Abstract The eye’s natural aging influences our ability to focus on close objects. Without optical correction, all adults will suffer from blurry close vision starting in their 40s. In effect, different optical corrections are necessary for near and far vision. Current state-of-the-art glasses offer a gradual change of correction across the field of view for any distance—using Progressive Addition Lenses (PALs). However, an inevitable side effect of PALs is geometric distortion, which causes the swim effect, a phenomenon of unstable perception of the environment leading to discomfort for many wearers. Unfortunately, little is known about the relationship between lens distortions and their perceptual effects, that is, between the complex physical distortions on the one hand and their subjective severity on the other. We show that perceived distortion can be measured as a psychophysical scaling function using a VR experiment with accurately simulated PAL distortions. Despite the multi-dimensional space of physical distortions, the measured perception is well represented as a 1D scaling function; distortions are perceived less with negative far correction, suggesting an advantage for short-sighted people. Beyond that, our results successfully demonstrate that psychophysical scaling with ordinal embedding methods can investigate complex perceptual phenomena like lens distortions that affect geometry, stereo, and motion perception. Our approach provides a new perspective on lens design based on modeling visual processing that could be applied beyond distortions. We anticipate that future PAL designs could be improved using our method to minimize subjectively discomforting distortions rather than merely optimizing physical parameters.
Introduction: The Challenge of Presbyopia
As we age, the eye’s natural lens loses its flexibility, a condition known as presbyopia. This makes it difficult to focus on close objects, typically starting in one's 40s. To correct this, Progressive Addition Lenses (PALs) provide a seamless gradient of optical power, allowing wearers to see clearly at all distances. However, this convenience comes with a mathematical trade-off: peripheral aberrations. According to the Minkwitz theorem, it is mathematically impossible to eliminate these aberrations when creating a power gradient.
These aberrations manifest as geometric distortions, leading to the "swim effect"—a disorienting sensation where the visual world appears to warp or move during head motion. Despite decades of lens engineering, the industry has lacked a rigorous way to measure how users subjectively perceive these distortions, often relying on physical metrics that do not always correlate with wearer comfort.
Methodology: Quantifying Perception through Virtual Reality
To bridge the gap between physical lens parameters and human experience, researchers developed a novel psychophysical approach using Virtual Reality (VR). By simulating PAL distortions within a controlled, immersive environment, they could isolate and measure the "swim effect" with high precision.
The study utilized an XTAL VR headset to present 10 different PAL designs to subjects. Instead of using arbitrary rating scales, the team employed a "triplet paradigm." Participants were shown three stimuli and asked to identify which of two choices was more similar to a central "anchor" stimulus. This relative judgment task, combined with Soft Ordinal Embedding (SOE), allowed the researchers to map complex, multi-dimensional distortions onto a single, intuitive psychophysical scale.
Results: Simplicity in Complexity
The results revealed several surprising aspects of how we process visual distortion. Most strikingly, despite the complex physics of lens geometry, stereo, and motion cues, the human brain perceives the intensity of distortion along a surprisingly simple one-dimensional scale.
Furthermore, the study identified a "myopia advantage": distortions are perceived as significantly less severe when combined with negative spherical power (correction for short-sightedness). This suggests that myopic individuals may have a natural advantage when adapting to new progressive lenses. Interestingly, whether observers moved their heads to induce dynamic "swim" or remained static, the resulting perceptual scales were nearly identical. This indicates that the global pattern of distortion is the primary driver of perception, regardless of the specific visual cues being utilized.
The relationship between a lens's physical power and its perceived distortion was found to follow a predictable exponential function ($a + b \cdot c^{Sph}$). This model achieved high accuracy, with $R^2$ scores near 0.95 for the majority of subjects, suggesting that future lens designs could be evaluated for comfort before they are even manufactured.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While this research provides a powerful new framework for lens design, it also opens new questions. Current simulations focused on geometric distortion; however, real-world lenses also introduce blur (astigmatism). Future iterations of this VR model will likely incorporate realistic blur to study the interaction between clarity and stability.
By shifting the focus from optimizing physical parameters to minimizing subjective discomfort, this perceptual approach promises a future where progressive glasses are easier to wear and more comfortable for everyone. Future PAL designs could be improved using this method to minimize subjectively discomforting distortions rather than merely optimizing physical parameters.
Summary updated