Analysis of influencing factors on settlement of widened subgrade based on differences in working conditions

Yang Liang, Wenyuan Xu, Li KekeInternational Journal of Computational Methods and Experimental Measurements 2022 · DOI

Abstract

The finite element method is used for numerical simulation analysis to explore the settlement characteristics of widened subgrade under the influence of different working conditions and factors. The research results show that at the end of the construction period, the maximum total settlement of the subgrade surface of the project of simultaneous widening and raising of the original subgrade is 1.97 cm, the maximum differential settlement of the subgrade surface is 0.21 cm, and the cross slope of the road arch increases by 1.4%. The maximum total settlement of the subgrade surface of the project of only widening of the original subgrade is 2.35 cm, which is an increase of 19.3% compared with the maximum total settlement of the subgrade surface of the project of simultaneous widening and raising of the original subgrade. The total settlement of the subgrade surface under the two working conditions varies with the change of filling materials and increases with the width, height, and slope ratio. When the width increases from 3.5 to 14 m, the maximum uncoordinated deformation of the subgrade surface of the project of simultaneous widening and raising of the original subgrade is increased from 0.54 to 1.31 cm, and the value of the subgrade surface settlement curvature of the splicing area for the project of only widening of the original subgrade is increased from 0.13 to 0.97. The obtained results can provide a reference for subgrade widening projects in the future.

Introduction

As traffic volumes increase, highway widening becomes a critical infrastructure necessity. However, expanding an existing roadbed is complex due to differential settlement between the old, well-compacted subgrade and the new, fresh fill. This discrepancy often leads to longitudinal cracking at the "splicing area" or junction. Engineers typically face two scenarios: simply widening the road or simultaneously raising and widening it to meet new design requirements. This study investigates how these two working conditions, along with factors like fill material and geometry, influence settlement behavior.

Methodology

The study utilized the Finite Element Method (FEM) to model the Lalinhe–Harbin section of the Beijing–Harbin Expressway. A Mohr–Coulomb ideal elastoplastic model was applied to simulate soil behavior. The subgrade was discretized using 4-node bilinear plane strain quadrilateral units (CPE4R), while the ground was modeled with pore pressure units (CPE4P) to account for drainage and consolidation.

Geometric models of the two subgrade widening conditions: simultaneous widening and raising (left) and widening only (right).

To optimize computational efficiency, only half of the cross-section was modeled due to symmetry. The simulation explored several variables:

  • Widening Widths: 3.5m, 7m, 10.5m, and 14m.
  • Raising Heights: 1m, 2m, 3m, and 4m.
  • Slope Ratios: 1:1, 1:1.5, and 1:2.
  • Fill Materials: Silty clay, Stone soil (Filling 1), and Medium sand (Filling 2).

Results and Discussion

The simulation results revealed significant differences in settlement patterns between the two working conditions.

Settlement Profiles

In the "raising and widening" scenario, the settlement curve across the subgrade surface resembles a smooth "basin." Conversely, the "widening only" scenario exhibits a sharp spike in settlement at the junction between the old and new subgrade, significantly increasing the risk of uncoordinated deformation and pavement cracking.

Numerical simulation contour plot showing the vertical displacement (U2) distribution across the subgrade and ground.

Comparative Analysis

  • Total Settlement: The "raising and widening" method resulted in a maximum settlement of 1.97 cm. In contrast, "widening only" led to 2.35 cm—a 19.3% increase. This suggests that raising the original subgrade helps redistribute stress more effectively toward the center, rather than concentrating it at the splicing area.
  • Differential Settlement: The simultaneous raising and widening approach maintained a remarkably low differential settlement of 0.21 cm.
  • Impact of Width: Increasing the widening width from 3.5m to 14m more than doubled the uncoordinated deformation in the raising scenario (from 0.54 cm to 1.31 cm). For widening-only projects, the settlement curvature at the splicing area increased from 0.13 to 0.97, indicating a heightened risk of structural failure as the road becomes wider.
  • Material Influence: Fill material was found to be the most critical factor. Using "Stone soil" with a high elastic modulus (900 MPa) significantly reduced settlement compared to standard silty clay.

Conclusion

Simultaneously raising and widening a subgrade offers superior settlement control compared to widening alone. This method reduces total settlement by approximately 19% and minimizes differential settlement at the critical junction between old and new materials. While increasing width and height naturally increases settlement, the choice of high-modulus fill material can mitigate these effects. Future research should consider long-term creep, traffic loading cycles, and environmental factors such as freeze-thaw cycles common in cold regions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The finite element method is used for numerical simulation analysis to explore the settlement characteristics of widened subgrade under the influence of different working conditions and factors. The research results show that at the end of the construction period, the maximum total settlement of the subgrade surface of the project of simultaneous widening and raising of the original subgrade is 1.97 cm, the maximum differential settlement of the subgrade surface is 0.21 cm, and the cross slope of the road arch increases by 1.4%. The maximum total settlement of the subgrade surface of the project of only widening of the original subgrade is 2.35 cm, which is an increase of 19.3% compared with the maximum total settlement of the subgrade surface of the project of simultaneous widening and raising of the original subgrade. The total settlement of the subgrade surface under the two working conditions varies with the change of filling materials and increases with the width, height, and slope ratio. When the width increases from 3.5 to 14 m, the maximum uncoordinated deformation of the subgrade surface of the project of simultaneous widening and raising of the original subgrade is increased from 0.54 to 1.31 cm, and the value of the subgrade surface settlement curvature of the splicing area for the project of only widening of the original subgrade is increased from 0.13 to 0.97. The obtained results can provide a reference for subgrade widening projects in the future.
BibTeX
@article{liang2022analysis,
  author = {Yang Liang and Wenyuan Xu and Li Keke},
  title = {{Analysis of influencing factors on settlement of widened subgrade based on differences in working conditions}},
  journal = {International Journal of Computational Methods and Experimental Measurements},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2495/cmem-v10-n2-117-130},
}
Figure