Abstract: We analyze two approaches to the quantum-classical Liouville (QCL) formalism that differ in the order of two operations: Wigner transformation and projection onto adiabatic electronic states. The analysis is carried out on a two-dimensional linear vibronic model where geometric phase (GP) effects arising from a conical intersection profoundly affect nuclear dynamics. We find that the Wigner-then-Adiabatic (WA) QCL approach captures GP effects, whereas the Adiabatic-then-Wigner (AW) QCL approach does not. Moreover, the Wigner transform in AW-QCL leads to an ill-defined Fourier transform of double-valued functions. The double-valued character of these functions stems from the nontrivial GP of adiabatic electronic states in the presence of a conical intersection. In contrast, WA-QCL avoids this issue by starting with the Wigner transform of single-valued quantities of the full problem. As a consequence, GP effects in WA-QCL can be associated with a dynamical term in the corresponding equation of motion. Since the WA-QCL approach uses solely the adiabatic potentials and non-adiabatic derivative couplings as an input, our results indicate that WA-QCL can capture GP effects in two-state crossing problems using first-principles electronic structure calculations without prior diabatization or introduction of explicit phase factors.
Introduction: The Challenge of Conical Intersections
In theoretical chemistry, conical intersections (CIs) are critical "funnels" where electronic energy levels meet, enabling rapid, non-adiabatic transitions essential for processes like photosynthesis and vision. However, CIs introduce a topological complexity known as the geometric phase (GP). When an electronic wavefunction moves in a closed loop around a CI, it acquires a phase factor of -1, flipping its sign. To maintain consistency in the total system's wavefunction, the nuclear wavefunction must also flip its sign, becoming "double-valued."
This double-valued nature poses a significant challenge for numerical simulations, which typically rely on single-valued functions. Traditional solutions involve either transforming the problem into a diabatic representation—often impossible for complex systems—or adding manual phase-compensation factors. This study investigates whether the Quantum-Classical Liouville (QCL) formalism, which mixes quantum and classical dynamics, can naturally account for GP effects.
Methodology: WA-QCL vs. AW-QCL
The researchers compared two derivation paths for the QCL equation of motion using a two-dimensional linear vibronic coupling (LVC) model:
- WA-QCL (Wigner-then-Adiabatic): The Wigner transformation is applied to the full system first, followed by a projection onto adiabatic electronic states.
- AW-QCL (Adiabatic-then-Wigner): The system is projected onto adiabatic states first, and then the Wigner transform is applied to the resulting nuclear densities.
The study found that the order of these operations is not commutative. AW-QCL is fundamentally flawed in the presence of a CI because it requires a Fourier transform of a double-valued function, which is mathematically ill-defined. In contrast, WA-QCL avoids this by starting with single-valued quantities.
Results and Discussion
The primary finding is that WA-QCL successfully captures GP effects using only standard adiabatic potentials and derivative couplings. This is achieved through an extra term in the equation of motion that accounts for changes in nuclear momenta as they couple to electronic degrees of freedom.
As shown in Figure 2, WA-QCL accurately predicts the rate of population transfer, closely matching the exact quantum (diabatic) results. In contrast, the AW-QCL and "no-GP" adiabatic models deviate significantly, proving that ignoring GP leads to physically incorrect dynamics.
Furthermore, the 2D probability density plots (Figure 4) reveal a "nodal line"—a region of zero probability caused by destructive interference from the geometric phase. The WA-QCL approach successfully reproduces this nodal line, whereas models without GP show spurious constructive interference in the same region.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The WA-QCL approach demonstrates that GP effects can be captured in two-state crossing problems using first-principles electronic structure calculations without prior diabatization. While successful, the method requires a high number of classical trajectories for convergence. Future work will explore how these findings apply to multi-level systems where coherences between three or more electronic states may introduce further complexities in handling double-valued boundary conditions.
Summary updated