An Investigation of Optimized Carbon Tax-Subsidy Mechanism to Enhance Power System Sustainability Considering Wind Power Penetration

Nima Shafaghatian, Hadi Hosseini, Reza NoroozianIEEE Access 2024 · DOI

Introduction

Decarbonizing the global power grid is no longer a choice but a necessity. While carbon taxes have long been proposed as an economic instrument to penalize fossil fuel power plants (FFPP), their implementation often faces significant hurdles. A primary concern is the potential for sharp increases in electricity prices, which can negatively impact consumers and suppress economic demand. This paper presents a novel approach to this dilemma: the Optimized Carbon Tax-Subsidy Mechanism (OCTSM). By dynamically recycling carbon tax revenue into subsidies for wind power plants (WPP), the framework aims to maximize grid sustainability without compromising economic stability.

The Proposed Framework (OCTSM)

The core of this research is the development of a comprehensive Power System Sustainability Index (PSSI). Unlike traditional metrics that focus solely on emissions or costs, the PSSI aggregates system operational costs, electricity prices, consumer demand levels, and CO2 emissions into a single objective function.

Conceptual framework of the OCTSM and its impact on the Power System Sustainability Index (PSSI).

To optimize this index, the OCTSM utilizes a sophisticated double-loop iterative process. The Inner Loop manages market dispatch by applying a non-linear carbon tax to FFPPs and immediately reallocating that revenue as a subsidy to WPPs. Because these financial shifts alter the AC Optimal Power Flow (AC-OPF), the system must iterate until the tax collected matches the subsidy paid. The Outer Loop then accounts for consumer behavior through a Price-Based Demand Response (PBDR) model, where demand fluctuates based on the resulting electricity prices. A Genetic Algorithm (GA) serves as the master optimizer, tuning the tax coefficients to find the peak PSSI value.

Methodology and Data

The model was validated using a modified IEEE 24-bus test system integrated with six wind turbines. To ensure realistic results, the authors incorporated:

  • Wind Uncertainty: Probabilistic wind scenarios were generated using Weibull distributions and scenario reduction techniques.
  • Economic Grounding: Demand price elasticity matrices and a social cost of carbon ($50/ton) were sourced from established literature.
  • Grid Constraints: The model respects the physical limitations of the grid, including the minimum production requirements of fossil fuel plants necessary for system stability.

Key Insights: The 100% Subsidy and Saturation Effects

One of the paper's most significant findings is the "Closed-Loop Economics" of the grid. Because taxes change dispatch patterns, they inherently change the very emissions they are meant to tax. The study proves that the system performs optimally when 100% of carbon tax revenue is recycled into wind subsidies. This full recycling effectively buffers the price spikes that a standalone tax would cause, creating a symbiotic relationship between environmental goals and consumer interests.

However, the research also identifies a critical "Saturation Effect." While increasing wind capacity initially leads to massive sustainability gains, the benefits eventually hit a ceiling. This is due to the non-linear costs associated with managing high renewable penetration and the grid's requirement to maintain baseline fossil fuel generation for reliability.

Results and Discussion

The OCTSM was tested across three scenarios with increasing wind turbine capacities (300 MW, 350 MW, and 400 MW per turbine):

  • Scenario 1 (300 MW): The optimized mechanism reduced CO2 emissions by 26.42% and increased the PSSI by 30.4%.
  • Scenario 2 (350 MW): CO2 emissions dropped by 33.08%, while the PSSI rose by 50.2%.
  • Scenario 3 (400 MW): Emissions were reduced by 36.60%, and the PSSI increased by 62.8%.

Notably, the jump from Scenario 1 to 2 provided a much larger relative improvement in sustainability than the jump from Scenario 2 to 3. This confirms the diminishing returns of simply adding more renewable capacity without addressing underlying infrastructure constraints.

Conclusion

The Optimized Carbon Tax-Subsidy Mechanism provides a robust roadmap for transitioning to a greener grid. By treating the carbon tax not as a penalty to be collected, but as a resource to be recycled, the OCTSM achieves significant decarbonization while protecting the consumer. Future research will focus on non-linear subsidy models and the integration of energy storage systems to overcome the current saturation limits and further reduce the grid's reliance on baseline fossil fuel generation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{shafaghatian2024investigation,
  author = {Nima Shafaghatian and Hadi Hosseini and Reza Noroozian},
  title = {{An Investigation of Optimized Carbon Tax-Subsidy Mechanism to Enhance Power System Sustainability Considering Wind Power Penetration}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2024.3406632},
}
Figure