An Experimental Study of the Effects of Cylinder Lubricating Oils on the Vibration Characteristics of a Two-Stroke Low-Speed Marine Diesel Engine

Gang Wu, Guodong Jiang, Changsheng Chen, Guohe Jiang, Xigang Pu, Biwen ChenPolish 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Two-stroke, low-speed diesel engines are widely used in large ships due to their good performance and fuel economy. However, there have been few studies of the effects of lubricating oils on the vibration of two-stroke, low-speed diesel engines. In this work, the effects of three different lubricating oils on the vibration characteristics of a low-speed engine are investigated, using the frequency domain, time-frequency domain, fast Fourier transform (FFT) and short-time Fourier transform (STFT) methods. The results show that non-invasive condition monitoring of the wear to a cylinder liner in a low-speed marine engine can be successfully achieved based on vibration signals. Both the FFT and STFT methods are capable of capturing information about combustion in the cylinder online in real time, and the STFT method also provides the ability to visualise the results with more comprehensive information. From the online condition monitoring of vibration signals, cylinder lubricants with medium viscosity and medium alkali content are found to have the best wear protection properties. This result is consistent with those of an elemental analysis of cylinder lubrication properties and an analysis of the data measured from a piston lifted from the cylinder after 300 h of engine operation.

Introduction

Two-stroke, low-speed marine diesel engines are the primary power sources for global maritime trade. Monitoring the health of internal components, particularly the piston-cylinder assembly, is critical but challenging. Traditional maintenance requires manual disassembly, leading to high costs and significant downtime.

As the industry transitions to low-sulfur fuels, the chemical environment within cylinders changes, placing new demands on lubricating oils. These oils must balance alkalinity (Total Base Number, TBN) to neutralize acids and viscosity to reduce friction. Improper oil selection can lead to corrosive wear (low TBN) or abrasive deposits (high TBN). This study investigates whether non-invasive vibration monitoring can serve as a reliable proxy for assessing lubricant performance and cylinder wear.

Experimental Methodology

The researchers utilized a MAN B&W 6S35ME-B9 six-cylinder engine for testing. Three distinct lubricating oil formulations were evaluated:

  • Recipe A: High viscosity (SAE 100) and high alkalinity (TBN 70).
  • Recipe B: Medium viscosity (SAE 40) and medium alkalinity (TBN 40).
  • Recipe C: Medium viscosity (SAE 40) and low alkalinity (TBN 25).
Schematic of the experimental setup including the six-cylinder engine, dynamometer, and data acquisition system.

Tri-axial accelerometers were mounted on cylinder covers, and proximity sensors tracked crankshaft angles. Data was collected at a 5 kHz sampling rate under 25%, 40%, and 50% load conditions. Analysis techniques included time-domain metrics (RMS and Kurtosis), Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) for frequency analysis, and Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) for time-frequency visualization. Validation was performed via a 300-hour steady-state run, elemental analysis of used oil (D-values), and physical piston inspection.

Key Insights and Results

The "Goldilocks" Lubricant

Recipe B (medium TBN/viscosity) demonstrated superior performance. Recipe A's high alkalinity caused abrasive deposits, while Recipe C's low alkalinity failed to neutralize combustion acids, leading to corrosive wear. Physical measurements confirmed this: Recipe B had the lowest iron "D-value" (75.2×10⁻⁶), compared to Recipe A (80×10⁻⁶) and Recipe C (88.2×10⁻⁶). Furthermore, under a 40% load, Recipe B showed a 27.7% reduction in maximum vibration values in the dominant combustion frequency range compared to other oils.

Vibration as a Diagnostic Tool

The study established a direct correlation between vibration signal stability and physical wear. Recipe B exhibited the most stable RMS and Kurtosis distributions, reflecting smoother mechanical operation.

Vibration signal recorded at 98 RPM showing the acceleration peaks corresponding to the firing order (1-5-3-4-2-6) during a complete engine cycle.

While FFT identifies dominant frequencies, STFT proved superior for marine engines by localizing these frequencies in time. This allows for the identification of individual cylinder events within the firing order (1-5-3-4-2-6). The researchers found that combustion shock induces dominant frequencies in the 0.75–1.3 kHz range. Interestingly, inadequate alkalinity (Recipe C) increased high-frequency fluctuations (1.9–2.5 kHz), likely due to increased micro-friction between the piston and liner.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that non-invasive vibration monitoring can successfully track cylinder wear in large-scale marine engines. The effects of lubricating oil on vibration become more pronounced at higher loads, suggesting that condition monitoring is most effective during standard operating speeds. Future work will focus on developing automated fault diagnosis systems capable of distinguishing between specific mechanical issues, such as liner scuffing or piston ring failure, based solely on vibration signatures.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Two-stroke, low-speed diesel engines are widely used in large ships due to their good performance and fuel economy. However, there have been few studies of the effects of lubricating oils on the vibration of two-stroke, low-speed diesel engines. In this work, the effects of three different lubricating oils on the vibration characteristics of a low-speed engine are investigated, using the frequency domain, time-frequency domain, fast Fourier transform (FFT) and short-time Fourier transform (STFT) methods. The results show that non-invasive condition monitoring of the wear to a cylinder liner in a low-speed marine engine can be successfully achieved based on vibration signals. Both the FFT and STFT methods are capable of capturing information about combustion in the cylinder online in real time, and the STFT method also provides the ability to visualise the results with more comprehensive information. From the online condition monitoring of vibration signals, cylinder lubricants with medium viscosity and medium alkali content are found to have the best wear protection properties. This result is consistent with those of an elemental analysis of cylinder lubrication properties and an analysis of the data measured from a piston lifted from the cylinder after 300 h of engine operation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2023experimental,
  author = {Gang Wu and Guodong Jiang and Changsheng Chen and Guohe Jiang and Xigang Pu and Biwen Chen},
  title = {{An Experimental Study of the Effects of Cylinder Lubricating Oils on the Vibration Characteristics of a Two-Stroke Low-Speed Marine Diesel Engine}},
  booktitle = {Polish},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.2478/pomr-2023-0062},
}
Figure