Analytical Solution of Ground Stress Induced by Shallow Tunneling with Arbitrary Distributed Loads on Ground Surface

Zejun Li, Jianchen Wang, Kaihang HanSymmetry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel analytical solution for predicting ground stress and displacement around shallow tunnels, specifically accounting for arbitrary distributed loads on the ground surface. This advancement is crucial for understanding the complex interactions between urban tunneling and existing surface structures, leading to more accurate predictions of potential plastic zones.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban tunneling, particularly the shallow tunneling method, is increasingly favored over traditional cut-and-cover techniques due to environmental and logistical considerations. However, shallow tunnels are often constructed near existing surface structures like buildings. This proximity creates a complex geotechnical problem: how do the stresses and deformations induced by tunneling interact with the loads already present on the ground surface? Existing analytical models often simplify this scenario, assuming a "green-field" condition (no surface loads) or a symmetric half-plane with a circular hole. This paper addresses the critical gap of analyzing shallow tunneling under arbitrary distributed surface loads, which is essential for accurately assessing the risk of ground failure and predicting the extent of plastic deformation in the soil.

Methods

The authors employ the complex variable method, a powerful mathematical tool for solving 2D elasticity problems. They extend existing solutions by:

  • Conformal Mapping: Transforming the physical plane (containing the tunnel and ground surface) into a simpler annular region in a mapped plane using a specific transformation function. This simplifies the mathematical treatment of the geometry.
  • Laurent Series Expansion: Representing the analytic functions that describe stress and displacement in the mapped plane as Laurent series. The coefficients of these series are then determined by the boundary conditions.
  • Generalization of Existing Solutions: The proposed method builds upon the work of Verruijt [7,8], incorporating not only ground loss (tunnel convergence) but also the effect of arbitrary distributed loads on the ground surface.
  • Mohr-Coulomb Yield Criterion: To predict the potential plastic zone, the derived analytical solutions for ground stress are combined with the Mohr-Coulomb yield criterion, a standard model for soil failure.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical derivations and numerical simulations for verification.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Coalescence of Plastic Zones: A significant finding is the tendency for the potential plastic zones around the tunnel and around the distributed surface loads to coalesce (merge) when the magnitude of the surface load is large or when the load is positioned close to the tunnel. This highlights a critical interaction that can lead to larger failure zones than predicted by considering each phenomenon in isolation.
  • Influence of Load Magnitude and Range: The study quantifies how both the magnitude (q) and the spatial extent (ao, bo) of surface loads influence the shape and size of the potential plastic zones. Larger loads and loads closer to the tunnel lead to more pronounced coalescing effects.
  • Sensitivity to Tunnel Boundary Conditions: The research emphasizes that the specific boundary conditions of the tunnel (e.g., uniform convergence, ovalization, vertical translation) significantly alter the distribution of potential plastic zones. This underscores the importance of accurately characterizing tunnel deformation for reliable predictions.
  • Validation through Numerical Simulation: The analytical solutions were validated against numerical simulations (using OptumG2), showing good agreement in the general shape and extent of the potential plastic zones, lending confidence to the proposed theoretical framework.

Key Results

The paper successfully derives analytical solutions for ground stresses and displacements under the specified conditions. The key qualitative results, illustrated through figures, demonstrate:

  • Figure 5: Shows that increasing the magnitude of distributed load (q) leads to a larger and more interconnected potential plastic zone, eventually coalescing with the tunnel's plastic zone.
  • Figure 6: Illustrates that a narrower range of distributed loads (closer to the tunnel) results in more significant interaction and coalescence of plastic zones compared to wider or more distant loads.
  • Figure 7: Clearly depicts how different tunnel boundary conditions (B.C.1 to B.C.4) lead to distinct shapes and extents of the potential plastic zones.
  • Figure 8: Compares the analytical results with numerical simulations, showing similar trends and extents for the potential plastic zones, though some differences exist due to the nature of analytical versus numerical approaches.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study assumes a symmetric elastic half-plane and a circular tunnel. Real-world scenarios may involve non-circular tunnels, non-homogeneous soil properties, or more complex geological formations.
  • The analytical solution is based on an elastic hypothesis for stress calculation, with the plastic zone determined by applying the Mohr-Coulomb criterion. Numerical simulations can directly model plasticity throughout the domain, potentially leading to slight discrepancies as noted in the paper.
  • The paper focuses on shallow tunnels. The behavior of deep tunnels under similar surface loading conditions might differ.
  • Future Work:
    • Extending the analytical framework to handle non-circular tunnels and non-homogeneous soil properties.
  • Investigating the influence of different yield criteria beyond Mohr-Coulomb.
  • Analyzing the long-term effects and time-dependent behavior of the ground.
  • Applying the developed solutions to more complex real-world case studies to further validate their practical applicability.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2019analytical,
  author = {Zejun Li and Jianchen Wang and Kaihang Han},
  title = {{Analytical Solution of Ground Stress Induced by Shallow Tunneling with Arbitrary Distributed Loads on Ground Surface}},
  journal = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/sym11060823},
}
Figure