Angle-preserving quantized phase embeddings

Petros T. BoufounosProceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "angle-preserving quantized phase embeddings" that efficiently encode the correlation (angle) between real-valued signals using a finite number of bits. This novel approach generalizes existing binary embedding techniques and offers a flexible trade-off between the number of measurements and the bit-rate per measurement, leading to improved performance in applications where signal angles are crucial.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In signal processing, it's often important to understand how signals relate to each other, not just their individual magnitudes. This relationship is often captured by the "angle" or "correlation" between signals. Traditional methods like Johnson-Lindenstrauss (J-L) embeddings focus on preserving the Euclidean distance between signals, which can be sensitive to signal scaling. While some methods preserve angles, they often require a large number of measurements or are limited to binary representations (1-bit). This paper addresses the need for efficient, multi-bit embeddings that specifically preserve the angular relationships between real-valued signals, enabling better data compression and signal representation for applications like detection and estimation where signal normalization is not a concern.

Methods

The core idea is to leverage the phase of complex-valued projections of real-valued signals. The authors propose using a complex random projection matrix $A \in \mathbb{C}^{M \times N}$ to transform a real signal $x \in \mathbb{R}^N$ into a complex vector $z = Ax \in \mathbb{C}^M$. The phase of this complex vector, $y = \angle(z)$, is then measured. This phase measurement, when quantized to $B$ bits per dimension, forms the "quantized phase embedding."

The key mathematical contributions include:

  • Continuous Phase Embeddings: Generalizing the sign function (used in binary embeddings) to the phase function. This allows for a richer representation than just binary values.
  • Angle Preservation Guarantee: Theoretical results (Theorem 3.1 and 3.2) demonstrate that these phase embeddings, both unquantized and quantized, approximately preserve the angles between signals with a certain probability. The error bound is shown to be related to the number of measurements ($M$) and the quantization level ($B$).
  • Trade-off Exploration: The paper highlights the flexibility in choosing $M$ and $B$ for a fixed total rate $R = MB$. This allows designers to balance the number of measurements against the precision of each measurement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments use randomly generated pairs of signals with varying angles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phase is Key for Correlation: The paper convincingly demonstrates that the phase of complex projections of real signals is a rich source of information about their angular relationships. This is a significant insight, moving beyond just magnitude-based embeddings.
  • Quantization Enables Efficiency: By quantizing the phase measurements, the authors achieve significant data reduction, making these embeddings practical for transmission and storage.
  • Flexible Trade-offs: The ability to tune the number of measurements ($M$) and bits per measurement ($B$) for a fixed total rate ($R$) is a major practical advantage. This allows tailoring the embedding to specific application needs.
  • Binary Embeddings as a Special Case: The proposed framework naturally encompasses binary embeddings (when $B=1$), showing a clear lineage and generalization.
  • Theoretical Bounds vs. Practical Performance: The authors note that their theoretical bounds are likely conservative, and practical performance can be better, especially for certain signal angle distributions.

Key Results

  • Experimental Validation: Figure 1 visually confirms that angle embeddings capture true angles with increasing accuracy as quantization improves.
  • Optimal Trade-off for General Angles: For preserving angles across a wide range (including nearly orthogonal signals), experiments suggest that using more embedding dimensions ($M$) and fewer bits per dimension ($B$) (specifically, binary embeddings, $B=1$) performs best.
  • Optimal Trade-off for Similar Signals: When only preserving angles between similar signals is important, using fewer embedding dimensions ($M$) and more bits per dimension ($B$) (e.g., $B=4$ or $5$) yields better performance.
  • Diminishing Returns of Quantization: Performance improvement from increasing bits per measurement ($B$) plateaus beyond 4-6 bits, suggesting that finer quantization beyond this point offers little additional benefit.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Loose Theoretical Bounds: The authors acknowledge that their theoretical bounds on embedding performance are likely too conservative and do not perfectly reflect practical outcomes. They conjecture that multiplicative error bounds, similar to those for J-L embeddings, might be achievable.
  • Experimental Trade-off Exploration: While experiments reveal trade-offs, the paper suggests that a principled theoretical method for finding the optimal bit allocation for a given rate is still needed.
  • Phase-Only Reconstruction: The paper mentions that these embeddings can be used for signal reconstruction (within a scaling factor) and suggests exploring phase-only compressed sensing and quantized phase measurements for reconstruction algorithms as future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

We demonstrate that the phase of randomized complex-valued projections of real-valued signals preserves information about the angle, i.e., the correlation, between those signals. This information can be exploited to design quantized angle-preserving embeddings, which represent such correlations using a nite bit-rate. The proposed embeddings generalize known results on binary embeddings and 1-bit compressive sensing and allow us to explore the trade-o between number of measurements and number of bits per measurement, given the bit rate. The freedom provided by this trade-off, which has also been observed in quantized Johnson-Lindenstrauss embeddings, can improve performance at reduced rate in a number of applications.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{boufounos2013angle,
  author = {Petros T. Boufounos},
  title = {{Angle-preserving quantized phase embeddings}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1117/12.2024412},
}
Figure