Analysis of Load-bearing Capacity of Multi-layer Wrapped High Pressure Vessels

Tong Wang, Qian Cai-fu, Zhiwei Wu, Zhao Jing-yuJournal of Mechanical Engineering 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the influence of manufacturing pre-stress and interlayer gaps on the load-bearing capacity of multi-layer wrapped high-pressure vessels (MLWHPV). Through analytical derivation and numerical simulation, it is demonstrated that while pre-stress significantly enhances the elastic performance of the vessel, it does not increase the ultimate limit load. Furthermore, manufacturing gaps between layers do not compromise the vessel's final burst strength, as the expansion under pressure effectively closes these clearances.

Introduction

Multi-layer wrapped high-pressure vessels are a cornerstone technology for high-pressure hydrogen storage and chemical processing. These vessels are constructed by wrapping multiple thin steel sheets around a central inner cylinder. Ideally, this manufacturing process induces a beneficial compressive pre-stress in the inner cylinder, allowing it to withstand higher internal pressures before yielding.

However, manufacturing imperfections, such as interlayer gaps, are common. These gaps can prevent the full application of intended pre-stress. This research quantifies how these factors affect the vessel's "limit load"—the maximum pressure it can withstand before the entire wall thickness yields.

Methodology

The study employs a dual-methodology approach:

  1. Analytical Derivation: Using the von-Mises yield criterion and shell theory, mathematical expressions were derived for stress distribution and limit loads under various conditions.
  2. Numerical Simulation: A 3D finite element model was developed in ANSYS to validate the analytical formulas. The model represents a vessel with a 1000 mm inner diameter, a 20.2 mm inner cylinder, and five 12.6 mm outer layers. It utilizes an "equivalent temperature drop" method to simulate pre-stress and contact elements to model interlayer interactions.
Finite element geometry model of the multi-layer wrapped vessel showing the inner cylinder (304) and outer layers (Q345R)

Key Findings

The "Erasure" of Pre-stress at Limit Load

A critical insight from the analysis is that as internal pressure approaches the limit load, the vessel enters a state of full yield. At this point, the initial pre-stress distribution is completely overridden by plastic flow. Consequently, the ultimate burst pressure depends solely on the total wall thickness and material properties, not the initial pre-stress state.

Elastic Range Benefits

While pre-stress does not affect the ultimate limit load, it remains highly valuable for operational longevity. It shifts the stress distribution, significantly lowering the working stress of the inner cylinder during normal operation, thereby extending the vessel's elastic life and preventing premature localized yielding.

Impact of Interlayer Gaps

The study reveals that interlayer clearances do not reduce the limit load. Under extreme internal pressure, the vessel expands, closing these gaps and ensuring all layers contribute their full strength to resisting the load.

Validation and Results

The numerical simulations showed excellent agreement with the theoretical derivations. For the studied vessel, the theoretical limit load was calculated at 44.32 MPa, compared to 45 MPa from the simulation. Figure 2 illustrates the close match between theoretical and numerical results for hoop stress distribution across the vessel's radius, with results generally within a 10% margin of error.

Comparison of numerical simulation and theoretical calculation for hoop stress across the vessel radius

Conclusion

The research confirms that manufacturing imperfections like interlayer gaps and variations in pre-stress do not compromise the static limit load of multi-layer wrapped vessels. However, these gaps remain a concern for fatigue life and stress corrosion in long-term service, as they can act as sites for moisture accumulation or cause uneven stress cycling. Future research should focus on the dynamic impact of these gaps on the vessel's fatigue lifespan.

Summary updated

Abstract

摘要: 在多层包扎式高压容器制造过程中,理想情况下层板的包扎会使筒体产生预应力,但如果制造精度不够,容器层板间可能出现间隙,就无法保证预应力的充分施加。理论推导得到了有无预应力两种情况下受压力作用时多层包扎高压容器筒体中应力的计算表达式以及极限载荷计算式,并进行了数值模拟验证。研究发现,理论和数值模拟结果较为吻合,预应力的施加显著降低内筒体的工作应力水平,并且能有效改善弹性状态下筒体的应力状态,提高筒体弹性承载能力。然而,在全屈服状态,预应力没有提高容器的极限承载能力,容器极限承载能力仅取决于内筒体和层板的厚度与材料性能。另外,理论分析和数值模拟还表明层间间隙的存在也不会影响容器筒体的极限承载能力。
BibTeX
@article{wang2023analysis,
  author = {Tong Wang and Qian Cai-fu and Zhiwei Wu and Zhao Jing-yu},
  title = {{Analysis of Load-bearing Capacity of Multi-layer Wrapped High Pressure Vessels}},
  journal = {Journal of Mechanical Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3901/jme.2023.14.169},
}
Figure