TL;DR
This systematic review synthesizes data from 229 global chilled water (CHW) plant case studies (2014-2025) to benchmark current operational energy efficiency and identify key improvement drivers. It reveals that while optimization yields significant gains (median 18.87%), a substantial portion of systems still fall short of top-tier efficiency standards, highlighting room for further advancement.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Improving the energy efficiency of chilled water (CHW) plants is crucial for reducing overall building energy consumption and meeting carbon neutrality goals. However, existing research on CHW plant performance is fragmented, often focusing on isolated cases or specific conditions. This lack of a broad, synthesized understanding hinders the ability to effectively revise standards, guide retrofit strategies, and assess operational effectiveness across diverse global contexts. The paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive, systematic review of annual operational energy efficiency in CHW plants.
Methods
The study employs a systematic literature review methodology. It involved an extensive search across academic databases (Web of Science and CNKI) using keywords related to CHW systems, energy performance, and optimization. A rigorous screening process, including full-text review, was used to select 124 publications reporting on 229 individual CHW plant cases. The analysis involved multi-dimensional categorization of these cases based on characteristics like climate zone, building type, chiller technology, and evaluation methods. Crucially, the study focuses on the annual operation energy efficiency ratio (EERao) as the primary performance metric, as it accounts for seasonal variations and provides a more holistic view than short-term metrics. The collected data was then analyzed to benchmark performance against international standards and identify factors influencing efficiency improvements.
Datasets
The study analyzed data from 229 individual CHW plant cases compiled from 124 publications spanning 2014 to 2025. These cases were sourced from the Web of Science and China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) databases. The paper does not introduce a new, curated dataset but rather synthesizes existing published data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- EERao is King for Annual Performance: The paper strongly advocates for EERao as the most robust metric for evaluating CHW plant performance due to its ability to capture year-round operational dynamics, unlike single-point or short-term metrics.
- Optimization Works, But Potential Remains: While optimization efforts consistently improve efficiency, a significant percentage of even optimized systems don't reach the highest efficiency tiers defined by U.S. and Chinese standards. This suggests that current optimization strategies, while effective, may not be fully exploiting the potential.
- Context Matters: Climate and Capacity are Key: The study highlights that climate zone and nominal cooling capacity (NCC) are significant drivers of CHW plant performance and must be integrated into future rating frameworks for more accurate benchmarking.
- Low-Hanging Fruit: Lower Baseline Efficiency = Higher Gains: Systems starting with lower initial energy efficiency offer substantially greater potential for improvement compared to those already performing well. This implies a need for tailored optimization goals based on baseline performance.
- Holistic Approach Wins: Combining equipment upgrades with operational control strategies yields significantly better efficiency improvements than relying on control strategies alone.
Key Results
- Overall Efficiency Gain: Optimization efforts led to an average efficiency gain of 18.87%. The median EERao increased from 4.61 (unoptimized) to 5.48 (optimized).
- Shortfall in Top Tiers: Despite improvements, 34.41% (U.S. standards) and 59.04% (Chinese standards) of optimized cases still failed to meet top-tier efficiency levels.
- Climate Influence: A consistent performance hierarchy was observed: HSWW > HSCW > Cold, both pre- and post-optimization.
- Capacity Influence: Systems with larger NCC (≥1758 kW) consistently demonstrated higher energy efficiency than smaller systems.
- Baseline Efficiency Impact: Systems with baseline EERao < 3.0 achieved an average improvement of 69.46%, while those with EERao ≥ 5.0 saw an average improvement of only 13.29%.
- Strategy Effectiveness: Combined equipment and control upgrades achieved a median improvement of 35.35%, significantly outperforming pure control-only approaches (10.76%).
- Control Strategy Comparison: Model-based and model-free control strategies yielded comparable median improvements (11.02% vs. 10.00%), suggesting implementation context is crucial.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Fragmentation: The study acknowledges that current CHW plant case studies are highly fragmented, with limited availability of detailed public data. This restricts the ability to perform more granular, statistically robust subgroup analyses.
- Standardization Needed: The paper emphasizes the pressing need to promote the broader adoption of annualized performance indicators like EERao and ECao in research and reporting to enable more accurate, systematic, and holistic assessments.
- Future Research Directions:
- Establish a global, open-access database of CHW plant energy efficiency cases to facilitate standardized reporting and large-scale cross-case analysis.
- Develop future EERao rating standards that explicitly incorporate climatic zoning and cooling capacity segmentation.
- Conduct cost-benefit analyses for equipment retrofits to determine feasibility and scalability.
- Explore optimization strategies considering economic cost, implementation complexity, robustness, and long-term stability, not just energy savings.
- Investigate the influence of implementation context and external boundary conditions on control strategy effectiveness.
Summary updated