Approximating Multi-criteria Max-TSP

Markus Bläser, Bodo Manthey, Oliver Putz

TL;DR

This paper introduces the first randomized approximation algorithms for the multi-criteria Maximum Traveling Salesman Problem (Max-TSP). It provides algorithms that achieve approximation ratios of $1/k - \varepsilon$ for undirected graphs (Max-STSP) and $1/(k+1) - \varepsilon$ for directed graphs (Max-ATSP), where $k$ is the number of objective functions. This is a significant step towards solving complex optimization problems with multiple, potentially conflicting, goals.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) is a classic optimization challenge: find the shortest possible route that visits a set of cities and returns to the origin. The "Max-TSP" variant flips this to find the longest possible route. This might seem counterintuitive, but it has applications in areas like maximizing coverage or resource utilization.

The real complexity arises when we introduce multi-criteria optimization. Imagine choosing a car: you might want it to be cheap, fast, and fuel-efficient. These are multiple, often competing, objectives. In a multi-criteria Max-TSP, we're not just looking for a single "best" route based on one criterion, but a set of "Pareto optimal" routes that represent the best possible trade-offs between several criteria. Finding these exact trade-offs (the Pareto curve) is computationally very hard, often requiring exponential time. This paper tackles the problem of finding approximate Pareto curves for multi-criteria Max-TSP, meaning we want to find a set of routes that are "close enough" to the true optimal trade-offs, and do so efficiently.

Methods

The core of the paper's approach lies in a clever decomposition technique and a reduction strategy.

  • Cycle Cover Decomposition: The algorithms first compute an approximate Pareto curve of cycle covers. A cycle cover is a set of vertex-disjoint cycles that together cover all vertices. Hamiltonian cycles (the goal of TSP) are a special case of cycle covers. The key idea is to decompose these cycle covers into paths.
  • Light-weight vs. Heavy-weight Edges: A crucial distinction is made between edges that contribute little to the overall weight across all objectives ("light-weight") and those that contribute significantly to at least one objective ("heavy-weight").
  • Decomposition Algorithms: For light-weight cycle covers, they develop deterministic and randomized algorithms (DECOMPOSE and RANDDECOMPOSE) to break them down into paths while preserving a significant portion of their weight. For heavy-weight edges, a more intricate strategy is employed.
  • Recursive Reduction: For heavy-weight edges, the problem is reduced to a simpler, multi-criteria Max-TSP instance with one fewer objective. This is achieved by carefully contracting paths and removing the objective function associated with the heavy-weight edge. This recursive process, combined with the decomposition of light-weight cycle covers, forms the basis of their approximation algorithms.
  • Randomization: The algorithms rely on randomization for computing approximate Pareto curves of cycle covers and for the recursive calls. The success probability is amplified to ensure a high likelihood of finding a good approximation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The problem is theoretical and focuses on algorithmic design rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Decomposition: The ability to break down complex cycle covers into manageable paths is fundamental. The distinction between light-weight and heavy-weight edges is key to handling the multi-objective nature of the problem.
  • Recursive Trade-off Management: The strategy of reducing the problem by one objective when a "heavy" edge is encountered is a powerful way to manage conflicting goals. It allows the algorithm to focus on a subset of objectives at each step.
  • Tightness of Approximation Ratios: The paper provides examples that demonstrate the limits of their decomposition techniques, suggesting that the derived approximation ratios are likely optimal for this algorithmic approach.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: While the problem is theoretical, the algorithms are designed to be efficient, with running times polynomial in the input size and the inverse of the approximation error ($\varepsilon$), making them potentially practical for certain applications.

Key Results

The paper presents the following main results:

  • Max-STSP (Undirected): A randomized approximation algorithm with an approximation ratio of $\frac{1}{k} - \varepsilon$ for $k > 1$ objective functions.
  • Max-ATSP (Directed): A randomized approximation algorithm with an approximation ratio of $\frac{1}{k+1} - \epsilon$ for $k$ objective functions.
  • Running Time: The algorithms have running times that are polynomial in the input size and $1/\varepsilon$, but exponential in the number of criteria $k$. However, for a small, constant number of criteria, this is efficient.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Exponential Dependence on k: The most significant limitation is that the running time is exponential in the number of criteria $k$. While efficient for small $k$, it becomes impractical as $k$ grows.
  • Conjecture for Ω(1/log k) Decompositions: The authors conjecture that better decompositions (Ω(1/log k)) might exist, which could lead to improved approximation algorithms, especially for larger $k$.
  • Heavy-weight Edge Handling: The techniques for handling heavy-weight edges are complex and might be a bottleneck for further improvements. Developing new methods for these cases is a promising direction.
  • Open Problem for Max-TSP: The paper notes that while approximations for multi-criteria Min-TSP exist, this work addresses the less-studied Max-TSP variant, leaving room for further exploration in this specific domain.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present randomized approximation algorithms for multi-criteria Max-TSP. For Max-STSP with k > 1 objective functions, we obtain an approximation ratio of \(\frac 1k - \varepsilon\) for arbitrarily small ε> 0. For Max-ATSP with k objective functions, we obtain a ratio of \(\frac{1}{k+1} - \varepsilon\).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{blaser2008approximating,
  author = {Markus Bläser and Bodo Manthey and Oliver Putz},
  title = {{Approximating Multi-criteria Max-TSP}},
  booktitle = {ESA},
  year = {2008},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ORTBLmNQSq},
}
Figure