An optimal energy storage system sizing determination for improving the utilization and forecasting accuracy of photovoltaic (PV) power stations

Bin Li, Mingzhe Li, Shiye Yan, Yifan Zhang, Bowen Shi, Jilei YeFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

As a new type of flexible regulation resource, energy storage systems (ESS) not only smooth out the fluctuation of new energy generation but also track the generation scheduling combined with new energy power to enhance the reliability of new energy system operations. In recent years, installing energy storage for new on-grid energy power stations has become a basic requirement in China, but there is still a lack of relevant assessment strategies and techno-economic evaluation of the size determination of energy storage systems from the perspective of new energy power stations. Therefore, this paper starts from summarizing the role and configuration method of energy storage in new energy power stations and then proposes multidimensional evaluation indicators, including the solar curtailment rate, forecasting accuracy, and economics, which are taken as the optimization targets for configuring energy storage systems in PV power stations. Lastly, taking the operational data of a 4000 MW PV plant in Belgium, for example, we develop six scenarios with different ratios of energy storage capacity and further explore the impact of energy storage size on the solar curtailment rate, PV curtailment power, and economics. The method proposed in this paper is effective for the performance evaluation of large PV power stations with annual operating data, realizes the automatic analysis on the optimal size determination of energy storage system for PV power stations, and verifies the rationality of the principle for configuring energy storage for PV power stations in some regions of China.

Introduction

As solar energy penetration grows, grid operators face two major challenges: intermittency (the sun doesn't always shine) and forecasting errors (predicting exactly how much it will shine is difficult). When a PV station produces more power than the grid can handle, that energy is "curtailed" or wasted. Conversely, if a station fails to meet its predicted output, it often faces stiff financial penalties from grid operators.

While many regions now mandate ESS installation for new PV plants, there is a lack of clear, techno-economic strategies for sizing these systems. If the battery is too small, the plant loses money on penalties and wasted energy; if it’s too large, the massive upfront investment eats all the profits. This paper presents a multidimensional optimization framework to determine the "Goldilocks" size for ESS paired with large-scale solar farms.

Methodology

The researchers developed a MATLAB-based simulation that evaluates ESS sizing through three primary lenses:

  1. Solar Curtailment Rate: Measuring how much potential energy is recovered by the battery instead of being wasted.
  2. Forecasting Accuracy: Using the ESS to "buffer" output so the plant more closely follows its predicted generation schedule, thereby avoiding grid penalties.
  3. Economics: Calculating the net revenue by subtracting the initial investment and maintenance costs from the gains in sold energy and avoided penalties.

A key feature of their method is the integration of real-world "Penalty Rules" (specifically from the Jiangsu Province Grid in China). They analyzed data at 15-minute intervals (96 points per day) to simulate how a battery would charge during surplus and discharge to meet forecasting commitments or night-time demand.

Figure 1: Statistical process for determining unqualified forecasting points and associated penalties based on grid regulations.

The study validated its model using a massive real-world dataset from a 4000 MW PV plant in Belgium, consisting of 35,040 sample points over one year. The authors created six distinct scenarios with ESS-to-PV power ratios ranging from 8% to 15%.

Key Results and Insights

  • The 11% Sweet Spot: For the specific economic and climatic conditions studied, a power ratio of 11% was optimal. At this level, the system maximized profit while bringing the solar curtailment rate well below the 5% industry benchmark.
  • Curtailment Reduction: Without storage, the plant had an average solar curtailment rate of 8.07%. Adding an 11% ratio ESS slashed this to 2.89%.
  • Profitability and Penalty Avoidance: The maximum annual net income reached 3.17 million RMB at the 11% ratio. At this optimal sizing, the number of "unqualified" forecasting points dropped by 203 per year, significantly lowering regulatory fines.
  • The Diminishing Returns of Sizing: Increasing battery size isn't always better. While a larger battery consistently reduces energy waste, the net income follows a bell curve. Once the ESS ratio exceeded 12%, net income turned negative, proving that over-sizing is a major financial risk for developers.

Conclusion

This research provides a robust framework for determining the optimal size of ESS for large-scale PV stations by balancing technical performance with economic viability. While the results are heavily tied to regional penalty structures and weather data, the methodology realizes automatic analysis for optimal size determination. Future work should explore how different storage technologies (like flow batteries) and long-term battery degradation might shift these economic forecasts.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a new type of flexible regulation resource, energy storage systems not only smooth out the fluctuation of new energy generation but also track the generation scheduling combined with new energy power to enhance the reliability of new energy system operations. In recent years, installing energy storage for new on-grid energy power stations has become a basic requirement in China, but there is still a lack of relevant assessment strategies and techno-economic evaluation of the size determination of energy storage systems from the perspective of new energy power stations. Therefore, this paper starts from summarizing the role and configuration method of energy storage in new energy power stations and then proposes multidimensional evaluation indicators, including the solar curtailment rate, forecasting accuracy, and economics, which are taken as the optimization targets for configuring energy storage systems in PV power stations. Lastly, taking the operational data of a 4000 MWPV plant in Belgium, for example, we develop six scenarios with different ratios of energy storage capacity and further explore the impact of energy storage size on the solar curtailment rate, PV curtailment power, and economics. The method proposed in this paper is effective for the performance evaluation of large PV power stations with annual operating data, realizes the automatic analysis on the optimal size determination of energy storage system for PV power stations, and verifies the rationality of the principle for configuring energy storage for PV power stations in some regions of China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023optimal,
  author = {Bin Li and Mingzhe Li and Shiye Yan and Yifan Zhang and Bowen Shi and Jilei Ye},
  title = {{An optimal energy storage system sizing determination for improving the utilization and forecasting accuracy of photovoltaic (PV) power stations}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.1074916},
}
Figure