Anxiety-impulsivity subtypes in adolescent internalizing disorder are characterized by distinguishable neurodevelopmental, neurocognitive and clinical trajectory signatures

Huaxin Fan, Nanyu Kuang, Xinran Wu, Gechang Yu, Tianye Jia, Barbara J. Sahakian, Trevor W. Robbins, Günter Schumann, Jianfeng Feng, Benjamin Becker, Jie ZhangmedRxiv 2021 · DOI

Introduction

Internalizing disorders, such as anxiety and depression, are among the most prevalent mental health challenges faced by adolescents. However, clinical presentations within these categories are notoriously heterogeneous. A critical point of contention in psychiatric research is the relationship between anxiety and impulsivity. While traditional views often associate anxiety with behavioral inhibition and risk avoidance, emerging evidence suggests that for some individuals, anxiety can drive impulsive, "urgency-based" behaviors as a maladaptive coping mechanism.

This study addresses this complexity by moving beyond traditional diagnostic labels toward a transdiagnostic framework. By examining the interaction between internalizing symptoms and impulsivity facets, researchers aimed to identify distinct subtypes of adolescent internalizing disorders and determine if these subtypes possess unique neurodevelopmental, neurocognitive, and clinical signatures.

Methodology

To investigate these subtypes, researchers utilized data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study, a comprehensive longitudinal study involving nearly 12,000 children in the United States. The analysis focused on a target group of 2,437 adolescents (aged 9–10) diagnosed with internalizing disorders but no comorbid ADHD or conduct issues at baseline, alongside 4,066 healthy controls.

Data-Driven Clustering

The researchers employed a combination of hierarchical and non-hierarchical (K-means) clustering strategies. Rather than grouping participants by clinical diagnosis, they used the five facets of the UPPS-P scale: negative urgency, lack of planning, lack of perseverance, sensation seeking, and positive urgency.

Neuroimaging and Longitudinal Tracking

Structural MRI was used to measure cortical thickness, a key indicator of brain maturation. In healthy adolescence, the brain typically undergoes "synaptic pruning," resulting in a thinning of the cortex as neural networks become more efficient. Additionally, the study tracked participants over a two-year follow-up period to observe how symptoms and neuroanatomy evolved, utilizing cross-lagged panel models (CLPM) to determine the direction of influence between anxiety and impulsivity.

Key Insights: The Impulsivity Split

The clustering analysis revealed two distinct subtypes of internalizing patients, both exhibiting comparable levels of high anxiety but diametrically opposed impulsivity profiles:

  • Subtype 1 (High Impulsivity): Characterized by high anxiety and significantly elevated impulsivity compared to healthy controls.
  • Subtype 2 (Low Impulsivity): Characterized by high anxiety but lower-than-average impulsivity (even compared to healthy controls).

The "Maturational Mismatch"

Neuroimaging revealed that Subtype 1 (high-impulsivity) adolescents possessed thicker prefrontal and temporal cortical regions. In the context of early adolescence, a thicker cortex is often a marker of neurodevelopmental delay, suggesting a failure or delay in the pruning process necessary for mature executive control and emotional regulation. In contrast, Subtype 2 did not show significant cortical thickness alterations compared to controls. These neuroanatomical profiles remained stable over the two-year follow-up, suggesting they represent ingrained developmental signatures.

Divergent Clinical Trajectories

The two subtypes followed remarkably different paths over the two-year study period:

  1. Risk and Dysfunction: Subtype 1 reported significantly higher rates of suicidal ideation and depressive symptoms. They also showed a higher rate of transition into "externalizing" disorders, such as ADHD or Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD).
  2. Cognitive Performance: Subtype 1 demonstrated impaired neurocognitive and educational performance. Conversely, Subtype 2 showed higher crystallized intelligence and better academic grades than even the healthy control group, suggesting that their inhibited, low-impulsivity nature may provide a temporary academic advantage despite their anxiety.
  3. Coping Mechanisms: The relationship between anxiety and impulsivity functioned differently in each group. In Subtype 1, baseline anxiety predicted increased impulsivity (specifically a lack of perseverance) two years later. In Subtype 2, baseline anxiety predicted decreased sensation-seeking, indicating a defensive avoidance strategy.

Discussion and Implications

The findings underscore that impulsivity—not just the presence of anxiety—is a critical determinant of risk in adolescent internalizing disorders. The high-impulsivity subtype represents a particularly vulnerable group characterized by neurodevelopmental delays and a higher risk for behavioral dysregulation and suicidality.

Limitations and Future Directions

While this study provides a robust structural framework, the authors note that future research should incorporate functional MRI to examine how these "thicker" brain regions communicate. Additionally, the higher prevalence of females in Subtype 2 suggests that sex-specific developmental pathways warrant further investigation.

Conclusion

Identifying these subtypes allows for a more nuanced approach to adolescent mental health. Adolescents in the high-impulsivity category may require early, specific interventions—such as targeted Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) focusing on urgency and regulatory control—to mitigate the risk of transitioning into more severe externalizing behaviors or self-harm. By recognizing impulsivity as a key moderator of internalizing disorders, clinicians can better predict clinical trajectories and tailor treatments to the individual's specific neurodevelopmental profile.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background Anxiety and impulsivity represent transdiagnostic pathology dimensions yet their interaction and contribution to emotional disorders in adolescence and to disease development remain controversial, and previous studies indicate heterogeneity within the broad category of internalizing disorders. Methods A combination of hierarchical and non-hierarchical clustering strategies was employed to determine impulsivity-related subtypes (based on the facets of negative urgency, lack of planning, lack of perseverance, sensation seeking and positive urgency in UPPS-P scales) in a large cohort of adolescents with internalizing disorders (n=2437) from Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study. Linear mixed-effect models were employed to determine cortical thickness alterations of the subtypes. Results Data-driven clustering identified two distinct subtypes of internalizing patients (subtype 1/subtype 2) with comparable levels of increased anxiety yet distinguishable levels of impulsivity, i.e., enhanced (subtype 1) or decreased (subtype 2) compared to healthy controls. Subtype 1 was further characterized by thicker prefrontal and temporal cortical regions involved in regulatory control and fear processing, while subtype 2 did not demonstrate significant thickness alterations. The differential neuroanatomical profiles remained stable over the two-year follow-up, while the two subtypes had different neurodevelopmental trajectories. Subtype 1 additionally reported more psychopathology and dysfunctionality including higher suicidal ideation, depressive symptoms and transition rates to externalizing disorders during follow-up as well as impaired neurocognitive and educational performance compared to subtype 2. Moreover, for subtype 1, anxiety at baseline (9-10 years) was significantly positively associated with impulsivity (lack of perseverance) at 2-year follow-up, while in subtype 2, baseline anxiety was significantly negatively associated with impulsivity (sensation seeking) at 2-year follow-up. Conclusions Our results demonstrate an impulsivity-dependent heterogeneity in adolescent internalizing disorders, with high-impulsivity patients being characterized by neurodevelopmental delay at the neural and cognitive levels. Individuals with elevated impulsivity are at a greater risk to develop behavioral dysregulation over the following two years and may thus require specific early interventions.
BibTeX
@misc{fan2021anxiety,
  author = {Huaxin Fan and Nanyu Kuang and Xinran Wu and Gechang Yu and Tianye Jia and Barbara J. Sahakian and Trevor W. Robbins and Günter Schumann and Jianfeng Feng and Benjamin Becker and Jie Zhang},
  title = {{Anxiety-impulsivity subtypes in adolescent internalizing disorder are characterized by distinguishable neurodevelopmental, neurocognitive and clinical trajectory signatures}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.10.30.21265692},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure