Safety Enhancement of the INDOT Network Pavement Friction Testing Prgram: Macrotexture and Microtexture Testing Using Laser Sensors

Shuo Li, Samy Noureldin, Karen Zhu2010 · DOI

Abstract

The Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) traditionally conducts annual network inventory friction testing using locked-wheel trailers to mitigate wet pavement crashes. However, this method presents safety risks on high-speed facilities and raises concerns regarding data credibility. While macrotexture can be measured at highway speeds, microtexture—a critical component of friction—has historically required low-speed surrogate devices. This pilot study investigates the use of high-frequency laser sensors to capture both macro- and microtexture. Findings indicate that microtexture metrics (MPD, RMS, and SV) stabilize at a baseline length of 12.75 mm. Furthermore, Slope Variance (SV) proved as effective as Root Mean Square (RMS) in estimating friction. Correlation analysis revealed that wet pavement friction is highly sensitive to both macrotexture and microtexture, with microtexture SV playing a dominant role. This research suggests that high-speed laser scanning can effectively estimate pavement friction, enhancing both operational safety and data quality.

Introduction: The Need for Non-Contact Testing

Maintaining adequate pavement friction is a cornerstone of highway safety, particularly for preventing wet-weather accidents. For years, the Indiana Department of Transportation (INDOT) has relied on the locked-wheel trailer method for friction inventory. While reliable, this approach has significant drawbacks: it requires testing at 40 mph on interstates where traffic flows at 70 mph, creating hazardous speed differentials, and the physical contact accelerates tire and pavement wear.

Engineers have long sought to replace physical friction testing with non-contact laser measurements. However, previous attempts focused primarily on macrotexture (wavelengths 0.5mm to 50mm), which facilitates water drainage but is a poor sole predictor of friction. The missing variable is microtexture (wavelengths < 0.5mm), the fine-scale grit that provides tire adhesion. This study explores a framework for capturing both scales at highway speeds using advanced laser sensors.

Methodology and Sampling Requirements

To bridge the gap between lab-scale accuracy and field-scale speed, the research team evaluated two laser systems: a stationary 1 kHz high-resolution scanner for baseline "ground truth" and a 62.5 kHz vehicle-mounted sensor for high-speed data acquisition.

A critical component of the methodology involved the Nyquist sampling theorem. To accurately capture the peaks and troughs of pavement texture at speeds of 30–50 mph, the team determined that a laser must pulse at a frequency between 54 kHz and 90 kHz. This ensures that the microtexture profile is not "aliased" or lost in the noise of high-speed travel.

Beyond the standard Mean Profile Depth (MPD), the study utilized two additional metrics to characterize the surface:

  • Root Mean Square (RMS): A measure of the overall magnitude of surface asperities.
  • Slope Variance (SV): A measure of the "sharpness" or angularity of the pavement grit.

Experimental Setup and Datasets

Testing was conducted at the INDOT Friction Test Track, utilizing three distinct surfaces to represent the spectrum of road conditions:

  1. Slick Concrete: Finished to a high smoothness to simulate worn, low-friction areas.
  2. 9.5-mm Hot Mix Asphalt (HMA): A standard SuperPave mix representing typical highway surfaces.
  3. Tined Concrete: Featuring 3mm deep transverse grooves to simulate high-drainage, high-friction environments.

Field validation also included in-service asphalt testing using both smooth and ribbed tires to correlate laser data with traditional Friction Numbers (FN).

Key Insights: The Role of "Sharpness"

The study's most significant finding was the importance of Slope Variance (SV). While depth (MPD) is the traditional metric for texture, the "sharpness" of the microtexture (SV) was found to be a more critical driver of wet pavement friction. Essentially, the angularity of the aggregate particles matters as much as the depth of the gaps between them. Notably, the study found that SV and RMS are redundant when used together; either metric is sufficient on its own to estimate friction from microtexture.

Additionally, the researchers identified a "stability threshold" for microtexture. Metrics like MPD, RMS, and SV tended to fluctuate at very short measurement lengths but remained constant once the baseline exceeded 12.75 mm. This finding provides a concrete standard for future sensor calibration and data processing algorithms.

Results and Correlation Analysis

The correlation between laser-derived metrics and physical friction measurements was remarkably strong. Wet pavement friction showed a Pearson correlation of 0.9722 with macrotexture MPD and 0.9159 with microtexture SV.

Regression analysis further demonstrated that:

  • Dry Friction: Almost entirely dependent on microtexture adhesion.
  • Wet Friction: A complex interaction of macrotexture (for bulk water drainage) and microtexture (for breaking the remaining water film).
  • Predictive Power: The study successfully developed linear regression models capable of predicting Friction Numbers (FN) using only laser data, achieving a high degree of accuracy within the test environment.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This pilot study confirms that high-speed laser sensors can capture the microtexture data necessary for accurate friction estimation. By moving toward a non-contact, high-speed testing regime, DOTs can significantly improve the safety of field operations while obtaining more comprehensive data on pavement health.

However, challenges remain. The 1 kHz stationary laser proved highly sensitive to ambient light, requiring physical shielding in the field. Furthermore, while 62.5 kHz is sufficient for macrotexture, capturing the finest microtextures on extremely slick surfaces may require even higher frequencies or the integration of high-resolution image processing. Future research will focus on expanding the dataset to more diverse real-world pavements and exploring 21MP+ camera systems as a potential alternative to laser scanning.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Indiana Department of Transportation has conducted annual network inventory friction testing using the locked wheel trailer to reduce wet pavement crashes. However, issues have arisen concerning the data credibility and field operation safety on high-speed highway facilities. Some researchers have investigated the evaluation of pavement friction using macrotexture measurements and found the relationship between friction and macrotexture is extremely weak. Currently, macrotexture can be readily measured at highway speeds, but microtexture is evaluated using friction at low speeds from a surrogate device. Microtexture plays an important role in friction force. The evaluation of pavement friction from texture measurements will be undermined without considering microtexture. This pilot study was conducted by the authors to examine the use of laser-based sensors in measuring pavement texture, in particular microtexture. The requirement for laser sampling frequency was established for choosing lasers during testing at highway speeds. Microtexture testing was conducted on cores taken from pavements. It was found that the Microtexture MPD, RMS and SV increased as the baseline length increased, regardless of the type of pavement, but tended to remain constant after the baseline length exceeded 12.75 mm. It was recommended that the microtexture MPD, RMS and SV should be computed in terms of a baseline length used for computing macrotexture. When estimating friction from microtexture measurements, the use of SV was as effective as the use of RMS. It is not necessary to include both SV and RMS when estimating friction from microtexture. Correlation analysis indicated that wet pavement friction had a positive relationship with macrotexture MPD, microtexture MPD, and microtexture SV. The microtexture SV may play a more important role in wet pavement friction than the microtexture MPD. Dry pavement friction is not as sensitive to macrotexture as to microtexture. Regression analysis indicated that pavement friction is related to both macrotextrue and microtexture, not to macrotexture only. In addition, when pavement is wet, its surface friction is more sensitive to the slope variance than to the mean profile depth of the microtexture profile. It was recommended that more research effort is needed to investigate the characterization of microtexture and examine the effect of macrotexture slope variance. Research work is also needed to examine the image processing technology for measuring microtexture, and to confirm the hypothesis that pavement friction is probably related to microtextures with wavelengths greater than a certain value.
BibTeX
@misc{li2010safety,
  author = {Shuo Li and Samy Noureldin and Karen Zhu},
  title = {{Safety Enhancement of the INDOT Network Pavement Friction Testing Prgram: Macrotexture and Microtexture Testing Using Laser Sensors}},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.5703/1288284314248},
}
Figure