An Information-Theoretic Analysis of Hard and Soft Assignment Methods for Clustering

Michael J. Kearns, Yishay Mansour, Andrew Y. Ng

TL;DR

This paper provides an information-theoretic analysis of K-means and EM clustering algorithms, revealing a fundamental trade-off K-means must manage: balancing cluster similarity with data distribution across clusters. This analysis explains why K-means often finds less overlapping cluster densities than EM.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Clustering algorithms like K-means and EM are workhorses in unsupervised learning. While we know K-means minimizes data distortion and EM maximizes likelihood, their systematic behavioral differences remain somewhat mysterious. This paper aims to bridge this gap by offering a theoretical framework to understand why these algorithms, despite their superficial similarities, can converge to different solutions, particularly in how they model underlying data distributions.

Methods

The core of the paper is an information-theoretic decomposition of the "partition loss," a measure of how well a set of cluster models (Po, P1) represent data partitioned by an assignment function (F). For K-means, this loss can be expressed as a sum of:

  • Modeling Terms: The Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between the true data distribution within a cluster (Q_b) and the model for that cluster (P_b). This measures how well the cluster models fit the data assigned to them.
  • Partition Information Term: The entropy of the partition itself, which quantifies how balanced or informative the assignment is.

This decomposition highlights the "information-modeling trade-off" inherent in K-means: it must balance fitting the data within clusters (minimizing KL divergence) with ensuring the data is spread evenly across clusters (maximizing partition entropy). EM, in contrast, primarily focuses on maximizing the overall data likelihood, without this explicit partition entropy consideration. The paper also introduces and analyzes a "posterior assignment" method.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses synthetic data generated from specified distributions for its examples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Information-Modeling Trade-off: K-means implicitly balances two competing goals: making cluster models accurate (low KL divergence) and making the assignment of data points to clusters informative (high partition entropy). EM, by focusing on overall likelihood, doesn't have this explicit partition entropy component.
  • K-means Bias Towards Less Overlap: The information-theoretic decomposition suggests that K-means, due to its hard assignment nature and the partition entropy term, tends to find cluster densities (Po, P1) that are more distinct and have less overlap compared to EM.
  • Weighted K-means: Introducing weights into K-means effectively removes the "information" component of the trade-off, making it solely focused on minimizing modeling error, leading to different behavior.
  • Posterior Assignment: A third assignment method is explored, which is probabilistically assigned based on cluster densities. While seemingly similar to EM's soft assignments, it leads to distinct algorithmic behavior and loss functions.

Key Results

  • The paper provides a formal decomposition of the K-means loss, showing it's a combination of KL divergences and partition entropy.
  • Through examples, the authors demonstrate how this trade-off leads K-means to solutions that differ from EM, often favoring less overlapping cluster densities. For instance, in Example (A), K-means converges to a solution with lower K-means loss but higher KL divergence than the initial parameters, illustrating the trade-off.
  • In Example (B), the paper shows how the partition entropy term can drive K-means to find more informative partitions even at the cost of increased KL divergence, a behavior not seen in EM.
  • The analysis suggests that K-means might implicitly encourage "different" component densities, as evidenced by experiments showing K-means solutions with larger variation distances between component densities compared to EM.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Two Clusters: The paper primarily concentrates on the case of two clusters for simplicity of development, though it notes that the results hold for the general K-cluster case.
  • Local Minima: Both K-means and EM are iterative algorithms that find local minima. The analysis focuses on understanding the nature of these local minima for each algorithm.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that the analysis provides a justification for why K-means might be preferred for certain clustering tasks where distinctness of clusters is important. The authors also hint at further exploration of the "posterior assignment" method and its implications. The experimental results are based on synthetic data, and real-world dataset performance would be a natural next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Assignment methods are at the heart of many algorithms for unsupervised learning and clustering — in particular, the well-known K-means and Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithms. In this work, we study several different methods of assignment, including the “hard” assignments used by K-means and the “soft” assignments used by EM. While it is known that K-means minimizes the distortion on the data and EM maximizes the likelihood, little is known about the systematic differences of behavior between the two algorithms. Here we shed light on these differences via an information-theoretic analysis. The cornerstone of our results is a simple decomposition of the expected distortion, showing that K-means (and its extension for inferring general parametric densities from unlabeled sample data) must implicitly manage a trade-off between how similar the data assigned to each cluster are, and how the data are balanced among the clusters. How well the data are balanced is measured by the entropy of the partition defined by the hard assignments. In addition to letting us predict and verify systematic differences between K-means and EM on specific examples, the decomposition allows us to give a rather general argument showing that K-means will consistently find densities with less “overlap” than EM. We also study a third natural assignment method that we call posterior assignment, that is close in spirit to the soft assignments of EM, but leads to a surprisingly different algorithm.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kearns1998information,
  author = {Michael J. Kearns and Yishay Mansour and Andrew Y. Ng},
  title = {{An Information-Theoretic Analysis of Hard and Soft Assignment Methods for Clustering}},
  booktitle = {Learning in Graphical Models},
  year = {1998},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=OJ9QeIlepqe},
}
Figure