Analysis of the vanishing moment method and its finite element approximations for second-order linear elliptic PDEs in non-divergence form

Xiaobing Feng, Thomas Lewis, Stefan Schnake

TL;DR

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical foundation for solving second-order linear elliptic PDEs in "non-divergence form"—equations that are notoriously difficult to solve because they lack a natural "weak" structure. By transforming these into fourth-order problems using the Vanishing Moment Method (VMM), the authors prove that standard $C^1$ finite element methods can achieve optimal convergence and stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the world of partial differential equations (PDEs), "divergence form" equations (like the Poisson equation) are the gold standard. They allow us to use integration by parts to define "weak solutions," which is the bedrock of the Finite Element Method (FEM).

However, many critical applications in stochastic control, mathematical finance, and game theory involve PDEs in non-divergence form (expressed as $-A : D^2u + \dots = f$). Because the coefficient matrix $A$ sits "inside" the second derivative, standard integration by parts doesn't work. This makes it incredibly difficult to build stable, convergent numerical solvers. While "strong solution" theory exists, translating it into a practical Galerkin-style numerical framework has remained a significant challenge.

Methods

The authors utilize the Vanishing Moment Method (VMM) to bridge this gap.

  1. Higher-Order Regularization: They add a small biharmonic term, $\epsilon \Delta^2 u^\epsilon$, to the original second-order PDE. This "regularizes" the problem into a fourth-order equation.
  2. Divergence-Form Transformation: Crucially, this new fourth-order term is in divergence form. This allows the authors to define a standard weak formulation that fits perfectly into the Galerkin framework.
  3. Boundary Conditions: They adopt "simply supported" boundary conditions ($u=0$ and $\Delta u=0$), which naturally absorb into the weak formulation and allow for high-order regularity estimates.
  4. $C^1$ Finite Elements: To solve a fourth-order PDE, the numerical approximation must be "smooth" across element boundaries. The authors propose using $C^1$ conforming finite elements, specifically the Argyris element (which uses 5th-degree polynomials) and cubic Hermite elements.
  5. Theoretical Analysis: The paper provides the first detailed PDE analysis for this specific class of problems, using "freezing coefficient" techniques and non-standard duality arguments to prove that the approximate solution $u^\epsilon$ converges to the true solution $u$ as $\epsilon \to 0$.

Datasets

As a theoretical and numerical analysis paper, it does not use external datasets. Instead, the authors evaluate their method using manufactured solutions in 2D to verify convergence rates:

  • Test 1 & 2: Square domains with solutions in $H^3$ and $H^2$ (where derivatives are discontinuous along a line).
  • Test 3: A circular domain used to test the method's resilience against the "Babuška paradox" (a known issue where polygonal approximations of circles fail for biharmonic problems).
  • Test 4: A "hard" problem involving a degenerate elliptic matrix where the solution is only a "viscosity solution" (not a strong solution).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Fourth-Order Bridge: The biharmonic term isn't just a mathematical trick; it acts as a bridge. It converts a problem that "hates" integration by parts into one that "loves" it, enabling the use of powerful Galerkin tools.
  • Regularity Boost: The authors show that even if the original solution $u$ is only in $H^2$, the perturbed solution $u^\epsilon$ can be much smoother (up to $H^4$), depending on the boundary's smoothness.
  • Avoiding the Babuška Paradox: By driving the regularization parameter $\epsilon$ to zero in tandem with the mesh size $h$, the VMM naturally avoids the convergence failures typically seen when approximating curved boundaries for biharmonic equations.
  • Viscosity Solution Potential: The numerical tests suggest that VMM works even for degenerate cases where standard theory breaks down, hinting at its utility for fully nonlinear equations like Monge-Ampère.

Key Results

  • Convergence Rates: The authors proved that the error between the VMM solution and the true solution is bounded by $\sqrt{\epsilon}$ in the $L^2$ and $H^1$ norms.
  • Optimal FEM Estimates: They established that the $C^1$ finite element scheme is well-posed and achieves optimal error estimates in the $H^2$ norm.
  • Numerical Superiority: In practice, the numerical experiments showed linear convergence ($O(\epsilon)$) in the $L^2$ norm, which is actually better than the theoretically proven $\sqrt{\epsilon}$ bound.
  • Stability: The method remained stable even when the solution had discontinuous second or third-order derivatives.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conservative Bounds: The authors acknowledge that their theoretical error estimates for $\epsilon$ are likely suboptimal compared to what they observed in practice.
  • Boundary Requirements: The global stability proofs require a $C^{2,1}$ boundary. While the method worked on polygons in tests, the rigorous theory for non-smooth domains is still an open area.
  • Path to Nonlinearity: This paper focuses on linear PDEs. The authors note that these results are a "crucial starting point" for analyzing VMM when applied to much harder, fully nonlinear second-order PDEs.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper is concerned with continuous and discrete approximations of $W^{2,p}$ strong solutions of second-order linear elliptic partial differential equations (PDEs) in non-divergence form. The continuous approximation of these equations is achieved through the Vanishing Moment Method (VMM) which adds a small biharmonic term to the PDE. The structure of the new fourth-order PDE is a natural fit for Galerkin-type methods unlike the original second order equation since the highest order term is in divergence form. The well-posedness of the weak form of the perturbed fourth order equation is shown as well as error estimates for approximating the strong solution of the original second-order PDE. A $C^1$ finite element method is then proposed for the fourth order equation, and its existence and uniqueness of solutions as well as optimal error estimates in the $H^2$ norm are shown. Lastly, numerical tests are given to show the validity of the method.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2019analysis,
  author = {Xiaobing Feng and Thomas Lewis and Stefan Schnake},
  title = {{Analysis of the vanishing moment method and its finite element approximations for second-order linear elliptic PDEs in non-divergence form}},
  booktitle = {Methods},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.4310/maa.2019.v26.n2.a5},
}

Loading related content...

Figure