Encapsulated water in a supramolecular $Ga_4$$L_6$$^{-12}$ cage is neither ice- nor bulk water-like

Federico Sebastiani, Trandon A. Bender, Simone Pezzotti, Wan‐Lu Li, Gerhard Schwaab, Robert G. Bergman, Kenneth N. Raymond, F. Dean Toste, Teresa Head‐Gordon, Stefan Henkel

Introduction

Supramolecular capsules, such as the $Ga_4L_6^{12-}$ assembly, serve as synthetic nanoreactors that mimic the confined environments of enzyme active sites. A critical but poorly understood aspect of these systems is the state of water molecules trapped within the cavity before a substrate enters. Understanding this "starting state" is essential because the displacement of these water molecules—a process known as desolvation—provides the primary thermodynamic driving force for guest binding and subsequent catalysis.

Experimental and Computational Methodology

To probe the nature of this confined water, researchers employed a combination of Terahertz (THz) absorption spectroscopy and Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics (AIMD) simulations. THz spectroscopy is uniquely suited for this task as it is sensitive to the collective, low-frequency vibrations of hydrogen-bond networks. The team utilized the B97M-rV functional, a sophisticated "meta-GGA" method known for its accuracy in modeling water interactions.

Experimental setup and THz spectra. (A) Water-filled cage (1). (B) Cage occupied by a bulky guest (2). (C) Isolated THz absorption spectra for both states.

By comparing the spectra of the water-filled cage (1) with a cage occupied by a bulky tetraethylammonium ($Et_4N^+$) cation (2), the researchers could "subtract" the cage's own vibrational signature. This allowed them to isolate the specific spectral contribution of the encapsulated water molecules, as shown in Figure 2C.

The "Magic Number" 9 and Dynamical Arrest

The study revealed that approximately $9 \pm 1$ water molecules are "dynamically distinct" within the cage. While the cavity can hold more, these nine molecules exhibit significantly slower orientational relaxation—about 2.5 times slower than bulk water—indicating a state of "dynamical arrest."

Comparison of experimental and simulated THz spectra. The main plot shows the difference spectrum ($\Delta\Delta\alpha$) compared against simulations for 8, 9, and 10 water molecules. Inset: Comparison of the encapsulated water signature with bulk ice phases.

As shown in the spectral analysis in Figure 5, the experimental THz data were best reproduced by simulations containing exactly 9 water molecules. Furthermore, the spectral signature of this confined water is distinct from both bulk liquid and various ice phases (Ih and amorphous), as seen in the inset. The spectrum shows a characteristic narrowing (55% narrower than bulk water), which is a hallmark of a restricted environment with reduced configurational entropy.

A "Frustrated" Droplet

Analysis of the hydrogen-bonding (HB) network revealed that the encapsulated water is severely undercoordinated. While bulk water typically forms 3.4 HBs per molecule and ice forms 4, the water inside the $Ga_4L_6^{12-}$ cage manages only about 1.8 HBs. This creates a "frustrated" droplet that is energetically "unhappy" due to missing bonds and entropically "unhappy" due to confinement. This state is neither liquid-like nor ice-like, but rather a unique phase of matter dictated by the nanoconfinement.

Conclusion: Thermodynamic Drive for Catalysis

The unique, non-ice-like state of the encapsulated water has profound implications for the cage's function. Because the water cluster is both high-energy (undercoordinated) and low-entropy (arrested), its displacement into the bulk liquid is highly favorable. This "inherent thermodynamic drive" explains why these supramolecular cages are so effective at capturing substrates, effectively using the "frustration" of confined water to power chemical transformations.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{sebastiani2020encapsulated,
  author = {Federico Sebastiani and Trandon A. Bender and Simone Pezzotti and Wan‐Lu Li and Gerhard Schwaab and Robert G. Bergman and Kenneth N. Raymond and F. Dean Toste and Teresa Head‐Gordon and Stefan Henkel},
  title = {{Encapsulated water in a supramolecular $Ga\_4$$L\_6$$^\{-12\}$ cage is neither ice- nor bulk water-like}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2004.09688},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.09688},
}
Figure