Analysis of Motion Sickness Associated Brain Activity Using fNIRS: A Driving Simulator Study

Chenyang Zhang, Shuguang Li, Yaohua Li, Shengbo Eben Li, Bingbing NieIEEE Access 2020 · DOI

Introduction

Motion sickness, often described as a "sensory conflict" disease, presents a significant hurdle for the widespread adoption of autonomous vehicles (AVs). As passengers in AVs increasingly engage in non-driving tasks like reading or using screens, the discrepancy between visual input (static) and vestibular sensation (motion) leads to discomfort. While the phenomenon is well-known, the specific neurological pathways involved in its development—the pathogenesis—remain poorly understood. This study aims to map brain activity changes during motion sickness in a naturalistic driving environment using functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS).

Methodology

The researchers employed a high-fidelity experimental setup to simulate realistic driving conditions while monitoring physiological responses.

Experimental Setup

A 6-degree-of-freedom (6-DOF) driving simulator was used to replicate the physical sensations of a real vehicle, including tilts, turns, and vibrations. This platform mimics the actual sensory inputs of a real car to ensure a naturalistic experience for the participants.

The 6-DOF driving simulator setup providing visual, audio, and motion sensations.

Brain Activity Monitoring

To measure cerebral activity, the study utilized fNIRS, a non-invasive technique that uses light to track changes in cerebral oxyhemoglobin concentration ($\Delta COE$). Unlike fMRI, which requires subjects to remain perfectly still, fNIRS allows for movement and is resilient to electromagnetic interference, making it ideal for a simulator environment.

fNIRS equipment and the principle of measuring brain activity via light source and detector.

Protocol

Fifty-two participants drove a hexagonal circular road consisting of alternating straight and curved segments. Brain activity was recorded across 41 channels covering various regions of the cerebral cortex. Subjective sickness levels were assessed using a 10-item Motion Sickness Questionnaire (MSQ). Statistical analyses, including the Jarque-Bera test for normality and t-tests or Mann-Whitney U tests, were used to compare "healthy" states (initial lap) with "sick" states (final lap).

Results and Discussion

The study found that approximately 90% of participants (47 out of 52) reported significant motion sickness symptoms by the end of the task.

The Occipital Hotspot

A primary finding was the consistent activation of the occipital lobe, specifically Brodmann Areas 17 and 18 (Channels 37 and 39). These areas, responsible for visual processing, showed significant activity changes ($p < 0.01$) regardless of the driving maneuver. This confirms that visual processing is a central component of motion sickness across all conditions.

Maneuver-Specific Activity

The brain's response varied depending on the road geometry:

  • Straight Driving: Primarily recruited the Frontal Cortex (BA6) and Somatosensory areas (BA1, 2, 3), indicating a focus on motor planning and physical sensation.
  • Curved Driving: Involved the Prefrontal Cortex (BA10), which handles the integration of complex sensory information. The increased cognitive load during turns appears to exacerbate sickness.

Furthermore, the results indicated a dominance of the left hemisphere during the onset of sickness, consistent with its role in sensorimotor integration.

Conclusion

This research provides a detailed map of the neurological changes associated with motion sickness. By identifying specific "active areas" like the occipital lobe, the study lays the groundwork for developing real-time detection systems. Future work will focus on using machine learning models to predict the onset of nausea, potentially allowing autonomous vehicles to adjust their driving dynamics to ensure passenger comfort.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2020analysis,
  author = {Chenyang Zhang and Shuguang Li and Yaohua Li and Shengbo Eben Li and Bingbing Nie},
  title = {{Analysis of Motion Sickness Associated Brain Activity Using fNIRS: A Driving Simulator Study}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2020.3038039},
}
Figure