An Open Solution to Provide Personalized Feedback for Building Energy Management

Andrea Monacchi, Fabio Versolatto, Manuel Herold, Dominik Egarter, Andrea M. Tonello, Wilfried Elmenreich

TL;DR

This paper introduces Mjölnir, an open-source energy management system designed to provide personalized, real-time feedback to users about their energy consumption. By analyzing data from households in Italy and Austria, the system formulates energy efficiency policies and offers tailored advice to encourage optimal resource utilization, aiming to improve grid stability and reduce energy waste.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing integration of renewable energy sources, with their inherent variability, is making it more challenging to balance electricity supply and demand. This dynamic nature necessitates better utilization of energy resources, which is difficult without efficient storage solutions. Demand-response mechanisms, where consumers adjust their usage based on grid conditions (often signaled by price), are crucial. However, the effectiveness of these mechanisms hinges on timely and understandable information exchange between the grid and consumers. Traditional billing systems have a significant delay between usage and feedback, making it hard for users to grasp their consumption patterns. This paper addresses the need for an interactive system that provides immediate, personalized feedback to empower users to manage their energy consumption effectively.

Methods

The authors developed an interactive energy management system, named Mjölnir, which is released as an open-source framework. The system comprises:

  • Hardware Measurement Units: These collect energy usage data at various granularities, from aggregate household consumption to individual appliance-level readings.
  • Management Software: This analyzes the collected data to identify usage patterns, formulate energy efficiency policies, and generate personalized feedback.
  • Advisor Widget: This component of the Mjölnir system autonomously analyzes user behavior and provides tailored energy feedback and advice.
  • Data Analysis: The system leverages data from monitored households to derive insights into usage behavior and inform the design of effective energy efficiency policies.
  • Feedback Categorization: The paper references Darby's classification of feedback into "indirect" (after consumption) and "direct" (during consumption), highlighting the benefits of direct feedback for immediate awareness.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the GREEND dataset. This dataset contains power profiles of selected devices from households in Italy and Austria, collected at 1 Hz resolution for approximately one year. The paper also mentions a specific measurement campaign conducted for two old fridges at site S5 due to coverage limitations of the GREEND dataset for those specific appliances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Fridge is the "Energy Hog": Across all monitored sites, the refrigerator consistently emerged as the most significant energy-consuming device, accounting for 40-47% of total monitored consumption. This highlights a key area for potential efficiency improvements.
  • Summer Peaks: Consumption peaks were observed during summer months, attributed to higher ambient temperatures, suggesting that cooling systems contribute significantly to energy demand.
  • Time-Dependent Tariffs Offer Limited Savings: While users in Italy are aware of and utilize time-dependent energy tariffs (shifting usage to off-peak hours), the actual monetary savings are minimal (e.g., 12 cents for a washing machine shift). This suggests that current tariff structures may not be sufficient to drive significant behavioral change.
  • Plasma vs. LCD TVs: Plasma televisions consume significantly more energy than LCD TVs, suggesting a potential for energy savings by swapping them or using plasma TVs in rooms associated with off-peak periods.
  • Standby Power is a Real Waste: Devices like televisions and decoders being left on standby mode contribute to a notable amount of wasted energy (e.g., 14% of total consumption in site S7 from 10 devices in standby).
  • Personalized Feedback is Key: The effectiveness of energy management systems is enhanced by providing personalized advice, tailored to individual usage patterns and device types.

Key Results

  • The study identified several energy efficiency policies, including:
  • Lighting: Promoting the use of energy-saving bulbs.
  • Device Diagnostics and Replacement: Encouraging the replacement of old, inefficient appliances (e.g., fridges) with newer, more efficient models. Replacing two old freezers with A+++ class ones could save 34 kWh per month (11% of total consumption for site S5).
  • Shedding of Standby Losses: Recommending the switch-off of devices in standby mode when not in use.
  • Device Shifting: Encouraging the postponement of energy-demanding tasks to off-peak periods.
  • Implementing these policies could yield significant savings, with estimations suggesting up to 34% savings in some cases. For example, shifting plasma TV usage to off-peak periods could result in 34% and 23% lower energy consumption for sites S4 and S5, respectively.
  • The Mjölnir framework was developed, offering a platform for implementing and assessing various feedback concepts, including disaggregated consumption information, production data, and tailored advice.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset Generality: The GREEND dataset, while comprehensive for Austrian and Italian scenarios, may lack generality. Future work should extend the analysis to include production from renewables and electrical vehicles to develop more universally applicable policies.
  • Load Disaggregation: While Mjölnir integrates with external load disaggregation modules via a RESTful interface, the authors envision integrating a load disaggregation unit directly into the Mjölnir project, potentially based on particle filtering.
  • Occupancy Modeling: To effectively suggest device shedding (e.g., for standby losses), a model of occupancy should be introduced and automatically learned.
  • Bidirectional Communication: For demand response to be fully exploited, energy-involving processes need to be automated. This requires bidirectional communication between controllable loads and the visualization dashboard.
  • Social Features: Further development of social features is planned, including a widget to compare users' performance against their peers, showing the distance from the best and worst performing friends.
  • Validation: While potential savings were estimated, real-world experiments with end-users are necessary to ultimately validate the proposed policies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The integration of renewable energy sources increases the complexity in mantaining the power grid. In particular, the highly dynamic nature of generation and consumption demands for a better utilization of energy resources, which seen the cost of storage infrastructure, can only be achieved through demand-response. Accordingly, the availability of energy and potential overload situations can be reflected using a price signal. The effectiveness of this mechanism arises from the flexibility of device operation, which is nevertheless heavily reliant on the exchange of information between the grid and its consumers. In this paper, we investigate the capability of an interactive energy management system to timely inform users on energy usage, in order to promote an optimal use of local resources. In particular, we analyze data being collected in several households in Italy and Austria to gain insights into usage behavior and drive the design of more effective systems. The outcome is the formulation of energy efficiency policies for residential buildings, as well as the design of an energy management system, consisting of hardware measurement units and a management software. The Mj\"olnir framework, which we release for open use, provides a platform where various feedback concepts can be implemented and assessed. This includes widgets displaying disaggregated and aggregated consumption information, as well as daily production and tailored advices. The formulated policies were implemented as an advisor widget able to autonomously analyze usage and provide tailored energy feedback.
BibTeX
@article{monacchi2017open,
  author = {Andrea Monacchi and Fabio Versolatto and Manuel Herold and Dominik Egarter and Andrea M. Tonello and Wilfried Elmenreich},
  title = {{An Open Solution to Provide Personalized Feedback for Building Energy Management}},
  journal = {J. Ambient Intell. Smart Environ.},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=7g9O4yNHnbN},
}
Figure