Applying a Goal-Directed Behavior Model to Determine Risk Perception of COVID-19 and War on Potential Travelers’ Behavioral Intentions

Taeuk Kim, Jung-Woo HaInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study applies the Model of Goal-Directed Behavior (MGB) to understand how potential travelers' perceptions of COVID-19 and war risks influence their intentions to travel internationally. It reveals that while both risks increase uncertainty and negatively impact mental well-being, "desire" acts as a crucial mediator to behavioral intentions, with gender playing a moderating role in some relationships.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent geopolitical instability (like the war in Ukraine) have created a complex and uncertain environment for international travel. Previous research has largely focused on COVID-19 risk perception, but this paper addresses the need to understand how the concurrent perception of both COVID-19 and war risks affects potential travelers' psychological states (uncertainty, mental well-being) and ultimately their behavioral intentions. It seeks to bridge the gap by integrating these dual risks into a comprehensive model of travel decision-making.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative approach using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) based on the Model of Goal-Directed Behavior (MGB). The MGB framework, which incorporates stimulus-organism-response (SOR) principles, was used to analyze the relationships between:

  • Stimuli: COVID-19 Risk Perception (CRP) and War Risk Perception (WRP).
  • Organism: Uncertainty toward International Travel (UIT) and Mental Well-being toward International Travel (MW).
  • Response: Desire (DS) and Behavioral Intentions toward International Travel (BI).

Data was collected through an online survey of potential travelers in Korea. Statistical analyses included Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA), correlation analysis, SEM, and moderation effect analysis (specifically for gender).

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 361 surveys collected from potential travelers in Korea between September 2nd and October 2nd, 2022. Participants were screened to ensure they had experienced international travel in the past 1-2 years.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Risk Perception is Key: The study highlights that understanding travel intentions requires considering both pandemic and geopolitical risks, not just one in isolation.
  • Desire as the Bridge: "Desire" emerges as a critical psychological construct that translates negative perceptions (uncertainty, poor mental well-being) into actual travel intentions. This emphasizes the emotional and motivational drivers of travel decisions.
  • Gendered Responses: While both genders are affected by risks, women appear to have a stronger negative reaction to CRP and WRP impacting their mental well-being, and a stronger influence of mental well-being on their desire to travel. This suggests that travel marketing might need to consider gender-specific messaging.
  • Uncertainty and Well-being as Mediators: Both uncertainty and mental well-being are shown to mediate the relationship between risk perceptions and desire, underscoring their importance in the decision-making process.

Key Results

  • Hypotheses 1-5 Supported:
    • COVID-19 Risk Perception (CRP) positively affects Uncertainty (UIT) and negatively affects Mental Well-being (MW).
  • War Risk Perception (WRP) positively affects Uncertainty (UIT) and negatively affects Mental Well-being (MW).
  • Uncertainty (UIT) negatively affects Desire (DS).
  • Mental Well-being (MW) positively affects Desire (DS).
  • Desire (DS) positively affects Behavioral Intentions (BI).
  • Gender Moderation (Hypotheses 6b, d, f Supported):
    • Gender significantly moderates the relationship between CRP and MW.
  • Gender significantly moderates the relationship between WRP and MW.
  • Gender significantly moderates the relationship between MW and DS.
  • Specifically, women showed a stronger negative effect of CRP and WRP on MW, and a stronger positive effect of MW on DS compared to men.
  • Gender Moderation (Hypotheses 6a, c, e, g Not Supported): Gender did not significantly moderate the relationships between CRP and UIT, WRP and UIT, UIT and DS, or DS and BI.
  • Predictive Power: The model demonstrated good predictive power, with R² values for UIT (0.378), MW (0.370), DS (0.672), and BI (0.530).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Representativeness: The study acknowledges a limitation in the underrepresentation of respondents aged 50 and older, suggesting that future research should aim for a more balanced sample across age groups.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on international travel generally. Future research could benefit from examining specific popular destinations (e.g., China, USA for Korean travelers) to provide more nuanced insights.
  • COVID-19 Status: The study did not differentiate based on whether respondents or their acquaintances had contracted COVID-19. Future work could explore the impact of direct/indirect personal experience with the virus on risk perception and travel intentions.
  • Longitudinal Study: Given the ongoing nature of the pandemic and geopolitical situations, the authors suggest that long-term, large-scale studies are needed to fully understand these influences.
  • Destination-Specific Risk: The study could be expanded to explore how destination-specific factors (e.g., quarantine policies, perceived safety) interact with general risk perceptions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to verify the influence of the relationship between risk perception of COVID-19 and the war-applied Model of Goal-directed Behavior (MGB) based on stimulus-organism-response (SOR) and potential travelers' behavioral intention. In addition, this study attempted to verify the relationship among uncertainty toward international travel, mental well-being toward international travel, and desire toward travelers' behavioral intention. Moreover, we examined the moderating effect of gender (female vs. male) among all variables for dependents. The survey was conducted on potential travelers in Korea. As for the survey period, a survey was conducted for one month beginning on 2 September 2022. Of the total 413 surveys, 361 surveys were used for the final analysis, and 52 unfaithful surveys were excluded. In addition, demographic, CFA, correlation analysis, structural equation modeling, and moderation effect analysis were verified using SPSS and AMOS. For the data analysis, we used SPSS 18.0 and Amos 20.0 to perform factor analysis and SEM. Significant effects were found in support for Hypotheses 1-5. Further, when it comes to the difference of gender on the relationship between all the variables, while no significant effect was found for Hypotheses 6a,c,e,g, a significant effect was found for Hypotheses 6b,d,f. Thus, H6a,c,e were rejected and H6b,d,f were supported. It was found that females had a greater influence on mental health and desire for overseas travel than males, but it was found that there was no difference between females and males in the relationship between desire and behavioral intention. Therefore, it was possible to verify that the MGB desire is an important psychological variable for both females and males. Furthermore, these findings offer academic practical implications to travel and tourism companies by presenting basic data based on the results of empirical research analysis in the context of the current dangerous situation.
BibTeX
@article{kim2023applying,
  author = {Taeuk Kim and Jung-Woo Ha},
  title = {{Applying a Goal-Directed Behavior Model to Determine Risk Perception of COVID-19 and War on Potential Travelers’ Behavioral Intentions}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20032562},
}
Figure