An H2-norm approach to performance analysis of networked control systems under multiplicative routing transformations

Ruslan Seifullaev, André M. H. Teixeira

Introduction

Networked Control Systems (NCS) are increasingly vulnerable to cyber-attacks as they rely on shared communication infrastructures. While significant research has focused on additive attacks—where malicious signals are injected into sensor or actuator channels—a more subtle class of threats involves multiplicative (or routing) attacks. In these scenarios, an adversary manipulates the network's structure, such as altering routing tables or sensor fusion weights, rather than injecting external energy.

Because these attacks do not necessarily increase the energy of the system's residuals, they can remain invisible to standard energy-based anomaly detectors. This paper introduces a mathematical framework using $H_2$-norms to quantify the impact of these structural manipulations on system performance and detectability.

The Multiplicative Attack Model

The authors model the attack as a transformation matrix $R$ that modifies the measurement vector $y_m$ before it reaches the controller. Unlike additive noise, this transformation alters the closed-loop dynamics of the system. The resulting system remains linear, but its stability and performance now depend explicitly on the unknown matrix $R$ chosen by the adversary.

System architecture showing the placement of the multiplicative attack between the plant and the controller.

This "energy-neutral" sabotage allows an attacker to reshape feedback pathways. By aligning the routing transformation with the system's internal modes—specifically those that are highly visible to performance outputs but hidden from residual outputs—an attacker can maximize damage while maintaining a low detection profile.

Performance Analysis via $H_2$-Norms

To evaluate the trade-off between performance degradation and detectability, the paper proposes an $H_2$-norm framework. The core of the analysis is the formulation of a performance-to-residual ratio:

  1. The Performance Ratio: The goal is to maximize the ratio between the steady-state energy of the performance output ($y_p$) and the residual output ($y_r$) used for anomaly detection.
  2. LMI Formulations: The authors derive Linear Matrix Inequality (LMI) conditions to make the calculation of worst-case ratios computationally efficient. This allows designers to determine the "safety envelope" of a system under various routing perturbations.
  3. Stochastic Advantage: While $H_\infty$ metrics are common in robust control, the authors argue that $H_2$-norms are more physically meaningful for multiplicative faults. They better capture how the energy of natural stochastic excitation (noise) propagates through the modified system structure.

Numerical Validation and Key Results

The framework was validated using a numerical simulation of a 3-state linear system. The results demonstrate that an adversary can significantly degrade performance without crossing detection thresholds.

In the nominal, attack-free case ($R = I$), the system exhibited a performance-to-residual ratio of approximately 2.46. By implementing a specific diagonal routing matrix that reduced signal power by roughly 30%, an attacker was able to increase this ratio to 5.35. Even under strict stealth requirements (e.g., keeping residual energy below a specific threshold), the adversary could still achieve a ratio of 4.65, representing a nearly twofold increase in performance error relative to detection signals.

Performance-to-residual ratio over time for various attack matrices, demonstrating increased degradation compared to the nominal case (R=I).

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a rigorous method for analyzing the vulnerability of NCS to structural manipulations. By quantifying the stealthy nature of multiplicative attacks, it highlights a critical gap in current anomaly detection strategies.

Future work aims to extend this analysis to non-linear and time-varying systems. Additionally, the authors suggest shifting from analysis to synthesis: designing controllers and observers that are inherently robust to routing manipulations, potentially through the use of "private excitation signals" that make it harder for an attacker to mask their influence on system residuals.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{seifullaev2026h,
  author = {Ruslan Seifullaev and André M. H. Teixeira},
  title = {{An H2-norm approach to performance analysis of networked control systems under multiplicative routing transformations}},
  booktitle = {ECC},
  year = {2026},
}
Figure