Abstract
When a tunnel passes beneath an existing road, uncoordinated deformation and the redistribution of internal forces can lead to structural damage or road failure. Despite this, existing studies often overlook the impact of pavement loads and the mutual influence between geological strata and road structures. This study presents a case study of the Jinshuang Interval of the Jinyidong Metro in Jinhua City, China, to accurately disclose the effects of shield tunneling on superstructures. Using ANSYS finite element software, a tunnel-soil-road interaction model was constructed to investigate stress and displacement variations under lane loading conditions. The research analyzed factors such as tunnel burial depth and soil parameters of the occupied layer. Results indicate that road settlement increases gradually during tunnel advancement and stabilizes after the shield machine has passed. Under combined tunnel and traffic loads, the maximum pavement settlement reached 2.31 cm—safely below the 3 cm control limit—occurring at the upper right position of the tunnel axis. Furthermore, settlement increases significantly in layers with poor soil quality, suggesting that shield tunneling is less applicable in such conditions. These findings provide theoretical references for practical shield tunneling projects beneath existing urban roads.
Introduction
As urban areas become increasingly dense, engineers are frequently required to excavate metro tunnels directly beneath active arterial roads. This process disturbs the surrounding soil, leading to a redistribution of internal stresses that can cause road deformation or structural failure. Traditional settlement prediction methods, such as the empirical Peck formula, often oversimplify the soil medium and ignore the structural integrity of the road and the live traffic loads it carries. This paper addresses the need for a holistic "tunnel–soil–road interaction" model to ensure the safety of urban infrastructure during underground construction. By simulating a real-world metro project in China, this study demonstrates that while tunneling causes a "V-shaped" settlement pattern, the resulting displacements can remain within safe engineering limits provided soil quality is sufficient.
Methodology
The study is based on the Jinshuang Interval of the Jinyidong Metro project in Jinhua City, China. Researchers developed a 3D finite element model using ANSYS, comprising over 58,000 units to simulate the tunnel, the surrounding geological strata, and the multi-layered road structure. The model utilized geological prospecting data to define five distinct layers: fill, clay, silt, gravel, and weathered rock.
The model utilized the Drucker-Prager (DP) yield criterion to accurately represent the elastic-plastic behavior of the soil. To simulate the physical excavation process, a "generation and killing" numerical technique was employed, where soil elements are removed to represent excavation and lining elements are added to represent tunnel segment installation. Unlike many previous studies, this model applied a uniform 20 kN/m² static load to the pavement to represent real-world traffic conditions.
Results and Discussion
The simulation revealed that road settlement follows a "V-shaped" pattern, with the most significant displacement occurring as the shield machine passes directly underneath. Key findings include:
- Asymmetric Settlement: The maximum settlement of 2.31 cm occurred at the upper right position of the tunnel axis, rather than directly above the center. This value remains safely below the international engineering control limit of 3.0 cm.
- Stabilization: Settlement increases gradually during the approach and passage of the tunnel but stabilizes quickly once the shield machine has fully down-traversed the area, identifying the active excavation phase as the most critical risk window.
- Stress Distribution: Internal stress within the road structure increases as the tunnel approaches but plateaus after the tunnel passes. The highest stress concentrations were found directly below the road center.
- Soil Sensitivity: The model demonstrated that settlement is highly dependent on the properties of the "occupied layer." While the project was stable in weathered rock and gravel, tunneling through poor-quality soil like soft silt resulted in significantly higher vertical displacement, suggesting that shield tunneling may require additional reinforcement or be inapplicable in such environments.
Conclusion
This research confirms that the shield tunneling method used in the Jinyidong Metro project maintains road settlement within safe limits. By accounting for the interaction between traffic loads and soil deformation, the proposed model provides a more robust framework for urban tunnel planning. Future research should consider dynamic traffic vibrations and more complex road geometries, such as intersections and ramps, to further refine these predictive models.
Summary updated