeX
@misc{burke2024are,
  author = {Marshall Burke and Mustafa Zahid and Mariana Martins and Christopher M. Callahan and Richard Lee and Tumenkhusel Avirmed and Sam Heft‐Neal and Mathew V. Kiang and Solomon Hsiang and David B. Lobell},
  title = {{Are We Adapting to Climate Change?}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2139/ssrn.4964403},
  howpublished = {SSRN},
}
Figure