Angular fractals in thermal QFT

Nathan Benjamin, Jaeha Lee, Sridip Pal, David Simmons–Duffin, Yixin Xu

TL;DR

This paper reveals that the partition function of quantum field theories at high temperatures, when subjected to specific spatial rotations, exhibits a fractal-like structure. This fractal behavior arises from the interplay of thermal effective field theory and "Kaluza-Klein vortex defects," offering a unified framework to understand spin-refined observables and their universal properties across various dimensions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the behavior of quantum field theories (QFTs) at high temperatures is crucial for various areas of physics, from condensed matter to cosmology. A key tool for this is the "thermal effective field theory" (EFT), which simplifies the problem by capturing the essential physics at low energies (or long distances) and high temperatures. However, this standard EFT approach breaks down when considering specific types of spatial symmetries, particularly those that involve rotations by rational angles. These rotations lead to a "spin-refined" information about the theory, like the difference in contributions from even- and odd-spin operators, which are not directly accessible with the naive thermal EFT. The paper addresses how to systematically incorporate these rational angle twists and understand the resulting complex behavior, including the emergence of new "Kaluza-Klein vortex defects."

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology lies in extending the framework of thermal effective field theory. The authors introduce a technique of "folding and unfolding" the partition function, which involves reinterpreting the insertion of a discrete spatial isometry as a topological defect. This allows them to map the problem onto a different geometry where the standard thermal EFT can be applied. Specifically, they utilize the concept of an "EFT bundle," which is a mathematical construction that elegantly describes the geometry arising from these twists. They also systematically analyze the contributions of "Kaluza-Klein vortex defects," which appear when the spatial rotation is not "free" (i.e., it has fixed points). The analysis is carried out for general QFTs and then illustrated with examples from free theories, CFTs, and holographic theories.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fractal Structure from Symmetry: The most striking insight is that imposing specific spatial rotations on a QFT at high temperatures leads to a partition function with a fractal-like structure as a function of the rotation angle. This fractal nature is not arbitrary but is governed by universal asymptotics around rational angles.
  • Kaluza-Klein Vortex Defects: The breakdown of the naive thermal EFT in the presence of these twists is explained by the emergence of "Kaluza-Klein vortex defects." These are not point-like defects but rather localized structures in the effective field theory that arise from the non-trivial topology of the geometry.
  • Unified Framework: The paper provides a unified framework for understanding spin-refined observables and their relation to the standard thermal partition function. The insertion of a spatial isometry effectively rescales the temperature and introduces new contributions, all within the thermal EFT.
  • General Applicability: The methods developed are shown to be applicable not only to conformal field theories (CFTs) but also to general QFTs, including free and holographic theories, and even fermionic theories with their specific subtleties.

Key Results

  • A general formula is derived for the high-temperature expansion of a QFT partition function with a finite-order spatial isometry insertion.
  • For CFTs, the effective free energy difference between even- and odd-spin operators at high temperatures is found to be smaller than the usual free energy by a factor of $1/2^d$, where $d$ is the number of dimensions.
  • The paper classifies Kaluza-Klein vortex defects and describes their contributions to the partition function, particularly near rational angles.
  • Explicit calculations are performed for free scalar and fermionic theories in various dimensions, as well as for holographic theories, demonstrating the validity of the derived formulas.
  • Nonperturbative corrections from worldline instantons are analyzed and shown to be consistent with the general framework.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Gapless Modes: The authors acknowledge that their results rely on the assumption that generic QFTs develop a mass gap when dimensionally reduced. It would be interesting to investigate how these results are modified in the presence of potential gapless modes.
  • Defect Properties: The paper suggests further investigation into whether Kaluza-Klein vortex defects can support gapless excitations, contribute to Weyl anomalies, or have nontrivial topological terms in their effective action.
  • General Geometries and Observables: The construction of the "EFT bundle" is applicable to geometries beyond spheres and cylinders. Exploring its implications for other types of partition functions and for "spin-refined" statistics of OPE coefficients is a promising future direction.
  • Nonperturbative Corrections: While worldline instantons are analyzed, a deeper understanding of the structure of nonperturbative terms beyond these, particularly in interacting theories, is desired. This includes understanding "instanton graphs" and their rules on general geometries.
  • Tauberian Techniques and Positivity: The paper suggests exploring Tauberian techniques and the role of positivity in obtaining more precise results and numerical bounds for high-temperature partition functions.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract We show that thermal effective field theory controls the long-distance expansion of the partition function of a d -dimensional QFT, with an insertion of any finite-order spatial isometry. Consequently, the thermal partition function on a sphere displays a fractal-like structure as a function of angular twist, reminiscent of the behavior of a modular form near the real line. As an example application, we find that for CFTs, the effective free energy of even-spin minus odd-spin operators at high temperature is smaller than the usual free energy by a factor of 1/2 d . Near certain rational angles, the partition function receives subleading contributions from “Kaluza-Klein vortex defects” in the thermal EFT, which we classify. We illustrate our results with examples in free and holographic theories, and also discuss nonperturbative corrections from worldline instantons.
BibTeX
@article{benjamin2024angular,
  author = {Nathan Benjamin and Jaeha Lee and Sridip Pal and David Simmons–Duffin and Yixin Xu},
  title = {{Angular fractals in thermal QFT}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep11(2024)134},
}

Loading related content...

Figure