An empirical study of DSRC V2V performance in truck platooning scenarios

Song Gao, Alvin Lim, David M. BevlyDigital 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a real-world empirical study of Dedicated Short Range Communication (DSRC) performance in truck platooning scenarios. By using actual semi-trailer trucks and commercial DSRC equipment, the study reveals how environmental factors like road curvature, terrain, and truck body orientation significantly impact communication reliability, offering crucial insights for developing robust platooning systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Truck platooning, where trucks drive in close proximity to save fuel and enhance safety, relies heavily on Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) communication, primarily using DSRC. However, understanding how DSRC performs in the complex and dynamic environment of commercial trucking is critical for its successful deployment. Previous studies often used simulations or smaller vehicles, leaving a gap in knowledge regarding DSRC's reliability under real-world truck operations, especially concerning factors like the truck's physical structure and varied road conditions. This paper aims to bridge that gap by empirically evaluating DSRC's performance in realistic truck platooning scenarios.

Methods

The researchers conducted real-world experiments using two commercial semi-trailer trucks equipped with DSRC units and antennas mounted on each side of the tractor. They employed a combination of dynamic tests (trucks driving on a test track) and static tests (trucks parked in specific configurations) to simulate various platooning conditions. Key metrics collected included delivery ratio (the percentage of messages successfully transmitted) and latency. The experiments systematically varied parameters such as data rate, message size, and message rate, while also testing different antenna configurations (left, right, and alternate) and environmental conditions (straight roads, curves, hills).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on real-world experimental data collected during their tests, rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Trucks are not just bigger cars: The physical dimensions and articulation of semi-trailer trucks significantly impact DSRC performance, especially when turning, where the trailer can block the line-of-sight for side-mounted antennas.
  • "Ideal" environments are rare: Even on seemingly straight roads, reflections from nearby terrain can degrade DSRC signal quality, leading to unexpected packet losses.
  • Antenna placement is crucial: While mounting antennas on both sides of the truck is a good strategy, their effectiveness varies greatly depending on the truck's orientation and the road's geometry.
  • Alternating antennas are a smart workaround: By switching between left and right antennas, the system can leverage the best available signal, significantly improving overall delivery ratio, particularly in challenging scenarios like curves.
  • DSRC is robust in ideal conditions: In the absence of environmental interference, DSRC can achieve near-perfect delivery ratios even at considerable distances.
  • Latency is mostly hardware/OS driven: For broadcast messages like Basic Safety Messages (BSMs), latency is primarily influenced by the underlying hardware, OS scheduler, and drivers, rather than network congestion or environmental factors, as long as the DSRC channel is clear.

Key Results

  • In ideal, open-field conditions, DSRC achieved nearly 100% delivery ratio at distances up to 78 meters, across various data rates, message sizes, and rates.
  • When a truck turns, the outside antenna's delivery ratio can drop significantly, especially at higher data rates, due to the trailer blocking the signal. The inside antenna generally performs better in these situations.
  • On straight roads with complex terrain, delivery ratios can be lower than on curves, particularly with large messages and high data rates, possibly due to reflections from the terrain.
  • Hilly roads can cause trucks to misalign, leading to reduced delivery ratios. However, terrain reflections can sometimes improve performance.
  • Using antennas alternately consistently improved delivery ratios, often achieving near 100% even in challenging scenarios.
  • Latency was generally low (under 5 ms, excluding outliers), with larger message sizes increasing latency and higher data rates decreasing it. High message rates (100 Hz) showed increased jitter, attributed to the DSRC radio's internal scheduling.

Limitations and Future Work

Limitations: * The study used commercial, proprietary DSRC hardware, meaning specific implementation details might influence results. * The experiments were conducted under specific weather conditions (lightly cloudy days), and the impact of rain or snow was not explored. * The "turning" scenario was static; dynamic turning tests might reveal different performance characteristics. * The study focused on pairwise delivery ratio for alternate antennas, which might mask individual antenna performance in certain analyses.

Future Work: The paper suggests that understanding DSRC performance in these real-world truck contexts is crucial for designing more robust applications. Further research could explore the impact of different weather conditions, more complex turning maneuvers, and the integration of DSRC with other sensing technologies for enhanced platooning safety and efficiency. Investigating the optimal antenna placement and switching strategies for various truck configurations and road types would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Among many safety applications enabled by Dedicated Short Range Communication (DSRC), truck platooning provides many incentives to commercial companies. This paper studies DSRC Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) performance in truck platooning scenarios through real-world experiments. Commercial DSRC equipments and semi-trailer trucks are used in this study. We mount one DSRC antenna on each side of the truck. One set of dynamic tests and a few sets of static tests are conducted to explore DSRC behaviors under different situations. From the test results, we verified some of our speculations. For example, hilly roads can affect delivery ratio and antennas mounted on opposite sides of a truck can suffer from low delivery ratio at curved roads. In addition, we also found that antennas can sometimes suffer from low delivery ratio even when the trucks are on straight roads, possibly due to reflections from the nearby terrain. Fortunately, the delivery ratio can be greatly improved by using the two side antennas alternately.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2016empirical,
  author = {Song Gao and Alvin Lim and David M. Bevly},
  title = {{An empirical study of DSRC V2V performance in truck platooning scenarios}},
  booktitle = {Digital},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1016/j.dcan.2016.10.003},
}
Figure