An Exception Handling Approach for Privacy-Preserving Service Recommendation Failure in a Cloud Environment

Lianyong Qi, Shunmei Meng, Xuyun Zhang, Ruili Wang, Xiaolong Xu, Zhili Zhou, Wanchun Dou

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of service recommendation failures in cloud environments, where distributed data and privacy concerns make traditional methods unreliable. They introduce "converse LSH," a novel technique to identify "enemy" users with opposing preferences, and use this to indirectly find friends and handle recommendation failures, improving system robustness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's cloud-centric world, businesses offer numerous web services, and users need help finding the best ones. Service recommendation systems aim to simplify this by suggesting relevant services. However, a significant hurdle arises from the distributed nature of Quality of Service (QoS) data, which is often collected by sensors and stored across different cloud platforms. Integrating this data for accurate recommendations is complex, especially while preserving user privacy.

Existing recommendation systems, even those using techniques like Locality-Sensitive Hashing (LSH) for efficient data integration and privacy, often fail to account for "recommendation failures." These failures occur when the system cannot find any suitable recommendations for a user, significantly reducing the system's robustness. The paper highlights a scenario where users have no directly similar friends in the system, leading to such failures.

Methods

The core contribution of this paper is the development of converse Locality-Sensitive Hashing (converse LSH). Traditional LSH is used to find similar users. Converse LSH, however, is designed to find users with opposite preferences, termed "enemies."

The proposed approach, SerRecconverse-LSH, works in three steps:

  1. Offline User Indexing: Traditional LSH is used to create hash indices for each user based on their historical QoS data. This is done offline to speed up online recommendation processes.
  2. Indirect Friend Finding: Converse LSH is employed to identify "enemy" users for a target user. Based on the "enemy's enemy is a possible friend" principle from Social Balance Theory, the system then infers indirect friends for the target user. This is crucial for handling situations where direct friends are scarce due to data sparsity.
  3. Service Recommendation: Services are recommended to the target user based on the preferences of these indirectly found friends. Missing QoS data is predicted to facilitate this.

Datasets

The paper uses the Movielens dataset for evaluation. This dataset contains movie ratings from a large number of users, which the authors adapt by randomly removing entries to simulate recommendation failure scenarios.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Enemy" as a Friend: The most striking idea is leveraging users with opposing preferences ("enemies") to find potential friends. This is a clever way to circumvent the limitations of data sparsity and direct similarity, which often lead to recommendation failures.
  • Social Balance Theory for Recommendations: Applying Social Balance Theory, specifically the "enemy's enemy is a possible friend" rule, provides a theoretical foundation for inferring indirect relationships, making the approach more than just a heuristic.
  • Handling Failures for Robustness: The paper directly addresses the critical issue of recommendation failures, which are often overlooked. By proposing an explicit exception handling mechanism, they aim to significantly improve the robustness of recommender systems.
  • Privacy-Preservation through LSH: The inherent privacy-preserving nature of LSH is leveraged, meaning the proposed approach maintains this benefit without additional complex privacy mechanisms.

Key Results

The experiments, conducted on the Movielens dataset, demonstrate the effectiveness of SerRecconverse-LSH:

  • Accuracy: SerRecconverse-LSH achieved higher accuracy compared to baseline approaches like "Random," "WSRec," and "SBT-SR" in handling recommendation failures. The accuracy was also noted to be relatively stable across iterations.
  • Efficiency: The proposed approach exhibits good efficiency, comparable to simpler methods like WSRec and Random, and outperforms SBT-SR, which relies more heavily on collaborative filtering. The authors attribute this efficiency to the offline indexing step and the polynomial time complexity of the core operations.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: The study found that the accuracy of SerRecconverse-LSH is not overly sensitive to the parameters L (number of hash tables) and r (number of hash functions), suggesting a good balance in its design.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and outline future research directions:

  • Single Quality Dimension: The current approach only considers a single quality dimension (user rating). Real-world scenarios often involve multiple, weighted quality dimensions (e.g., response time, reliability, cost). The authors plan to extend their work to handle these multi-dimensional and weighted applications.
  • Diversity of Quality Values: The paper focuses on real and continuous QoS values. Future work will explore integrating diverse quality value formats, such as discrete, binary, fuzzy, and correlated values, to provide more comprehensive recommendations.
  • Context Awareness: QoS data can vary significantly based on context (e.g., invocation time, user location). The authors intend to improve their approach by incorporating contextual information.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{qi2018exception,
  author = {Lianyong Qi and Shunmei Meng and Xuyun Zhang and Ruili Wang and Xiaolong Xu and Zhili Zhou and Wanchun Dou},
  title = {{An Exception Handling Approach for Privacy-Preserving Service Recommendation Failure in a Cloud Environment}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=BlnCS4ntY8},
}
Figure