An increase in the posterior subarachnoid space accelerates the timing of syrinx resolution after foramen magnum decompression of type I Chiari malformation

Yu‐ichiro Ohnishi, S Fujiwara, T Takenaka, Saki Kawamoto, Koichi Iwatsuki, Haruhiko KishimaScientific 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Syrinx resolution has been associated with an increase in the size of the posterior subarachnoid space (pSAS) after foramen magnum decompression (FMD) for type I Chiari malformation (CM1). The present study investigated the influence of pSAS increase on syrinx resolution and symptom improvement after FMD. 32 patients with CM1 with syrinx were analyzed retrospectively. FMD was performed for the 24 patients with CM1 with syrinx. pSAS areas were measured on sagittal magnetic resonance images. Neurological symptoms were grouped into three clinical categories and scored. The rates of symptom improvement in the CM1 patients with syrinx after FMD was 19.7% ± 12.9%. The mean times to the improvement of neurological symptoms in CM1 patients with syrinx after FMD was 23.4 ± 50.2 months. There were no significant differences between the patients with and without improvement of syrinx after FMD with regard to the age, length of tonsillar herniation, BMI, and preoperative pSAS areas. The rate of increase in the pSAS areas was significantly higher in the group with syrinx improvement within 1 year (p < 0.0001). All patients with a > 50% rate of increase in the pSAS area showed syrinx improvement. Our results suggested that the increasing postoperative pSAS area accelerated the timing of syrinx resolution.

Introduction

Type I Chiari malformation (CM1) is a condition where the cerebellar tonsils are displaced through the foramen magnum, obstructing the normal flow of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). This obstruction often leads to the formation of a syrinx—a fluid-filled cavity within the spinal cord that can cause permanent nerve damage. The standard treatment is Foramen Magnum Decompression (FMD) surgery, which aims to create space for CSF circulation. While surgeons recognize that creating space is vital, predicting the speed and success of syrinx resolution has remained difficult. This study investigates whether the measurable increase in the posterior subarachnoid space (pSAS) on MRI can serve as a reliable predictor for recovery timing.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective study of 32 patients with CM1 and associated syringomyelia, 24 of whom underwent FMD surgery. Radiological assessment utilized T2-weighted MRI scans to measure the pSAS area—the space between the dura mater and the spinal cord—on midline sagittal images using ImageJ software.

MRI progression showing the pSAS area (highlighted in yellow) and syrinx resolution from preoperative (Pre) to postoperative (Post) and final follow-up.

Neurological symptoms were categorized into pain, sensory disturbances, and motor disturbances, and scored on a 1–5 scale. Syrinx resolution was defined as at least a 20% reduction in the syrinx-to-spinal-cord ratio or overall length.

Key Results and Insights

The study identified the rate of pSAS expansion as the primary driver for "early improvement" (within one year). Key findings include:

  • The 50% Threshold: Every patient who achieved a >50% increase in their pSAS area showed syrinx improvement. For those with less than a 50% increase, the improvement rate dropped to 40%.
  • Statistical Significance: The rate of pSAS increase was significantly higher in patients who saw syrinx improvement compared to those who did not.
Bar chart illustrating the significantly higher rate of increase in the pSAS area for the improved group (Imp+) compared to the non-improved group (Imp-).
  • Clinical Gains: Postoperative scores for pain and sensory disturbances showed significant improvement (p=0.0019 and p=0.0059, respectively). In patients with syrinx improvement, the mean pSAS area expanded from 49.2 mm² to 95.3 mm².

Discussion and Limitations

The results suggest that syrinx resolution is not merely about removing a physical blockage but about restoring a specific volume of fluid buffer. If surgery successfully "balloons" the subarachnoid space by more than 50%, the syrinx resolves significantly faster.

While promising, the authors acknowledge limitations including the small sample size (24 surgical patients) and the use of 2D sagittal slices rather than 3D volumetric analysis. Future research may refine these morphometric standards to help surgeons choose between different decompression variations, such as the necessity of duraplasty.

Summary updated

Abstract

Syrinx resolution has been associated with an increase in the size of the posterior subarachnoid space (pSAS) after foramen magnum decompression (FMD) for type I Chiari malformation (CM1). The present study investigated the influence of pSAS increase on syrinx resolution and symptom improvement after FMD. 32 patients with CM1 with syrinx were analyzed retrospectively. FMD was performed for the 24 patients with CM1 with syrinx. pSAS areas were measured on sagittal magnetic resonance images. Neurological symptoms were grouped into three clinical categories and scored. The rates of symptom improvement in the CM1 patients with syrinx after FMD was 19.7% ± 12.9%. The mean times to the improvement of neurological symptoms in CM1 patients with syrinx after FMD was 23.4 ± 50.2 months. There were no significant differences between the patients with and without improvement of syrinx after FMD with regard to the age, length of tonsillar herniation, BMI, and preoperative pSAS areas. The rate of increase in the pSAS areas was significantly higher in the group with syrinx improvement within 1 year (p < 0.0001). All patients with a > 50% rate of increase in the pSAS area showed syrinx improvement. Our results suggested that the increasing postoperative pSAS area accelerated the timing of syrinx resolution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ohnishi2021increase,
  author = {Yu‐ichiro Ohnishi and S Fujiwara and T Takenaka and Saki Kawamoto and Koichi Iwatsuki and Haruhiko Kishima},
  title = {{An increase in the posterior subarachnoid space accelerates the timing of syrinx resolution after foramen magnum decompression of type I Chiari malformation}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-98546-z},
}
Figure