Analyses of Flight Time During Solar Proton Events and Solar Flares

X. H. Xu, Y. Wang, F. S. Wei, X. S. Feng, M. H. Bo, H. W. Tang, D. S. Wang, Bolin Lei, P. B. Zuo, C. W. Jiang, Zhiqiang Zhou, Z. Li, P. Zou, L. D. Wang, Yan-ming Gu, Y. L. Chen, W. Y. Zhang, P. SunarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Analyzing the effects of space weather on aviation is a new and developing topic. It has been commonly accepted that the flight time of the polar flights may increase during solar proton events because the flights have to change their route to avoid the high-energy particles. However, apart from such phenomenon, researches related to the flight time during space weather events is very rare. Based on the analyses of 39 representative international air routes around westerlies, it is found that 97.44% (94.87%) of the commercial airplanes on the westbound (eastbound) air routes reveal shorter (longer) flight time during solar proton events compared to those during quiet periods, and the averaged magnitude of change in flight time is ~10 min or 0.21%-4.17% of the total flight durations. Comparative investigations reassure the certainty of such phenomenon that the directional differences in flight time are still incontrovertible regardless of over-land routes (China-Europe) or over-sea routes (China-Western America). Further analyses suggest that the solar proton events associated atmospheric heating will change the flight durations by weakening certain atmospheric circulations, such as the polar jet stream. While the polar jet stream will not be obviously altered during solar flares so that the directional differences in flight time are not found. Besides the conventional space weather effects already known, this paper is the first report that indicates a distinct new scenario of how the solar proton events affect flight time. These analyses are also important for aviation since our discoveries could help the airways optimize the air routes to save passenger time costs, reduce fuel costs and even contribute to the global warming issues.

Introduction

While the aviation industry is well aware of the direct radiation risks posed by space weather—often leading to the rerouting of polar flights—the indirect impact of these events on atmospheric circulation has been largely overlooked. This research identifies a critical gap: beyond safety-driven rerouting, does space weather fundamentally alter the winds that commercial aircraft rely on? Specifically, the study investigates how high-energy particles from Solar Proton Events (SPEs) interact with the Earth's atmosphere to influence the polar jet stream, a high-altitude "river" of air that significantly dictates flight durations on international routes.

Methodology

The researchers employed a large-scale statistical analysis comparing flight times during three distinct conditions: Solar Proton Events (SPEs), solar flares, and "quiet" periods. The study utilized approximately 8.3 million individual flight records from 2015 to 2019, sourced from Travelsky Mobile Technology Limited.

Map of studied flight routes and the polar jet stream.

Thirty-nine representative international air routes near the westerlies were selected and categorized into two groups: over-land (Group 1: China-Europe) and over-sea (Group 2: China-Western America). SPE-affected periods were defined as the 72 hours following the start of an event, while solar flare durations were set to 24 hours to account for daily flight cycles. By comparing SPEs to solar flares, the authors could distinguish between the effects of particle precipitation (protons) and electromagnetic radiation (flares).

Key Results and Discussion

The study reveals a distinct directional asymmetry in flight times during SPEs. When SPEs reach Earth, the geomagnetic field deflects high-energy protons toward the poles, causing localized atmospheric heating. This heating reduces the temperature and pressure gradients between the equator and the poles, which in turn weakens the polar jet stream.

Proportion of flights with increased or decreased travel times during SPEs.

As shown in the statistical analysis, this weakening leads to:

  • Westbound Flights: 97.44% of commercial airplanes on westbound routes showed shorter flight times during SPEs because the headwind they usually fight is weaker.
  • Eastbound Flights: 94.87% of airplanes on eastbound routes showed longer flight times because the tailwind boost they usually enjoy is diminished.

The average change in flight time was approximately 10 minutes. Notably, solar flares did not produce this effect, as electromagnetic radiation does not specifically heat the polar regions in the same manner as particle precipitation. This confirms that the phenomenon is unique to SPEs.

Conclusion

This research provides the first evidence of a new scenario where space weather affects aviation efficiency by modulating atmospheric dynamics. While the 10-minute shift is statistically significant and consistent across different geographies, future work could explore these effects across longer solar cycles. Integrating space weather forecasts into real-time flight planning could help airlines optimize routes, save time, reduce fuel costs, and lower carbon emissions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Analyzing the effects of space weather on aviation is a new and developing topic. It has been commonly accepted that the flight time of the polar flights may increase during solar proton events because the flights have to change their route to avoid the high-energy particles. However, apart from such phenomenon, researches related to the flight time during space weather events is very rare. Based on the analyses of 39 representative international air routes around westerlies, it is found that 97.44% (94.87%) of the commercial airplanes on the westbound (eastbound) air routes reveal shorter (longer) flight time during solar proton events compared to those during quiet periods, and the averaged magnitude of change in flight time is ~10 min or 0.21%-4.17% of the total flight durations. Comparative investigations reassure the certainty of such phenomenon that the directional differences in flight time are still incontrovertible regardless of over-land routes (China-Europe) or over-sea routes (China-Western America). Further analyses suggest that the solar proton events associated atmospheric heating will change the flight durations by weakening certain atmospheric circulations, such as the polar jet stream. While the polar jet stream will not be obviously altered during solar flares so that the directional differences in flight time are not found. Besides the conventional space weather effects already known, this paper is the first report that indicates a distinct new scenario of how the solar proton events affect flight time. These analyses are also important for aviation since our discoveries could help the airways optimize the air routes to save passenger time costs, reduce fuel costs and even contribute to the global warming issues.
BibTeX
@misc{xu2022analyses,
  author = {X. H. Xu and Y. Wang and F. S. Wei and X. S. Feng and M. H. Bo and H. W. Tang and D. S. Wang and Bolin Lei and B. Y. Wang and P. B. Zuo and C. W. Jiang and X. J. Xu and Zhiqiang Zhou and Z. Li and P. Zou and L. D. Wang and YAN-MING GU and Y. L. Chen and W. Y. Zhang and P. Sun},
  title = {{Analyses of Flight Time During Solar Proton Events and Solar Flares}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2209.07703},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2209.07703},
}
Figure