Abstract
Emotional singing can affect vocal performance and the audience's engagement. Chinese universities use traditional training techniques for teaching theoretical and applied knowledge. Self-imagination is the predominant training method for emotional singing. Recently, virtual reality (VR) technologies have been applied in several fields for training purposes. In this empirical comparative study, a VR training task was implemented to elicit emotions from singers and further assist them with improving their emotional singing performance. The VR training method was compared against the traditional self-imagination method. By conducting a two-stage experiment, the two methods were compared in terms of emotions' elicitation and emotional singing performance. In the first stage, electroencephalographic (EEG) data were collected from the subjects. In the second stage, self-rating reports and third-party teachers' evaluations were collected. The EEG data were analyzed by adopting the max-relevance and min-redundancy algorithm for feature selection and the support vector machine (SVM) for emotion recognition. Based on the results of EEG emotion classification and subjective scale, VR can better elicit the positive, neutral, and negative emotional states from the singers than not using this technology (i.e., self-imagination). Furthermore, due to the improvement of emotional activation, VR brings the improvement of singing performance. The VR hence appears to be an effective approach that may improve and complement the available vocal music teaching methods.
Introduction
In vocal music education, particularly within Chinese universities, the curriculum often emphasizes theoretical knowledge and technical vocal mechanics. While these are foundational, "emotional singing"—the ability to convey deep feeling—is what truly resonates with an audience. Traditionally, educators rely on self-imagination, a method where singers internally visualize a scene to trigger a specific emotional state. However, this approach is highly subjective and frequently fails to elicit the necessary emotional depth, resulting in technically proficient but emotionally flat performances.
This study explores whether Virtual Reality (VR) can provide a more consistent and immersive environment to elicit these emotions. By comparing VR training to traditional self-imagination, researchers aimed to determine if technology-driven emotional activation translates into superior vocal performance.
Methodology
The researchers conducted a two-stage experiment involving 16 music students (8 male, 8 female). The study utilized six songs representing three emotional states: Positive, Neutral, and Negative.
Experimental Design
- Emotion Elicitation: Participants were subjected to two conditions. In the self-imagination condition, they were guided by a teacher's verbal commentary. In the VR condition, they wore Oculus Quest 2 headsets to view 360-degree immersive videos tailored to each song's mood.
- Data Acquisition: During the elicitation phase, 64-channel wireless EEG data was recorded.
- Performance Evaluation: Following the training, students recorded one-minute singing samples. These were evaluated by five professional vocal teachers in a blind test and through student self-reports.
EEG Analysis Pipeline
The EEG data underwent rigorous processing, including source localization using sLORETA to map scalp signals to 68 cortical regions based on the ICBM152 head model. Functional connectivity was measured via Pearson correlation, and the "max-relevance and min-redundancy" (mRMR) algorithm identified the top 10 discriminative features for classification via a Support Vector Machine (SVM).
Key Results and Insights
Enhanced Emotional Activation
The study confirmed that VR acts as a powerful "emotional catalyst." SVM classification accuracy for the VR group reached 85.84% in the gamma band, outperforming the self-imagination group's 82.82%. Singers reported significantly higher levels of arousal and pleasure during VR sessions compared to traditional methods.
Brain Connectivity and Frequency Bands
The most discriminative data for emotion recognition emerged from the Beta (13–30 Hz) and Gamma (30–45 Hz) frequency bands, which are associated with high-level cognitive and emotional processing.
As shown in the connectivity maps, VR training significantly altered functional connectivity in regions like the rostral anterior cingulate (emotion regulation) and the orbitofrontal cortex (emotional expression). The study also noted distinct hemispheric asymmetry, with VR creating unique connectivity "hubs" that were absent in the self-imagination condition.
Improved Vocal Performance
Expert evaluations revealed that VR training led to measurable improvements in technical performance. Professional teachers rated the VR-trained group significantly higher in five key categories: Coherence, Breath Use, Resonance, Musicality, and Emotional Expression.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The findings suggest that VR is a highly effective tool for eliciting emotions in singers, leading to enhanced technical and emotional performance. While promising, the study notes limitations such as a small sample size and the potential for cybersickness. Future research should focus on larger cohorts and individualized brain templates to further refine emotion-recognition accuracy. Despite these hurdles, VR represents a significant advancement in vocal music pedagogy, offering a robust complement to traditional teaching methods.
Summary updated