Analysis of Laser Cleaning and Rust Removal Technology for Substation Isolator Switches

Haoyu Zhang, Jing Zhang, Xu Zhang, Shengrong Zhu, Min ZhangJournal of Physics Conference Series 2023 · DOI

Abstract

After running for a long time, isolator switches are prone to be covered with dirt and corrosion. Switch cleaning is necessary for good operation and safety. Laser cleaning technology for rust removal is emerging in recent years. This paper introduces the technical principles of laser cleaning for rust removal in detail, designs a specific process scheme and takes a steel plate sample cleaning and rust removal as a case. The application effect of laser cleaning and rust removal technology is tested and shows that the technology analyzed in this paper can play a great cleaning effect without damaging the equipment base.

Introduction

In electrical infrastructure, substation isolator switches are critical components for operational control and safety. Due to their outdoor placement, these switches are continuously exposed to humidity and environmental pollutants, leading to significant corrosion and dirt accumulation. This buildup is more than an aesthetic concern; rust increases contact resistance, which can result in overheating, equipment failure, or hazardous electrical faults.

Traditional maintenance methods—such as manual scrubbing, chemical solvents, or ultrasonic cleaning—often fail to remove submicron-sized pollutants effectively or are too labor-intensive and environmentally damaging. Laser cleaning has emerged as a non-contact, "green" alternative. However, optimizing this technology requires a precise balance of parameters to ensure complete rust removal without damaging the underlying metal substrate.

Theoretical Principles of Laser Cleaning

The effectiveness of laser cleaning relies on overcoming the adhesion forces that bind contaminants to the metal surface. As shown in the figure below, there are three primary forces at play: Van der Waals forces, capillary forces, and electrostatic forces.

Adhesion forces on the substrate

Laser cleaning works by inducing rapid thermal expansion. When the laser energy is absorbed by the contaminant layer, it generates a force greater than these combined adhesion forces, causing the particles to detach from the basal surface. This process allows for the removal of both thick dirt layers and fine particles.

Experimental Methodology

To determine the optimal cleaning parameters, researchers utilized a handheld laser cleaning system consisting of a fiber laser, a computer control system, and a cleaning head equipped with scanning galvanometers.

The study focused on steel plate samples artificially corroded with seawater to simulate the harsh conditions of a substation. With the laser power fixed at 20W, two primary variables were tested:

  1. Scanning Speed: Evaluated at 500 mm/s, 1500 mm/s, and 2500 mm/s.
  2. Laser Frequency: Tested across five levels ranging from 130 KHz to 600 KHz.

Surface morphology was inspected using an OLYMPUS BX51 light microscope (50x to 1000x magnification) to evaluate residual rust and potential substrate damage.

Results and Discussion

The experiments identified a critical relationship between scanning speed, frequency, and cleaning quality.

Mechanism of particle removal

The Impact of Scanning Speed

There is a non-linear relationship between speed and efficiency. While higher speeds (e.g., 2500 mm/s) are faster, they result in insufficient energy accumulation, leaving "islands" of residual rust. Conversely, speeds that are too slow accumulate excessive heat, risking damage or warping of the base metal. The study found that 500 mm/s provided the optimal balance for revealing the clean metal base.

The Role of Laser Frequency

Frequency determines the energy density per pulse. Lower frequencies (130 KHz) provide high energy density, which is effective for rust removal but can cause unwanted oxide scale on the substrate. Higher frequencies (500-600 KHz) spread energy too thinly to break adhesive bonds. The researchers identified 170 KHz as the ideal setting, removing all rust while maintaining the integrity of the equipment base.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that handheld laser cleaning is a highly effective method for maintaining substation isolator switches. By utilizing a scanning speed of 500 mm/s and a frequency of 170 KHz for a 20W system, operators can achieve high surface cleanliness without damaging the equipment. Future work should focus on scaling these parameters for higher-wattage lasers and developing real-time monitoring systems, such as acoustic or spectral sensors, to provide immediate feedback on cleaning efficacy in the field.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract After running for a long time, isolator switches are prone to be covered with dirt and corrosion. Switch cleaning is necessary for good operation and safety. Laser cleaning technology for rust removal is emerging in recent years. This paper introduces the technical principles of laser cleaning for rust removal in detail, designs a specific process scheme and takes a steel plate sample cleaning and rust removal as a case. The application effect of laser cleaning and rust removal technology is tested and shows that the technology analyzed in this paper can play a great cleaning effect without damaging the equipment base.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2023analysis,
  author = {Haoyu Zhang and Jing Zhang and Xu Zhang and Shengrong Zhu and Min Zhang},
  title = {{Analysis of Laser Cleaning and Rust Removal Technology for Substation Isolator Switches}},
  journal = {Journal of Physics Conference Series},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1088/1742-6596/2488/1/012033},
}
Figure