An Elementary Proof That Symplectic Matrices Have Determinant One

Donsub Rim

Abstract: We give one more proof of the fact that symplectic matrices over real and complex fields have determinant one. While this has already been proved many times, there has been lasting interest in finding an elementary proof. Our result is restricted to the real and complex case due to its reliance on field-dependent spectral theory, however in this setting we obtain a proof which is more elementary in the sense that it is direct and requires only well-known facts. Finally, an explicit formula for the determinant of conjugate symplectic matrices in terms of its square subblocks is given.

Introduction

Symplectic matrices are fundamental objects in mathematics and physics, appearing prominently in Hamiltonian mechanics, symplectic geometry, and quantum information theory. A $2N \times 2N$ matrix $A$ is defined as symplectic if it satisfies the condition:

$$A^T JA = J$$

where $J$ is the standard skew-symmetric block matrix:

$$J = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & I_N \\ -I_N & 0 \end{pmatrix}$$

From the definition, it is straightforward to show that $(\det A)^2 = 1$, implying that $\det A = \pm 1$. However, proving that the determinant is strictly $+1$ is a classic challenge in linear algebra. Traditional proofs typically invoke advanced machinery such as the polar decomposition of $A$, the theory of Pfaffians, or topological arguments regarding the connectivity of the symplectic group $Sp(2N, \mathbb{R})$. While rigorous, these methods often obscure the underlying algebraic simplicity of the result. This paper presents a direct, elementary proof for the real and complex cases using basic spectral theory.

The Elementary Proof Strategy

The author’s approach centers on the spectral properties of positive definite matrices. The core of the proof involves examining the matrix $A^T A + I$ (or $A^* A + I$ in the complex case) rather than $A$ in isolation.

1. The Positive Definite Constraint

Because $A^T A$ is a symmetric positive definite matrix, its eigenvalues are all strictly positive. By adding the identity matrix $I$, we ensure that all eigenvalues of $A^T A + I$ are greater than 1. Consequently, the determinant $\det(A^T A + I)$ must be a strictly positive real number.

2. Block Manipulation and Unitary Transformation

The matrix $A$ is partitioned into four $N \times N$ subblocks:

$$A = \begin{pmatrix} A_{11} & A_{12} \\ A_{21} & A_{22} \end{pmatrix}$$

By applying a specific unitary transformation to the block structure, the author demonstrates that the determinant of the augmented matrix can be factored. Specifically, it is shown that:

$$\det(A^T A + I) = \det(A) \cdot |\det(C + iD)|^2$$

where $C$ and $D$ are matrices derived from the subblocks of $A$.

3. Establishing the Sign

Since $\det(A^T A + I) > 0$ and the term $|\det(C + iD)|^2$ is non-negative, the sign of $\det(A)$ is forced to be positive. Given the prior knowledge that $\det(A) \in \{1, -1\}$, the only possible value is $\det(A) = 1$. This logic elegantly converts a discrete algebraic problem into an inequality problem solvable via spectral theory.

Extension to Conjugate Symplectic Matrices

The paper further extends this logic to conjugate symplectic matrices, defined by the relation $A^* JA = J$. Unlike standard symplectic matrices, the determinants of conjugate symplectic matrices are not restricted to $\pm 1$; instead, they can lie anywhere on the complex unit circle ($|\det A| = 1$).

The author provides a new, explicit formula to determine the exact phase of this determinant based on the matrix subblocks:

$$\det(A) = \frac{\det((A_{11} + A_{22})^2 + (A_{12} - A_{21})^2 - i[A_{11} + A_{22}, A_{12} - A_{21}])}{|\det((A_{11} + A_{22})^2 + (A_{12} - A_{21})^2 - i[A_{11} + A_{22}, A_{12} - A_{21}])|}$$

This formula offers a direct computational path to the determinant that avoids the need for full matrix decomposition.

Conclusion and Limitations

The primary strength of this proof is its accessibility, requiring only the standard toolkit of a first-year graduate linear algebra course. However, this simplicity comes at the cost of generality. Because the proof relies on the spectral properties of positive definite matrices (eigenvalues), it is strictly limited to the fields of $\mathbb{R}$ and $\mathbb{C}$.

For symplectic matrices defined over finite fields or other algebraic structures where the concept of "positive definite" is not applicable, the more complex proofs involving Pfaffians remain the necessary standard. Nevertheless, for the most common applications in physics and engineering, this elementary proof provides a clearer, more intuitive path to a fundamental result.

Summary updated

Abstract

We give one more proof of the fact that symplectic matrices over real and complex fields have determinant one. While this has already been proved many times, there has been lasting interest in finding an elementary proof. Our result is restricted to the real and complex case due to its reliance on field-dependent spectral theory, however in this setting we obtain a proof which is more elementary in the sense that it is direct and requires only well-known facts. Finally, an explicit formula for the determinant of conjugate symplectic matrices in terms of its square subblocks is given.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rim2017elementary,
  author = {Donsub Rim},
  title = {{An Elementary Proof That Symplectic Matrices Have Determinant One}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.37622/adsa/12.1.2017.15-20},
}
Figure