Arbitrage With Power Factor Correction Using Energy Storage

Md Umar Hashmi, Deepjyoti Deka, Ana Bušić, Lucas Pereira, Scott Backhaus

TL;DR

This paper demonstrates that energy storage systems can be co-optimized to perform both energy arbitrage (buying low, selling high) and local power factor correction (PFC) simultaneously. The researchers show that these two goals are largely decoupled, meaning batteries can fix grid inefficiencies caused by solar power without sacrificing their primary profit-making potential.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As rooftop solar (distributed generation) proliferates, it creates a headache for grid operators: power factor (PF) degradation. Most small-scale solar inverters are designed to only produce "active power" (the stuff that actually does work). However, the grid also requires "reactive power" to maintain magnetic fields in motors and transformers.

When solar panels provide the active power but not the reactive power, the ratio between the two—the Power Factor—drops. A low PF leads to higher currents, excessive thermal losses, and potential equipment damage. While large-scale plants have strict PF rules, small residential systems often don't, leading to a "systematic degradation" of the grid's load profile. This paper investigates whether residential energy storage can step in to provide that missing reactive power while still performing its main job: energy arbitrage.

Methods

The authors frame the challenge as a co-optimization problem. The core difficulty is that the joint optimization of active and reactive power is non-convex, making it mathematically "hard" to solve efficiently.

To tackle this, they employ several strategies:

  • McCormick Relaxation: They reformulate the non-convex PF constraints into a mixed-integer convex problem that can be solved quickly by standard industrial solvers (like Gurobi or Mosek).
  • Penalty-Based Schemes: They introduce a penalty function for PF violations, allowing the system to prioritize PFC or arbitrage depending on the severity of the grid's needs.
  • Model Predictive Control (MPC): For real-time application, they use MPC to make decisions over a rolling horizon.
  • Forecasting: They use ARMA (Auto-Regressive Moving Average) models to predict future load and solar generation, and ARIMA models to forecast volatile electricity prices.

Datasets

The study uses high-resolution, real-world data to validate its models:

  • Load and Solar Data: 15-minute averaged household consumption and solar generation data from the island of Madeira, Portugal (part of the EU SMILE project).
  • Price Data: Real-time electricity pricing from the New York ISO (NYISO) and the California ISO (CAISO).
  • Battery Profiles: They simulated various battery types, ranging from slow-ramping (like Tesla Powerwalls) to fast-ramping (like flywheels).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Decoupling Effect: One of the most important findings is that active and reactive power control are largely decoupled. Because the battery's inverter often has "spare" capacity when it isn't charging or discharging at max power, that capacity can be used for PFC at almost zero cost to the arbitrage mission.
  • PFC is Myopic: Unlike arbitrage, which requires looking ahead at future prices to be profitable, Power Factor Correction is primarily a "now" problem. The authors found that look-ahead windows don't significantly improve PFC performance; it can be handled effectively in real-time.
  • The "Fast Battery" Penalty: Batteries with faster ramp rates (the ability to charge/discharge very quickly) are much more sensitive to forecasting errors. If the price forecast is wrong, a fast battery can "lose" more potential profit than a slow-ramping one.
  • Converter Sizing Matters: The ability to fix the power factor is limited primarily by the size of the inverter (the converter), not the energy capacity of the battery itself.

Key Results

  • Profit Preservation: In deterministic simulations, the arbitrage profit remained nearly identical (e.g., $0.3367 vs $0.3367) whether or not the battery was also performing PFC.
  • PF Restoration: Without storage, solar integration dropped the minimum power factor of the test house from 0.82 to a dismal 0.15. With the proposed storage control, the PF was successfully maintained at or above the 0.90 limit required by many utilities.
  • Real-Time Success: Even with uncertain forecasts in the MPC framework, the system maintained high mean power factors (above 0.94 in most test cases) while still capturing significant arbitrage gains.

Limitations and Future Work

While the paper provides a robust framework for co-optimization, a few areas remain for future exploration:

  • Battery Aging: While one variant of their algorithm attempts to minimize converter usage to extend hardware life, a more detailed model of battery chemical degradation (cycle vs. calendar life) could be integrated.
  • Network Constraints: The study focuses on a single consumer. Future work could expand this to "feeder-level" control, where multiple batteries and capacitor banks are coordinated across a whole neighborhood to manage voltage limits.
  • Financial Incentives: Currently, many residential users aren't paid to provide reactive power. The authors suggest that analyzing the financial structures (like reactive power charges) necessary to incentivize this behavior is a logical next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

The importance of reactive power compensation for power factor (PF) correction will significantly increase with the large-scale integration of distributed generation interfaced via inverters producing only active power. In this work, we focus on co-optimizing energy storage for performing energy arbitrage as well as local power factor correction. The joint optimization problem is non-convex, but can be solved efficiently using a McCormick relaxation along with penalty-based schemes. Using numerical simulations on real data and realistic storage profiles, we show that energy storage can correct PF locally without reducing arbitrage profit. It is observed that active and reactive power control is largely decoupled in nature for performing arbitrage and PF correction (PFC). Furthermore, we consider a real-time implementation of the problem with uncertain load, renewable and pricing profiles. We develop a model predictive control based storage control policy using auto-regressive forecast for the uncertainty. We observe that PFC is primarily governed by the size of the converter and therefore, look-ahead in time in the online setting does not affect PFC noticeably. However, arbitrage profit are more sensitive to uncertainty for batteries with faster ramp rates compared to slow ramping batteries.
BibTeX
@article{hashmi2020arbitrage,
  author = {Md Umar Hashmi and Deepjyoti Deka and Ana Bušić and Lucas Pereira and Scott Backhaus},
  title = {{Arbitrage With Power Factor Correction Using Energy Storage}},
  journal = {IEEE Transactions on Power Systems},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/tpwrs.2020.2969978},
}

Loading related content...

Figure