Anytime Guarantees for Reachability in Uncountable Markov Decision Processes

Kush Grover, Jan Kretínský, Tobias Meggendorfer, Maximilian Weininger

TL;DR

This paper introduces the first "anytime" algorithms for computing reachability probabilities in Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) with continuous state and action spaces. These algorithms provide provably correct lower and upper bounds that iteratively improve, allowing for arbitrary precision, even for systems where exact solutions are impossible.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world systems, like robots navigating complex environments or resource management systems, are best modeled by Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) with continuous (uncountable) state and action spaces. Analyzing these systems for critical properties like "reachability" (e.g., "will the robot reach its goal?") is crucial but incredibly challenging. While some methods can approximate these probabilities, they often lack guarantees on the precision of their results, making them unsuitable for safety-critical applications. The core problem is that exact computation of reachability in these systems is generally undecidable, requiring a careful balance between making sufficient assumptions for analysis and keeping those assumptions as weak as possible.

Methods

The authors adapt and extend classical Value Iteration (VI) and Bounded Real-Time Dynamic Programming (BRTDP) algorithms to handle uncountable state and action spaces. Key to their approach are:

  • Lipschitz Continuity: Assuming the value function is Lipschitz continuous (with a known constant) allows for extrapolating information from sampled states to their continuous surroundings. This is a crucial assumption for bridging the gap between finite samples and uncountable spaces.
  • Approximation Schemes: They introduce "Maximum Approximation" and "Transition Approximation" to handle the continuous nature of actions and transitions, allowing for under- and over-approximation of values up to a desired precision.
  • State-Action Sampling: Instead of updating all states, they use a "GETPAIR" oracle to sample state-action pairs, making the process tractable. This oracle has specific fairness requirements to ensure all relevant parts of the system are eventually explored.
  • Anytime Algorithms: The algorithms are designed to be "anytime," meaning they can be stopped at any point and will return the best available bounds with a known precision. This is achieved by iteratively refining both lower and upper bounds.
  • Absorption Assumption: To guarantee convergence of upper bounds, they introduce an "Absorption" assumption, which ensures that the system eventually reaches a target or a designated "sink" state, preventing problematic "end components" that can stall convergence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical algorithms and their properties, with experimental evaluation on custom-built one- and two-dimensional navigation models.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: The paper demonstrates that by carefully combining Lipschitz continuity with approximation techniques, it's possible to derive provably correct bounds for reachability in uncountable MDPs, a problem previously considered intractable for guaranteed analysis.
  • Anytime Guarantees are Possible: The development of an "anytime" algorithm means that users can obtain useful, albeit less precise, results quickly, and then let the algorithm run longer for higher accuracy, offering a practical trade-off between computation time and precision.
  • Weakening Assumptions: The authors meticulously analyze and justify their assumptions, aiming to push the boundaries of what's analytically possible while still maintaining correctness guarantees. They argue why each assumption is necessary for algorithms relying on finite observations.
  • General Templates: The proposed algorithms are presented as general templates, capable of incorporating various heuristics and domain-specific knowledge, making them adaptable to a wide range of problems.

Key Results

  • First Anytime Algorithms: The paper presents the first algorithms that provide anytime guarantees (iteratively improving lower and upper bounds with known precision) for reachability in general uncountable MDPs.
  • Provable Correctness: The algorithms are proven to be correct under a set of carefully defined, relatively weak assumptions.
  • Experimental Validation: A prototype implementation on one- and two-dimensional navigation models demonstrated the algorithms' effectiveness, achieving required precision within reasonable timeframes and memory usage. For instance, a one-dimensional model converged to a precision of $\epsilon=0.05$ in 236,000 updates, taking 9 seconds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumption D (Absorption): The authors acknowledge that the "Absorption" assumption, while crucial for upper bound convergence, is restrictive. They conjecture it could be weakened by developing methods to automatically find and treat problematic "end components."
  • Lipschitz Constant Acquisition: The paper assumes the Lipschitz constant is known. Acquiring this constant in practice can be challenging and is a direction for future work.
  • Discontinuities: While the paper discusses extensions to handle discontinuities, a more robust treatment is suggested.
  • Practical Efficiency: The current algorithms are presented as theoretical templates. Future work will focus on optimizing their practical efficiency and applying them to more complex, real-world systems.
  • Linear Temporal Logic (LTL): Extending the approach to handle LTL queries for uncountable MDPs is identified as a challenging but promising area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the problem of approximating the reachability probabilities in Markov decision processes (MDP) with uncountable (continuous) state and action spaces. While there are algorithms that, for special classes of such MDP, provide a sequence of approximations converging to the true value in the limit, our aim is to obtain an algorithm with guarantees on the precision of the approximation. As this problem is undecidable in general, assumptions on the MDP are necessary. Our main contribution is to identify sufficient assumptions that are as weak as possible, thus approaching the "boundary" of which systems can be correctly and reliably analyzed. To this end, we also argue why each of our assumptions is necessary for algorithms based on processing finitely many observations. We present two solution variants. The first one provides converging lower bounds under weaker assumptions than typical ones from previous works concerned with guarantees. The second one then utilizes stronger assumptions to additionally provide converging upper bounds. Altogether, we obtain an anytime algorithm, i.e. yielding a sequence of approximants with known and iteratively improving precision, converging to the true value in the limit. Besides, due to the generality of our assumptions, our algorithms are very general templates, readily allowing for various heuristics from literature in contrast to, e.g., a specific discretization algorithm. Our theoretical contribution thus paves the way for future practical improvements without sacrificing correctness guarantees.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{grover2022anytime,
  author = {Kush Grover and Jan Kretínský and Tobias Meggendorfer and Maximilian Weininger},
  title = {{Anytime Guarantees for Reachability in Uncountable Markov Decision Processes}},
  booktitle = {CONCUR},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.4230/lipics.concur.2022.11},
}
Figure