Abstract
As data-driven methods are deployed in real-world settings, the processes that generate the observed data will often react to the decisions of the learner. For example, a data source may have some incentive for the algorithm to provide a particular label (e.g. approve a bank loan), and manipulate their features accordingly. Work in strategic classification and decision-dependent distributions seeks to characterize the closed-loop behavior of deploying learning algorithms by explicitly considering the effect of the classifier on the underlying data distribution. More recently, works in performative prediction seek to classify the closed-loop behavior by considering general properties of the mapping from classifier to data distribution, rather than an explicit form. Building on this notion, we analyze repeated risk minimization as the perturbed trajectories of the gradient flows of performative risk minimization. We consider the case where there may be multiple local minimizers of performative risk, motivated by situations where the initial conditions may have significant impact on the long-term behavior of the system. We provide sufficient conditions to characterize the region of attraction for the various equilibria in this settings. Additionally, we introduce the notion of performative alignment, which provides a geometric condition on the convergence of repeated risk minimization to performative risk minimizers.
Introduction
When machine learning models are deployed, they often change the very data they are trying to predict—a phenomenon called performative prediction. This paper provides a control-theoretic framework to analyze "echo chambers" in these systems, offering mathematical tools to predict which local equilibrium a model will settle into based on its initial starting point.
In classical machine learning, we assume the data distribution is a fixed target. However, in the real world, the "target" moves in response to the model. For example, if a bank uses a specific credit scoring model, loan applicants will change their financial behavior to get a better score. This creates a feedback loop. Previous research often focused on finding a single, globally stable point. However, if multiple stable points exist, the model might fall into different "echo chambers"—self-fulfilling prophecies where initial bias shapes data, reinforcing that same bias. This paper characterizes the regions of attraction: the set of initial parameters leading to a specific local equilibrium.
Methodology
The authors treat the learning process as a dynamical system, comparing two types of gradient flows:
- Performative Risk Minimization (PRM) Flow: The ideal scenario where the learner accounts for distribution shifts.
- Repeated Risk Minimization (RGD) Flow: The realistic scenario where the learner ignores shifts and updates based on current data.
To analyze these, they utilize Lyapunov Functions for stability proofs, Perturbation Analysis to view RGD as a perturbed PRM flow, and a novel Performative Alignment geometric condition. This condition ensures that as long as model updates don't deviate too far from the true risk gradient, convergence to a desirable local minimum is maintained.
Experimental Setup
The framework is validated using synthetic environments:
- Bernoulli Distribution with Squared Error: A 1D toy model used to visualize multiple equilibria and regions of attraction.
- Adversarial Agents: A classification simulation where agents strategically manipulate features to avoid specific classifications under a logistic loss function.
Key Results and Insights
- Echo Chambers as Local Minima: Different initializations can lead to vastly different long-term outcomes in decision-dependent systems. The risk landscape can be complex, as seen in the adversarial agent simulation.
- RGD as Perturbed PRM: Using robust control theory, the authors provide "ultimate bounds" on how close a model gets to the optimal point despite ignoring distribution shifts.
- Convergence Guarantees: Theorem 1 proves that under certain curvature conditions, RGD flow converges exponentially fast to a neighborhood around a local performative risk minimizer.
- Attraction Regions: The authors provide a formula to under-approximate "safe" regions of attraction, showing high accuracy in 1D simulations (e.g., calculating a safe region of $|x| \le 0.21$ for a true region of $x < 0.23$).
Limitations and Future Work
While the theoretical results are robust, verifying the required curvature properties in high-dimensional deep learning models remains challenging. Furthermore, the framework assumes some knowledge of the distribution shift mapping $D(x)$, which is often a "black box" in practice. Future work involves developing conditions that don't require full knowledge of the shift, potentially integrating reinforcement learning or bandit algorithms.
Summary updated