An Investigation of Customer Psychological Perceptions of Green Consciousness in a Green Hotel Context: Applying a Extended Theory of Planned Behavior

Taeuk Kim, Jung-Woo HaInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how customers' perceptions of green hotels influence their eco-friendly behavior. By extending the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) with concepts like "willingness to sacrifice for the environment," the research found that a hotel's green image and the psychological benefits customers derive from it significantly impact their green consciousness, which in turn drives their eco-friendly actions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The hospitality industry, particularly hotels, has a significant environmental footprint. While "green hotels" aim to mitigate this impact, understanding what truly motivates customers to engage in eco-friendly behaviors within this context remains a challenge. Previous research has explored various factors, but this paper aims to provide a more comprehensive model by integrating customers' psychological perceptions, their awareness of corporate social responsibility (CSR), and established behavioral theories like the TPB. Specifically, it seeks to bridge the gap between customers' awareness of environmental issues and their actual eco-friendly actions in a green hotel setting, addressing the question of how to effectively encourage sustainable choices among hotel guests.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using a survey methodology. They collected data from 410 customers of green hotels in Seoul, South Korea. The core of their analytical framework is the Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), a statistical technique used to analyze complex relationships between multiple variables. They utilized SPSS 18.0 and Amos 20.0 for data analysis.

A key methodological contribution is the extension of the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB). The standard TPB includes attitude, subjective norm, and perceived behavioral control as predictors of behavioral intention. This study augmented the TPB by incorporating:

  • Image Perception of Green Corporate Social Responsibility (IP-GCSR)
  • Green Psychological Benefit (GPB)
  • Green Consciousness (GC)
  • Willingness to Sacrifice for the Environment (WSE)

This expanded model allowed them to explore a broader range of psychological and social factors influencing green behavior. They also implemented procedural remedies to mitigate Common Method Bias (CMB), such as using different cover stories for survey sections and providing clear definitions for terms.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset collected from 410 customers of green hotels in Seoul, South Korea. The data was gathered through a two-part online and offline survey conducted between March 10 and April 9, 2022. The survey included demographic information and measures for various constructs related to green behavior and perceptions. No new benchmarks were introduced; instead, existing validated scales were adapted and employed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Green Image Matters: A hotel's perceived commitment to environmental responsibility (IP-GCSR) is a strong driver of customers' green consciousness. This suggests that marketing and communication efforts highlighting a hotel's green initiatives can have a direct impact on customer awareness and concern.
  • Psychological Benefits Drive Consciousness: Beyond just the image, the positive psychological feelings customers derive from staying at a green hotel (GPB) also contribute to their green consciousness. This highlights the importance of the experience of green hospitality.
  • Bridging the Intention-Action Gap: The study reinforces the TPB's components (attitude, subjective norm, perceived behavioral control) as significant predictors of green behavior. However, it also emphasizes that these alone might not be sufficient.
  • Willingness to Sacrifice is Key: The inclusion of "willingness to sacrifice for the environment" (WSE) as an extended TPB variable proved crucial. This concept, representing a customer's readiness to accept minor inconveniences or costs for environmental benefit, significantly influences their actual green behavior. This is a novel contribution to understanding eco-friendly choices in the hotel context.
  • Overcoming the Price Premium: The research suggests that by effectively communicating the benefits and fostering a positive perception of green practices, hotels can encourage customers to overcome potential price premiums associated with eco-friendly options (e.g., willingness to pay a premium price, intention to revisit).

Key Results

The SEM analysis confirmed most of the hypothesized relationships:

  • IP-GCSR had a significant positive effect on GC (β = 0.319).
  • GPB had a significant positive effect on GC (β = 0.124).
  • GC significantly influenced GATB (attitude, β = 0.180), GSN (subjective norm, β = 0.314), and GPBC (perceived behavioral control, β = 0.140).
  • GC also had a significant positive effect on GB (green behavior, β = 0.244).
  • The TPB components (GATB, GSN, GPBC) all had significant positive effects on GB (β = 0.246, 0.439, and 0.156, respectively).
  • GC had a significant positive effect on WSE (β = 0.094).
  • Crucially, WSE had a significant positive effect on GB (β = 0.189).

The model explained a substantial portion of the variance in green behavior (R²(GB) = 0.328).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Online Survey Limitations: The reliance on online surveys might have limited participant engagement or led to less detailed responses compared to in-person interactions.
  • Recall Bias: The survey was conducted over a 14-day period, and participants were asked about their experiences within the last six months. This time gap could lead to memory recall issues.
  • Contextual Factors: The study did not deeply explore how the purpose of the visit (business, leisure) or the company (family, friends) might influence eco-friendly experiences and behaviors.
  • Pandemic Influence: The research was conducted during the COVID-19 pandemic, which could have influenced participants' perceptions and behaviors related to health, safety, and travel.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Cross-Cultural Comparisons: Analyzing the influence of image and benefits across different cultural contexts (Asian vs. Western) would be valuable.
  • In-depth Interviews: Conducting direct interviews could provide richer qualitative data.
  • Exploring Visitor Context: Investigating how trip purpose and travel companions affect eco-friendly experiences.
  • Timelier Data Collection: Conducting research in a post-pandemic context to understand evolving attitudes.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigated the relationship between green consciousness and green behavior, and the relationship between psychological state, attitude, and behavior of green hotel customers by applying variables suitable for an expanded theory of planned behavior. The purpose of the study was to predict green behavior based on the theory of planned behavior. Together with preceding research including the correlation between customers' image perception of green corporate social responsibility (CSR), green psychological benefit, and green consciousness, we added willingness to sacrifice for the environment to define the relationship with green consciousness and green behavior. A survey was conducted with 410 customers of green hotels in Seoul, Korea more than twice over a period of over 6~12 months. Vague and insincere answers were removed. SPSS 18.0 and Amos 20.0 were used to conduct factor and SEM data analysis. Our theory was verified and adopted following validation from our analysis. The results have important theoretical and practical implications for the environment by providing primary data on customers' perceptions of eco friendliness to support the establishment of corporate management strategies. Moreover, they may encourage green hotels to participate in preventing environmental problems.
BibTeX
@article{kim2022investigation,
  author = {Taeuk Kim and Jung-Woo Ha},
  title = {{An Investigation of Customer Psychological Perceptions of Green Consciousness in a Green Hotel Context: Applying a Extended Theory of Planned Behavior}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19116795},
}
Figure