Annotating Macromolecular Complexes in the Protein Data Bank: Improving the FAIRness of Structure Data

Sri Devan Appasamy, John M. Berrisford, Romana Gáborová, Sreenath Nair, Stephen Anyango, Sergei Grudinin, Mandar Deshpande, David Armstrong, Ivanna Pidruchna, Joseph I. J. Ellaway, Grisell Díaz Leines, Deepti Gupta, Déborah Harrus, Mihály Váradi, Sameer Velankar

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to standardize the naming and identification of macromolecular complexes within the Protein Data Bank (PDB). By integrating external databases, they've successfully named over 90% of unique assemblies, significantly improving data findability and reusability for researchers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Protein Data Bank (PDB) is a crucial repository for experimentally determined 3D structures of biological molecules. However, a major challenge has been the lack of standardized naming conventions for macromolecular complexes. This ambiguity makes it difficult for researchers to consistently identify and retrieve all instances of the same biological assembly, hindering in-depth analysis of their dynamics, conformation, and functional states. Imagine trying to find all studies on "hemoglobin" when some entries are labeled "adult human hemoglobin," others "fetal hemoglobin," and some even describe subunits individually. This inconsistency makes searching and comparing data across different PDB entries a significant hurdle.

Methods

The core of this work lies in an automated pipeline that leverages external biological databases to annotate PDB assemblies. The process involves:

  • Component Mapping: Individual components within an assembly are mapped to external identifiers. Proteins are linked to UniProt accessions, and RNA molecules to Rfam. Antibody annotations are also incorporated.
  • Description Label Generation: For components that can be mapped, a description label is created using their accession and stoichiometry. For unmapped components, PDB entry-id, entity-id, and stoichiometry are used.
  • Unique Identifier Creation: These description labels are combined to create a unique identifier for each distinct assembly composition.
  • External Database Integration: These unique identifiers are then compared against the Complex Portal for matching entries. If a match is found, the Complex Portal's name is assigned. For homomeric protein assemblies, UniProt names are used.
  • Naming Hierarchy: A decision tree guides the naming process, prioritizing Complex Portal names, then UniProt names, and incorporating component types (DNA, RNA, antibody) for assemblies with additional components. Gene Ontology (GO) terms and a manually curated list of complex names are also utilized.
  • Sub- and Super-Assembly Identification: The approach also defines and identifies sub-assemblies (components of larger assemblies) and super-assemblies (assemblies containing other assemblies).
  • Symmetry Analysis: The AnAnaS software is used to infer point-group symmetry operators for assemblies, identifying common symmetries like cyclic (Cn) and dihedral (Dn).

Datasets

The primary dataset is the Protein Data Bank (PDB) itself, containing experimentally determined macromolecular structures. The method also heavily relies on and integrates data from:

  • UniProt: A comprehensive database of protein sequences and functional information.
  • Rfam: A database of non-coding RNA families.
  • Complex Portal: A curated resource of macromolecular complexes.
  • Gene Ontology (GO): A structured vocabulary describing gene product functions.
  • ANARCI: A tool for antibody numbering.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather enhances the existing PDB data by providing standardized annotations and identifiers.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Integration: This work powerfully demonstrates how integrating multiple specialized biological databases can overcome limitations inherent in a single resource. By combining PDB, UniProt, Rfam, and Complex Portal, a much richer and more consistent view of macromolecular assemblies emerges.
  • Beyond Simple Titles: Relying on PDB entry titles for assembly identification is insufficient. The proposed method provides persistent, standardized identifiers that are far more robust for programmatic searching and data analysis.
  • FAIR Principles in Action: The project directly addresses the FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, Reusable) data principles, making macromolecular assembly data significantly more discoverable and usable for the scientific community.
  • Unveiling Assembly Heterogeneity: The analysis highlights the significant heterogeneity in how assemblies are represented in the PDB, with multiple stoichiometries for the same protein and inconsistencies in symmetry annotations, underscoring the need for standardization.

Key Results

  • Over 90% Naming Success: The proposed approach successfully assigned human-readable names to over 90% (90,999 out of 97,528) of unique assemblies in the PDB.
  • Persistent Identifiers: Stable, persistent identifiers have been generated for each unique assembly, facilitating consistent referencing.
  • Comprehensive Assembly Coverage: The study identified and characterized over 97,000 unique assembly compositions within the PDB.
  • Dominance of Protein Assemblies: Protein-only assemblies constitute the vast majority (84%) of macromolecular assemblies in the PDB.
  • Methodological Robustness: The pipeline demonstrated its ability to handle various assembly types, including those with unmapped components, and to identify sub- and super-assemblies.
  • Symmetry Analysis Insights: The study found that cyclic (Cn) and dihedral (Dn) symmetries are the most prevalent in the PDB, but also identified a notable percentage of assemblies with inconsistent symmetry operators, suggesting potential areas for further investigation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unmapped Components: While the system handles unmapped components, the authors acknowledge that they are still working on classifying these and identifying suitable external references.
  • Cross-Species Comparison: The current approach primarily identifies assemblies within a given species and does not yet compare them across different species.
  • Automated Naming Challenges: A small number of assemblies (~7,000) remain unnamed automatically due to complex heteromeric compositions with both mapped and unmapped components. The authors are developing new rules and manual curation for these cases.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to continue refining their approach, incorporating advancements in integrative/hybrid methods and multi-chain protein assembly prediction. They also aim to facilitate data interchange with other resources like Complex Portal and UniProt to foster data sharing and reuse. The generated data and code are made publicly available to support further research and development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Macromolecular complexes are essential functional units in nearly all cellular processes, and their atomic-level understanding is critical for elucidating and modulating molecular mechanisms. The Protein Data Bank (PDB) serves as the global repository for experimentally determined structures of macromolecules. Structural data in the PDB offer valuable insights into the dynamics, conformation, and functional states of biological assemblies. However, the current annotation practices lack standardised naming conventions for assemblies in the PDB, complicating the identification of instances representing the same assembly. In this study, we introduce a method leveraging resources external to PDB, such as the Complex Portal, UniProt and Gene Ontology, to describe assemblies and contextualise them within their biological settings accurately. Employing the proposed approach, we assigned standard names to over 90% of unique assemblies in the PDB and provided persistent identifiers for each assembly. This standardisation of assembly data enhances the PDB, facilitating a deeper understanding of macromolecular complexes. Furthermore, the data standardisation improves the PDB's FAIR attributes, fostering more effective basic and translational research and scientific education.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{appasamy2023annotating,
  author = {Sri Devan Appasamy and John M. Berrisford and Romana Gáborová and Sreenath Nair and Stephen Anyango and Sergei Grudinin and Mandar Deshpande and David Armstrong and Ivanna Pidruchna and Joseph I. J. Ellaway and Grisell Díaz Leines and Deepti Gupta and Déborah Harrus and Mihály Váradi and Sameer Velankar},
  title = {{Annotating Macromolecular Complexes in the Protein Data Bank: Improving the FAIRness of Structure Data}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41597-023-02778-9},
}
Figure