Architectural challenges and solutions for collocated LWIP — A network layer perspective

S Thomas Valerrian Pasca, P C Amogh, Debashisha Mishra, Nagamani Dheeravath, Anil Kumar Rangisetti, Bheemarjuna Reddy Tamma, A. Antony Franklin

Abstract

Achieving a tighter level of aggregation between LTE and Wi-Fi networks at the radio access network (a.k.a. LTE-Wi-Fi Aggregation or LWA) has become one of the most prominent solutions in the era of 5G to boost network capacity and improve end user's quality of experience. LWA offers flexible resource scheduling decisions for steering user traffic via LTE and Wi-Fi links. In this work, we propose a Collocated LTE/WLAN Radio Level Integration architecture at IP layer (C-LWIP), an enhancement over 3GPP non-collocated LWIP architecture. We have evaluated C-LWIP performance in various link aggregation strategies (LASs). A C-LWIP node (i.e., the node having collocated, aggregated LTE eNodeB and Wi-Fi access point functionalities) is implemented in NS-3 which introduces a traffic steering layer (i.e., Link Aggregation Layer) for efficient integration of LTE and Wi-Fi. Using extensive simulations, we verified the correctness of C-LWIP module in NS-3 and evaluated the aggregation benefits over standalone LTE and Wi-Fi networks with respect to varying number of users and traffic types. We found that split bearer performs equivalently to switched bearer for UDP flows and switched bearer outperforms split bearer in the case of TCP flows. Also, we have enumerated the potential challenges to be addressed for unleashing C-LWIP capabilities. Our findings also include WoD-Link Aggregation Strategy which is shown to improve system throughput by 50% as compared to Naive-LAS in a densely populated indoor stadium environment.

Introduction

The exponential growth of mobile data traffic, projected to exceed 30 Exabytes per month, has led to a "spectrum crunch" for telecommunication providers. To address this, 3GPP introduced standards like LTE-WLAN Radio Level Integration with IPsec (LWIP). However, current LWIP standards often assume a non-collocated architecture where the LTE eNodeB and Wi-Fi Access Point (AP) are separate entities. This separation introduces significant overhead due to IPsec tunneling and limits the ability to make fine-grained, millisecond-level traffic steering decisions based on rapid radio channel fluctuations.

Proposed C-LWIP Architecture

To overcome these limitations, we propose Collocated LWIP (C-LWIP), where eNodeB and Wi-Fi AP functionalities are integrated into a single physical node. This collocation enables tighter coordination and more efficient resource management.

A core component of C-LWIP is the Link Aggregation Layer (LAL). Positioned above the radio interfaces, the LAL acts as a traffic steering sub-layer that collects network parameters and executes intelligent steering decisions at either the packet or flow level. Crucially, this architecture requires no modifications to the User Equipment (UE) protocol stack, ensuring compatibility with existing commercial devices.

C-LWIP Node and UE Protocol Stacks

In dense environments, Wi-Fi performance often suffers from high contention and collisions during the uplink phase. We introduce the WoD-Link Aggregation Strategy (WoD-LAS), which routes all uplink traffic through the scheduled LTE interface while utilizing Wi-Fi exclusively for downlink data. This strategy "clears the air" for Wi-Fi, significantly improving downlink efficiency in crowded scenarios.

Performance Evaluation

We implemented the C-LWIP module in the NS-3 network simulator and evaluated it across several scenarios, including home environments with mixed traffic and a large-scale indoor stadium layout with 10 C-LWIP nodes and up to 400 users.

Performance evaluation of C-LWIP across various scenarios and traffic types

Key Findings

  • Throughput Gains: In the dense stadium simulation (Fig. 9), the WoD-LAS strategy achieved a system throughput of approximately 155 Mbps, representing a 50% improvement over naive splitting strategies (PS-N-LAS).
  • TCP vs. UDP Dynamics: For UDP traffic, packet-level splitting (PS-N-LAS) performs comparably to flow-level switching. However, for TCP traffic, packet splitting causes significant out-of-order delivery due to latency differences between LTE and Wi-Fi. This triggers TCP congestion control mechanisms, making "switched bearer" strategies (keeping a flow on one radio) superior for TCP-heavy workloads (Fig. 7).
  • Spectrum Efficiency: Collocation allows for advanced techniques like Fractional Frequency Reuse (FFR), where Wi-Fi can be prioritized for cell-edge users who might otherwise face high LTE interference from neighboring cells.

Conclusion and Future Work

C-LWIP offers a promising path toward seamless LTE-Wi-Fi integration. While it provides substantial throughput benefits, particularly with the WoD-LAS strategy in dense environments, challenges remain. The primary hurdle is the out-of-order delivery issue for TCP during packet-level aggregation. Future work will focus on developing dynamic offloading algorithms that account for reordering costs and optimizing the Link Aggregation Layer for better protocol stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

Achieving a tighter level of aggregation between LTE and Wi-Fi networks at the radio access network (a.k.a. LTE-Wi-Fi Aggregation or LWA) has become one of the most prominent solutions in the era of 5G to boost network capacity and improve end user's quality of experience. LWA offers flexible resource scheduling decisions for steering user traffic via LTE and Wi-Fi links. In this work, we propose a Collocated LTE/WLAN Radio Level Integration architecture at IP layer (C-LWIP), an enhancement over 3GPP non-collocated LWIP architecture. We have evaluated C-LWIP performance in various link aggregation strategies (LASs). A C-LWIP node (i.e., the node having collocated, aggregated LTE eNodeB and Wi-Fi access point functionalities) is implemented in NS-3 which introduces a traffic steering layer (i.e., Link Aggregation Layer) for efficient integration of LTE and Wi-Fi. Using extensive simulations, we verified the correctness of C-LWIP module in NS-3 and evaluated the aggregation benefits over standalone LTE and Wi-Fi networks with respect to varying number of users and traffic types. We found that split bearer performs equivalently to switched bearer for UDP flows and switched bearer outperforms split bearer in the case of TCP flows. Also, we have enumerated the potential challenges to be addressed for unleashing C-LWIP capabilities. Our findings also include WoD-Link Aggregation Strategy which is shown to improve system throughput by 50% as compared to Naive-LAS in a densely populated indoor stadium environment.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pasca2017architectural,
  author = {S Thomas Valerrian Pasca and P C Amogh and Debashisha Mishra and Nagamani Dheeravath and Anil Kumar Rangisetti and Bheemarjuna Reddy Tamma and A. Antony Franklin},
  title = {{Architectural challenges and solutions for collocated LWIP — A network layer perspective}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.1704.03873},
}
Figure