Applying machine learning techniques to improve user acceptance on ubiquitous environement

Djallel Bouneffouf

Introduction

Ubiquitous computing aims to provide the right information at the right time and place via mobile devices. However, these systems face two major hurdles: the cold-start problem and interest evolution. When a user first interacts with a system, the lack of prior data often leads to irrelevant recommendations, causing immediate abandonment. Furthermore, user interests are dynamic, shifting based on context such as time, location, and social setting.

Traditional Reinforcement Learning (RL) is effective at adapting to change but requires a "random" exploration phase that can feel intrusive to new users. Conversely, Collaborative Filtering (CF) provides strong initial guesses based on similar users but fails to track individual interest shifts over time. This paper proposes CF-QL, a hybrid algorithm that combines CF with RL to solve these issues, ensuring the system remains useful from the very first interaction.

System Architecture and Methodology

The core innovation of CF-QL (Collaborative Filtering for Q-Learning) lies in its approach to the classic "exploration vs. exploitation" trade-off. The system operates within a perception-action loop, interacting with the user's environment to refine its recommendations.

System architecture illustrating the perception-action loop between the sensor module, recommender system, and environment.

In standard Q-Learning, the system occasionally picks a random action (exploration) to discover better rewards. In CF-QL, this random step is replaced with Memory-based Collaborative Filtering. Instead of guessing blindly, the system suggests actions based on the habits of the user's social or professional group. By "exploring" using the wisdom of the crowd, the system maintains user trust while the RL agent learns the individual's specific nuances.

Experimental Evaluation

The algorithm was tested using an experimental platform developed in C# and a context simulator. The scenario involved "Paul," a new sales representative at a company. The system started with zero knowledge of Paul but had access to the behavioral data of ten colleagues. The goal was to recommend the correct resource (e.g., a client's register of complaints) when Paul arrived at a specific context (midday in Paris).

Results and Discussion

The performance of CF-QL was compared against standard Q-Learning (QL) and pure Memory-based Collaborative Filtering (MCF) over 100 trials, measuring Precision (the percentage of recommendations the user actually interacted with).

Precision comparison of MCF, QL, and CF-QL algorithms over 100 trials.

Key findings include:

  • Superior Early Performance: CF-QL significantly outperformed standard Q-Learning in the early stages because its initial "guesses" were socially informed rather than random.
  • Personalization Over Time: While pure CF performed well initially, CF-QL eventually overtook it. The RL component allowed the system to personalize the experience to Paul’s unique deviations from the group norm.
  • Sustained Accuracy: The precision curves demonstrate that CF-QL maintained higher or equal precision compared to the other two algorithms throughout the trial period, proving it is both "ready-to-use" and capable of life-long learning.

Conclusion

CF-QL demonstrates that "exploration" in machine learning can be socially informed to improve user acceptance. By treating acceptability as a technical constraint, the system avoids the pitfalls of the cold-start problem. Future work will focus on testing with real users in unpredictable environments and integrating more complex context dimensions, such as cognitive and spatial data, to further refine the recommendation engine.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ubiquitous information access becomes more and more important nowadays and research is aimed at making it adapted to users. Our work consists in applying machine learning techniques in order to adapt the information access provided by ubiquitous systems to users when the system only knows the user social group, without knowing anything about the user’s interest. The adaptation procedures associate actions to perceived situations of the user. Associations are based on feedback given by the user as a reaction to the behavior of the system. Our method brings a solution to some of the problems concerning the acceptance of the system by users when applying machine learning techniques to systems at the beginning of the interaction between the system and the user.
BibTeX
@misc{bouneffouf2013applying,
  author = {Djallel Bouneffouf},
  title = {{Applying machine learning techniques to improve user acceptance on ubiquitous environement}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1301.4351},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1301.4351},
}
Figure