An Empirical Study on Hazardous Chemicals Risk of Urban Residents in China: Analysis of Mediating Effect and Channel Preference of Response Action Decision Model

Ziwei Wang, Yongkui Liu, Tiezhong LiuInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how urban residents in China perceive and respond to hazardous chemical risks. It reveals that while mass media is the most influential channel for risk communication, the effectiveness of information processing and threat perception varies significantly depending on whether single channels or channel combinations are used, and how demographic factors influence these pathways.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

A significant gap exists in understanding how urban populations in China process information about hazardous chemical risks and subsequently make decisions about how to respond. This lack of understanding can lead to inadequate safety measures, increased casualties, and greater property damage during chemical incidents. The paper aims to address this by developing and testing a model that explains the pathways from communication channels to response action decisions, considering the mediating roles of information processing and threat perception, and the influence of demographic characteristics.

Methods

The study employs a structural equation modeling (SEM) approach to analyze the complex relationships between variables. They developed a "Response Action Decision Model" (RADM) based on existing theories, which includes:

  • Independent Variables: Channel Preference (Mass Media, Social Media, Face-to-face communication).
  • Mediator Variables: Information Processing (exposure, concern, comprehension) and Threat Perception (possibility, seriousness, fear & unknown factors).
  • Dependent Variable: Response Action Decision (risk assessment, hazard response action search, etc.).

The researchers collected data through questionnaires and used statistical analysis, including Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA), reliability analysis, and multi-group analysis, to test their hypotheses and validate the model.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 1700 questionnaires collected from urban residents in six Chinese cities: Chongqing, Tianjin, Zhangzhou, Changzhou, Zibo, and Lanzhou. These cities were selected due to their significant presence of hazardous chemical factories. The demographic characteristics of the participants, including gender, marriage status, age, education, income, and prior hazards experience, were also collected.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mass Media Reigns Supreme: Mass media emerged as the most influential channel for communicating hazardous chemical risks, followed by social media, and then face-to-face communication.
  • Mediating Roles Matter (Sometimes): Information processing and threat perception significantly mediate the relationship between single communication channels and response action decisions, effectively amplifying the message.
  • Channel Combinations Bypass Mediators: When communication channels are combined (e.g., Mass Media + Social Media), Information Processing and Threat Perception lose their mediating role, and the combination directly influences response decisions.
  • Demographics Shape Perception: Gender and prior experience with disasters significantly moderate the impact of mass media, while other demographic factors influence the overall response decision model.
  • The "Why" Behind the Response: Understanding how individuals process information and perceive threats is crucial for predicting their response actions, highlighting the importance of tailored communication strategies.

Key Results

  • Single Channels: Information Processing and Threat Perception were found to have significant mediating effects when using Mass Media, Social Media, or Face-to-face communication individually.
  • Combined Channels: For channel combinations (Mass Media ↔ Social Media, Mass Media ↔ Face-to-face, Social Media ↔ Face-to-face), Information Processing and Threat Perception did not act as mediators; the combinations directly influenced response action decisions.
  • Channel Influence Hierarchy: Mass Media > Social Media > Face-to-face communication in terms of their impact on urban residents' response action decisions.
  • Moderating Effects: Gender and experience showed a stronger moderating effect on the Mass Media channel.
  • Model Applicability: The developed Response Action Decision Model is deemed applicable for analyzing threat perception and response decisions regarding hazardous chemicals among urban residents in China.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hypothesis Testing Nuances: While Hypothesis 1 (channels directly link to RAD) and Hypothesis 2 (channels directly link to TP) were supported, Hypothesis 3 (IP directly links to RAD) and Hypothesis 4 (IP and TP mediate in combined channels) were not supported.
  • Demographic Group Size: The paper notes that some demographic groups (e.g., widowed, very young/old) had sample sizes too small to significantly impact model accuracy, suggesting a need for larger sample sizes in future studies for these specific groups.
  • Regional Differences: While the study selected diverse cities, future research could delve deeper into the specific cultural and governmental influences on channel preference within these regions.
  • Model Refinement: The authors suggest that the RADM can be further applied and refined to study how Chinese urban residents can improve their threat perception and response actions. The study also highlights the need for more research on how to effectively communicate the serious consequences of hazardous chemical disasters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Because urban residents do not have a strong understanding of hazardous chemicals, they cannot effectively make response action decisions to ensure safety, protect lives, and reduce property damage. This paper constructs the Response Action Decision Model of hazardous chemicals, and analyzes the mediating effect of Information Processing and Threat Perception, as well as channel preferences of urban residents with different demographic characteristics. A total of 1700 questionnaires were collected in Chongqing, Tianjin, Fujian Zhangzhou, Shandong Zibo and Lanzhou, where there are significant hazardous chemicals factories. The results show that: Firstly, Information Processing and Threat Perception have significant mediating effects on the relationship between Mass Media, Social Media, Face-to-face communication and Response Action Decision in a single channel, which can effectively promote the spread effect of different channels, affecting the ways that urban residents make hazard response action decisions; secondly, Information Processing and Threat Perception do not have a mediating effect on the relationship between the channel combination of "Mass Media ↔ Social Media", "Mass Media ↔ Face-to-face communication", "Social Media ↔ Face-to-face communication" and Response Action Decision, and the channel combination can directly link to the Response Action Decision; thirdly, in terms of the extent that it affects urban residents to make response action decisions, Mass Media is greater than Social Media and greater than Face-to-face communication; fourthly, two demographic characteristics of gender and experience have a stronger moderating effect for the Mass Media channel, while other demographic characteristics have greater influences on the Response Action Decision Model; finally, the Response Action Decision Model can be better applied to those analyses and research which address threat perception of hazardous chemicals and response action decisions of urban residents in China.
BibTeX
@article{wang2021empirical,
  author = {Ziwei Wang and Yongkui Liu and Tiezhong Liu},
  title = {{An Empirical Study on Hazardous Chemicals Risk of Urban Residents in China: Analysis of Mediating Effect and Channel Preference of Response Action Decision Model}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph182010932},
}
Figure